Manitowoc Foodservice Companies LLC.

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

DESIGNS ACT 2003

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS WITH REASONS

Re:Design Registration Nos. 338258 and 338260 in the name of Manitowoc Foodservice Companies LLC. and examination thereof.

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Owner:   Alison McMillan of IP Gateway, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Decision:

2013 ADO 2
Section 63 request for examination: design not distinctive; registrar satisfied that a ground of revocation has been made out. Examination taken to have been completed.

Background

  1. This matter came before me because Manitowoc Foodservice Companies LLC. (‘the Owner’) had requested to be heard in relation to matters raised during examination of its design registration nos. 338258 (‘Design A’) and 338260 (‘Design B’) (together, ‘the Designs’ or ‘the Registrations’). 

  2. Following examination, the Designs were found not to be distinctive because they were said to be substantially similar in overall impression to design(s) published before the priority date of the Registrations.

  3. The Owner asked to be heard and was represented at the hearing, which took place by telephone on 4 March 2013, by Alison McMillan of IP Gateway, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys.

Examination

  1. Applications were filed under the Designs Act 2003 (“the Act”) on 1 August 2011 claiming, in the case of Design A, Convention priority from US Design Patent 29/385,247, and in the case of Design B, Convention priority from US Design Patent 29/385, 259, both filed 10 February 2011 (the ‘priority date’) to register the Designs shown below in relation to products in each case described as an  “Ice Machine”.

Design A

Design B

  1. The Designs were duly registered and the Owner requested examination under section 63(1) of the Act. An examiner was appointed to determine whether the Designs were new and distinctive when compared with material in the public domain before the priority date.

  2. First examination reports issued on both Designs on 21 November 2011.  The examiner alleged that Design B was not new and distinctive in view of United States Design Patent No. D394,270 issued 12 May 1998 also for an ice making machine (‘Prior Disclosure A’) and registered by what appears to be a company related to the Owner, Manitowoc Foodservice Group Inc.  An image of Prior Disclosure A is shown below. 

    Prior Disclosure A

  3. The examiner alleged that Design A was not new and distinctive in view of Prior Disclosure A and Australian Design No. 335222 (‘Prior Disclosure B’), shown below.

    Prior Disclosure B

  4. The issue is whether or not the Designs are substantially similar in overall impression to the prior disclosures.

Legislative framework

  1. Under section 65(2)(a), examination requires the Registrar to consider whether a registration should be revoked because it does not relate to a registrable design. Section 15(1) of the Act states that a design is a registrable design if it is new and distinctive when compared with the prior art base for the design as it existed before the priority date of the design.

10. Section 16 of the Act provides that a design is new unless it is identical to a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manitowoc Foodservice Companies LLC. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ADO 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Manitowoc Foodservice Companies LLC. sought to have design registration nos. 338258 and 338260, which relate to ice machine designs, examined by the Registrar of Designs. The primary issue was whether these designs were distinctive, as they were found to be substantially similar to prior disclosures. Specifically, Design A was compared to US Design Patent No. D394,270 and Australian Design No. 335222, while Design B was compared to US Design Patent No. D394,270 alone. The crux of the matter hinged on whether these prior designs and the current designs were substantially similar in overall impression.

The legal framework for determining the distinctiveness of a design is provided under the Designs Act 2003. Section 15(1) stipulates that a design is registrable if it is new and distinctive when compared to the prior art base. Section 16 elaborates on what constitutes a new design, and Section 16(2) explains that a design is distinctive unless it is substantially similar in overall impression to prior art. Section 19 provides specific factors to consider when assessing substantial similarity, including the state of development of the prior art base, the importance of particular visual features, and the degree of freedom of the designer to innovate.

The Delegate considered the submissions and the evidence presented by the Owner, including the views of an informed user, Mr Van Der Drift. The Owner argued that the designs were distinctive due to differences in the shape of the ventilation fins and the presence of a temperature monitor panel. However, the Delegate found these differences to be insufficient to overcome the substantial similarity in overall impression. In particular, the curved fins of Design B were not deemed to be of significant importance, and the presence of the temperature monitor panel, although visually notable, did not sufficiently alter the overall impression to make the design distinctive.

Ultimately, the Delegate concluded that both Design A and Design B were substantially similar in overall impression to the prior art and therefore were not new and distinctive. Consequently, the Delegate ordered that the design registrations be revoked. This decision aligns with the Delegate's earlier findings in a similar case involving the same type of product.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.