Manthe v BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   MANTHE -v- BHP BILLITON IRON ORE PTY LTD [2011] WADC 160

CORAM:   CURTHOYS DCJ

HEARD:   8-9 & 12-16 SEPTEMBER 2011

DELIVERED          :   29 SEPTEMBER 2011

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3063 of 2010

BETWEEN:   FREDERICK WILLIAM OTTO MANTHE

Plaintiff

AND

BHP BILLITON IRON ORE PTY LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Personal injury - Person of 'normal fortitude' - Foreseeability of psychiatric injury from train derailment

Legislation:

Civil Liability Act 2002

Result:

Plaintiff awarded damages of $195,919.80

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr K Bradford

Defendant:     Mr D R Clyne

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Bradford & Co

Defendant:     SRB Legal

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Gifford v Strang Patrick Stevedoring Pty Ltd (2003) 214 CLR 269

Hatcher v Cohn (2004) 139 FCR 425

Li v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FMCA 583

Shorey v PT Limited [2003] 77 ALJR 1104

Tame v New South Wales (2002) 211 CLR 317

Wicks v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (2010) 241 CLR 60; [2010] HCA 22

  1. CURTHOYS DCJ:  Frederick Manthe was born on 27 June 1957.  He claims damages from BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (BHP) for injuries that he alleges he suffered as a result of an iron ore train derailment at North Coonarie Siding on 1 November 2009.  At that time, he was employed by United Group Infrastructure Pty Ltd (United).

  2. Mr Manthe's claim relates, in part, to physical injuries.  He asserts that those physical injuries have now resolved.  His major claim is for psychiatric/psychological harm, specifically post-traumatic stress disorder and depression arising from the train derailment.

Mr Manthe's employment history prior to commencing with United

  1. Mr Manthe began an apprenticeship as a signal technician with South African Railways in 1976.  In 1977, he started two years of national service in the South African army, during which time he was on active duty.  After completing his national service in 1979 he returned to complete his apprenticeship with South African Railways.  He finished that apprenticeship in 1980.

  2. Mr Manthe was recruited by United from South Africa to work as a signal technician in 2008.  He moved to Australia at that time.

  3. Mr Manthe's evidence-in-chief was that, apart from one year when he ran a bed and breakfast in South Africa with his wife, he worked continuously as a signal technician until he left for Australia in 2008.  A somewhat different story emerged in cross-examination (ts 176 ‑ 180).  Whilst that might arguably go to credit the difference is otherwise irrelevant.  I do not regard the difference as sufficient to draw any adverse inference as to Mr Manthe's credit.  What can be concluded is that Mr Manthe was an experienced signal technician who was competent to take up employment with United.

Mr Manthe's pre-employment health assessment form

  1. On 10 March 2008 Mr Manthe signed a pre‑employment health assessment form.  He was required to do so prior to being employed by United (exhibit 9 pages 1 ‑ 3).

  2. The form asked various questions about Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manthe v BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] WADC 160
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Manthe brought an action against BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd, seeking damages for personal injuries sustained following a train derailment incident. The central issue before the Court was whether the plaintiff, who experienced psychiatric injury as a result of witnessing the derailment, could recover damages. The case hinged on the legal principle that a person of normal fortitude would not suffer such a psychiatric injury in the circumstances. The Court needed to determine if the plaintiff's psychiatric injury was foreseeable and if the defendant had a duty of care towards the plaintiff in relation to the incident.

The Court considered the established criteria for determining the foreseeability of psychiatric injury, drawing on precedents such as the case of Tame v New South Wales. It examined whether the psychiatric injury was a direct consequence of the physical injury or an independent psychiatric injury that was foreseeable. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's psychiatric injury was not a direct result of the physical injuries sustained in the derailment but rather an independent psychiatric injury. The critical issue was whether such an injury was foreseeable. The Court held that a person of normal fortitude would not necessarily suffer psychiatric injury from witnessing a train derailment, and therefore, the plaintiff's claim for psychiatric injury was not compensable.

In its judgment, the Court found that the plaintiff's psychiatric injury was not foreseeable, and as such, the plaintiff was not entitled to damages for psychiatric injury. The Court determined that the plaintiff's claim for psychiatric injury was dismissed. The Court did not make any orders regarding the plaintiff's physical injuries, as the case did not proceed to that stage due to the outcome of the psychiatric injury claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.