JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: COMMERCIAL & CIVIL
ACT: BUILDERS' REGISTRATION ACT 1939 (WA)
CITATION: MANOR ROOF RESTORATION and MARGIESON [2009] WASAT 197
MEMBER: DR B DE VILLIERS (MEMBER)
HEARD: 15 SEPTEMBER 2009
DELIVERED : 13 OCTOBER 2009
FILE NO/S: CC 1002 of 2009
BETWEEN: MANOR ROOF RESTORATION
Applicant
AND
CAROL MARGIESON
Respondent
Catchwords:
Review of decision - Grounds for review - Submission of new evidence during application for review - Difference between fresh evidence and new evidence - New evidence is evidence that could have been made available at the time of the hearing - Fresh evidence is evidence that was not available at the time of the hearing - Failure of a party to attend proceedings or to make submissions - Reliance of a party on the report of an inspector
Legislation:
Builders' Registration Act 1939 (WA), s 41(1)
Result:
The application for leave to review the decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal is dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Mr Roope (Representative)
Respondent: Self-represented
Solicitors:
Applicant: Manor Roof Restoration
Respondent: Self-represented
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Devereaux‑Warnes v Hall [2006] WASCA 268
Manor Roof Restoration and Margieson [2009] WASAT 194
Tangent Nominees Pty Ltd and Edwards [2005] WASAT 119
Wilson v Metaxas [1989] WAR 285
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
Manor Roof Restoration sought a review of a decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal to pay an amount of $12,000 to Ms Margieson for the fixing of leaks in her roof and to repair damage that was caused by the leaks.
Manor Roof Restoration contended that the decision was made in their absence; that the members of the Building Disputes Tribunal were not experts in roof restoration; that the work could be done much cheaper and that the leaks were caused by gutters and downpipes not being properly cleaned. They further contended that the report of the inspector should have been accepted.
Ms Margieson contended that Manor Roof Restoration should have made their submissions and evidence to the Building Disputes Tribunal. The Tribunal, according to Ms Margieson, acted on the basis of the submissions and evidence before it when it came to its decision. The Building Disputes Tribunal accepted her evidence that she had cleaned the gutters regularly. There was no reason why the decision should be reopened and new evidence submitted due to the failure of Manor Roof Restoration or their subcontractor to participate in the earlier proceedings.
The Tribunal found that the Building Disputes Tribunal acted properly, that it considered all the evidence before it and there was no reason why the decision should be re-opened. It acted on the basis of the submissions and evidence before it; it adjourned proceedings to enable Manor Roof Restoration to participate; and that no breaches of the rules of natural justice had occurred. The Tribunal emphasises that there were important public policy considerations to bring litigation to finality and that if anyone is to blame for any potential inadequacies in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MANOR ROOF RESTORATION and MARGIESON and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASAT 197
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the tribunal needed to resolve were whether the BDT had jurisdiction to make the decision it did, whether the decision was procedurally fair, and whether the evidence presented to the BDT was sufficient to justify its findings. Manor Roof contended that the BDT should have accepted the inspector's report and that the BDT members lacked the qualifications to make certain findings. They also argued that the amount awarded for repairs was excessive and that new evidence, which they proposed to present during the review, would show that the repairs could be done more cheaply and that the damage was due to blocked gutters and downpipes. The tribunal had to assess the validity of these arguments and determine if the new evidence presented constituted fresh evidence that was not available at the time of the BDT hearing or if it was merely new evidence that could have been produced earlier.
The tribunal concluded that the BDT's decision was procedurally fair and that the tribunal had no jurisdiction to review the decision on the grounds presented. It found that the new evidence Manor Roof intended to present was not fresh evidence but rather new evidence that could have been produced during the original BDT hearing. As such, the tribunal dismissed the application for leave to review and affirmed the BDT's decision. The tribunal emphasised that the process for review was clear and that additional evidence could only be submitted if leave to review was granted. Given that leave was denied, the matter was concluded with the BDT's decision standing.
In conclusion, the tribunal upheld the BDT's decision and dismissed Manor Roof's application for leave to review. The tribunal found no grounds for review based on the arguments presented and confirmed that the new evidence Manor Roof intended to present did not qualify as fresh evidence. The tribunal's decision was final, and no further submissions regarding the merits of the case were to be considered.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Manor Roof Restoration (Manor Roof) also sought a stay of the decision of the BDT. The application for stay of the Order to Pay was dismissed on 6 October 2009 in matter Manor Roof Restoration and Margieson [2009] WASAT 194. The hearing for the stay and review were combined on 15 September 2009. The review application continued on 6 October 2009. Mr Roope participated for Manor Roof via telephone from the United Kingdom; Ms Margieson was present and so was Mr Milbourne who did the building work for Manor Roof. The parties made oral submissions and gave evidence at the same time. Mr Roope made a further written submission, dated 5 October 2009, in which he summarised the concerns with the BDT decision which he had expressed during the review hearing. The parties each made a summary of their position at the final hearing on 6 October 2009. The parties were self-represented. The Tribunal allowed the process of oral submissions and evidence for the application for stay and the application for leave to review to be combined, on the basis that the parties expressed their desire to bring matters to a close and get finality about their respective rights. The parties were therefore satisfied that they had made available to the Tribunal all information known in regard to both the stay and the review applications. The Tribunal explained to the parties that the application for leave to review the decision of the BDT will be progressed in two phases. The first step is aimed solely on the question whether leave to review should be granted. If leave is granted, the parties will be invited to make further submissions regarding the merit of the matter and the hearing will be de novo. If leave is refused, the matter is concluded. It is only when leave is granted that additional evidence and information that were not before the BDT may be submitted to the Tribunal. After conclusion of the hearing, the Tribunal offered the parties an opportunity to meet in mediation under the chairmanship of one of its sessional members, Mr Mouchemore, who is an expert in building matters. The mediation took place on 2 October 2009, but the dispute did not settle. The Tribunal reserved its decision on 6 October 2009. Ground for review Manor Roof, supported by Mr Milbourne who was the subcontractor, in summary contends as follows in support of its application for leave to review the decision of the BDT:•Manor Roof and Mr Milbourne were not present at the hearing of the BDT and they were being punished by the BDT for the non-attendance.•They relied on the report and findings of the building inspector instructed by the BDT, and the BDT should have accepted the inspector's report.•The BDT members did not have adequate qualifications to make a finding of this nature in regard to roof reparation.•The amount awarded to fix the problem far exceeds the original contract sum.•The leakage was either caused, or was contributed to, due to blocked gutters and downpipes and this was not taken into account by the BDT.•New evidence to be produced at the hearing will show that the work can be done much cheaper than the amount awarded by the BDT. The new evidence will also support the contention that the damage was caused by uncleaned gutters and downpipes.•The BDT should have accepted the report of their inspector who emphasised that the blocked gutters and downpipes contributed to the leaks and damages.•The company's standing amongst its peers has been diminished by the finding.