Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 4586 (12 December 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/5416

Re:Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Skills Quality Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mark Hyman, Member

Date:12 December 2018

Place:Canberra

The conditions sought to be imposed by the respondent are refused.

Liberty to apply is preserved

........................................................................

Mark Hyman, Member

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – stay – proposal to attach conditions to stay previously granted – consequences for the public and students in the absence of the conditions sought – consequences for the applicant if the conditions were imposed – whether the tribunal has the power to grant the conditions sought – tribunal has the power – competing considerations best addressed through an expedited hearing – whether the matter might benefit from alternative dispute resolution

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 37, 41, Division 3

National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011, ss 2A, 31, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203

Cases

ASIC v AAT [2009] FCAFC 185

Scott and ASIC [2009] AATA 798

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mark Hyman, Member

12 December 2018

  1. This decision is about whether conditions can and should be attached to a stay already granted to Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd (Mantra), the applicant, in respect of the decision under review taken by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA), the respondent, to not allow a shorter period to Mantra to make an application for renewal of its registration as a Registered Training Organisation (RTO) under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (the NVR Act). It also covers the question of whether this matter may be amenable to conciliation or another alternative dispute resolution process.

  2. This is one of two matters in which Mantra is the applicant. The other is an application for review of a decision by ASQA to refuse to extend Mantra’s scope of registration as an RTO by the addition of a qualification in training and assessment. That refusal was made on 28 February 2018, and the review is matter number 2018/2442. Normal tribunal processes would have the two matters heard together. For reasons explained below that course of action will not be followed in this instance.

  3. Mantra, when applying for review of the decision in matter 2018/5416, also sought a stay of ASQA’s decision, and that application was not opposed. Under section 41 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act), a decision that is under review by the tribunal will normally continue to have effect while the review proceeds, but the section also provides that under certain circumstances a stay may be granted, preventing the decision from operating. On 26 September 2018, in response to Mantra’s application and in light of written advice from ASQA not opposing, I granted a stay.

  4. On 22 October ASQA submitted documents for the hearing in respect of this matter, and also sought that matters 2018/2442 and 2018/5416 should be delinked…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd and Australian Skill... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4586
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) between Mantra Training and Development Pty Ltd (Mantra) and the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA). The dispute arose from ASQA's decision not to allow Mantra a shorter period to make an application for renewal of its registration, a decision made under section 31 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (NVR Act). Mantra sought a review of this decision, and a stay had previously been granted on 26 September 2018, allowing Mantra's registration to continue pending the review. ASQA subsequently sought to attach conditions to this stay.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it possessed the power to grant the conditions sought by ASQA. This question arose due to the nature of ASQA's original decision, which was to refuse a shorter period for a renewal application, but which ASQA argued had the same practical effect as denying renewal of registration. The Tribunal was required to consider the competing interests of Mantra, its students, potential students, the general public, and ASQA itself, in determining whether to impose conditions on the existing stay.

The Tribunal, constituted by Member Mark Hyman, reasoned that the power to grant a stay under subsection 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) requires consideration of various factors, including the prospects of success, the consequences for the applicant and respondent, the public interest, and whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory without a stay. While the initial stay was granted unopposed, taking into account the nugatory effect on Mantra's review application if refused, ASQA's subsequent submissions highlighted the public interest and ASQA's functional responsibilities. The Tribunal found that the interests affected by the decision and the stay were broad, encompassing Mantra, its students, and the public. Drawing on the Full Federal Court's decision in *ASIC v AAT* [2009] FCAFC 185, the Tribunal concluded that the nature of the decision under review informed the interests to be considered. Crucially, the Tribunal determined that it did indeed have the power to impose the conditions sought by ASQA, as the effect of the decision under review was to bring Mantra's registration and services to an end, and the stay without conditions risked allowing students to enrol in courses they might not complete.

The Tribunal found that it had the power to impose the conditions sought by ASQA. It also noted that Mantra appeared agreeable to an expedited hearing, and that a conciliation might be helpful given Mantra's view that ASQA's decision was based on inaccurate information. However, the Tribunal also observed that Mantra's submission regarding more generous treatment of another company had no bearing on the merits of its own case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The submission from Mantra was evidently prepared without the benefit of legal advice. It suggests that a conciliation might be helpful in that ASQA has taken a decision on the basis of information that in Mantra’s view is inaccurate; but it makes no argument that relates to the power of the tribunal to make the orders sought. Mantra points to another company that has received treatment that is regarded as more generous than that afforded to Mantra; but that has no bearing on the merits of Mantra’s case and is not something I can take into account. It appears that Mantra is agreeable to an expedited hearing.CONSIDERATION The decision not to allow a shorter period for Mantra to make an application for renewal of its registration was made under section 31 of the NVR Act; it is a reviewable decision under section 199 of the NVR Act. The letter at T14 advising Mantra of the decision states that the decision was made by the Chief Commissioner of ASQA, and under subsection 203(2) of the NVR Act the decision is therefore reviewable by this tribunal. The effect of the stay granted on 26 September 2018 is that Mantra’s registration continues pending the review of ASQA’s decision. A stay may be granted where the tribunal “is of the opinion that it is desirable to do so”, taking into account relevant interests, “for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review” (subsection 41(2) of the AAT Act). In Scott and ASIC [2009] AATA 798 Downes J, then President of the tribunal, set out (at [4]) a non-exhaustive list of considerations which go to the question of whether to grant a stay: 1. The prospects of success.2. The consequence for the applicant of the refusal of a stay.3. The public interest.4. The consequences for the respondent in carrying out its functions depending upon whether a stay is granted or not. 5. Whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory if a stay were not granted. 6. Other matters that are relevant … [including the time that is likely to elapse before the matter is heard]. The stay application by Mantra was not opposed by ASQA, and the stay was granted on that basis, taking into account especially the second and fifth of the above points: the consequences of refusing the stay would be that Mantra would be unable to continue operations, and the application for review would indeed be rendered nugatory as a consequence. The submissions that ASQA now makes suggests that the conditions sought would balance those considerations with regard in particular to the third and fourth of the above points: as noted in ASQA’s submission, there are consequences for students, for the general public and therefore for ASQA in the carrying out of its functions if Mantra is allowed to continue operations but is then unsuccessful in the review. The question of the tribunal’s powers to impose the conditions sought only arises because of the apparently narrow ambit of the power exercised by ASQA in the decision under review: it is a decision not to allow a shorter period in which to receive an application. But ASQA points out, reasonably, that the effect of the decision is the same as the effect of a decision to deny renewal of registration. ASQA’s submission takes me, helpfully, to ASIC v AAT [2009] FCAFC 185 (ASIC v AAT), where the full Federal Court noted that the interests of those affected by a review, which are to be taken into account in a stay decision, will be affected by the nature of the decision under review, in accordance with the statutory scheme under which the decision was made. The effect of the decision in this instance, in the absence of a stay, would be to bring Mantra’s registration, and therefore its education and training services, to an end; the effect of the stay without the proposed conditions would be to allow students to enrol in courses that they might not be able to complete. The interests affected will indeed include those of Mantra, its students and potential students, the general public, and ASQA itself; and there is no question that the tribunal indeed has the power to impose the conditions that ASQA seeks.