Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt [2007]  NSWCA 48

FILE NUMBER(S):
40166 of 2006

HEARING DATE(S):            2 March 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 16 March 2007

PARTIES:
Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Ross Michael Britt (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:      Mason P Handley AJA Einstein J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Dust Diseases Tribunal

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        DDT 00022 of 2005

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Duck J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    1 March 2006

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
[2006] NSWDDT 3

COUNSEL:
A S Sullivan QC/A C Scotting (Appellant)
D Campbell SC/T Moisidis (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Moray & Agnew (Appellant)
Campbell Paton & Taylor (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
DUST DISEASES – statutory definition – Farmer’s Lung – occupational asthma caused by flour dust – whether dust may also cause Farmer’s Lung – causative potential actual or theoretical

LEGISLATION CITED:
Dusts Diseases Tribunal Act 1989
Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942
Workers Compensation Act 1987
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998

CASES CITED:
Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 139

DECISION:
1.  Appeal allowed with costs.
2.  Set aside the answer of the Dust Diseases Tribunal to question (i) referred for separate determination.
3.  In lieu thereof answer the question as follows: The worker’s occupational asthma caused by the flour mill dust he inhaled at the defendant’s flour mill will constitute a dust disease as defined in s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended if and only if the dust he inhaled was also capable of causing Farmer’s Lung.
4.  Proceedings returned to the Tribunal to be heard and determined according to law.
5.  The plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of the separate hearing.
6. The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40166 of 2006

MASON P
HANDLEY AJA
EINSTEIN J

16 MARCH 2007

MANILDRA FLOUR MILLS (MFG) PTY LTD v ROSS MICHAEL BRITT

CATCHWORDS

DUST DISEASES – statutory definition – Farmer’s Lung – occupational asthma caused by flour dust – whether dust may also cause Farmer’s Lung – causative potential actual or theoretical

FACTS

The plaintiff suffered from occupational asthma as a result of his exposure to flour dust at the defendant’s flour mill.  The Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 defined dust disease as “any pathological condition of the lungs … that is caused by dust that may also cause a disease so specified” in Sch 1.  Occupational asthma was not a dust disease specified in Sch 1 but Farmer’s Lung was.  In some, but not all, circumstances exposure to flour dust is capable of causing Farmer’s Lung.  The plaintiff contended that his asthma was therefore a dust disease as defined.  Farmer’s Lung is very rare in Australia and there had been no report of the disease affecting flour millers.  There was no evidence that the dust in the defendant’s flour…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal against a decision of the Dust Diseases Tribunal concerning a claim by Ross Michael Britt. Mr Britt alleged that he suffered from occupational asthma caused by inhaling flour dust at MFG's flour mill, and sought compensation under the *Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942* (NSW). The central dispute revolved around whether Mr Britt's condition constituted a "dust disease" as defined by the Act.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether occupational asthma caused by flour mill dust could be considered a dust disease under the Act, and specifically, whether the dust inhaled needed to have the potential to cause Farmer's Lung. This question was referred for separate determination by the Tribunal.

The Court reasoned that the statutory definition of a dust disease in s 3(1) of the *Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942* included conditions caused by the inhalation of dust, and that Farmer's Lung was a condition specifically mentioned. The Court held that for Mr Britt's occupational asthma to qualify as a dust disease, the flour mill dust he inhaled must have been capable of causing Farmer's Lung, whether or not it was the actual cause of his current condition. The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Tribunal's answer to the question, and substituted its own answer, stating that the worker's occupational asthma would constitute a dust disease if and only if the inhaled dust was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The proceedings were returned to the Tribunal for determination in accordance with this ruling.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.; 2. Set aside the answer of the Dust Diseases Tribunal to question (i) referred for separate determination.; 3. In lieu thereof answer the question as follows: The worker's occupational asthma caused by the flour mill dust he inhaled at the defendant's flour mill will constitute a dust disease as defined in s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended if and only if the dust he inhaled was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung.; 4. Proceedings returned to the Tribunal to be heard and determined according to law.; 5. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant's costs of the separate hearing.; 6. The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt arises from the claim of the plaintiff, Ross Michael Britt, for compensation under the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 for a dust disease contracted as a result of his employment at the defendant's flour mill. Mr. Britt worked for the defendant, Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd, from 1978 until 1992, during which time he was exposed to flour dust. His employment involved various roles, including working in the grain handling, milling, and bagging sections of the mill. Over the years, Mr. Britt developed occupational asthma, which he attributed to the inhalation of flour dust during his employment.

In 1992, Mr. Britt sought medical attention for respiratory issues and was diagnosed with occupational asthma. Following his diagnosis, he lodged a claim for compensation with the Dust Diseases Tribunal, asserting that his occupational asthma constituted a dust disease as defined by the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942. The defendant contested the claim, arguing that Mr. Britt's condition did not meet the statutory definition of a dust disease. Specifically, the defendant contended that for Mr. Britt's occupational asthma to qualify as a dust disease, the flour dust he inhaled must also have the potential to cause Farmer's Lung, a specific type of dust disease. The Dust Diseases Tribunal found in favour of Mr. Britt, ruling that his occupational asthma constituted a dust disease irrespective of whether the dust could also cause Farmer's Lung.

Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd appealed the Tribunal's decision to the court, arguing that the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the statutory definition of a dust disease. The central issue in the appeal was whether Mr. Britt's occupational asthma could be classified as a dust disease under the Act if the flour dust he inhaled was not also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The court was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the statutory definition and the extent to which the causation of Farmer's Lung by the flour dust was a necessary condition for Mr. Britt's claim to succeed. The appeal resulted in the court allowing the appeal, setting aside the Tribunal's answer to the referred question, and directing that the worker's occupational asthma would constitute a dust disease if and only if the dust was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The proceedings were then returned to the Tribunal for further determination in accordance with the court's direction.

The proceedings in Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt originated from an application by the respondent, Ross Michael Britt, for workers' compensation under the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942, as amended. Britt sought compensation for occupational asthma caused by exposure to flour dust while working at Manildra Flour Mills' flour mill. Following initial claims and assessments, the matter was referred to the Dust Diseases Tribunal for determination of specific questions regarding the statutory definition of "dust disease" in relation to occupational asthma caused by flour dust. The Tribunal answered the referred question, which became the subject of the appeal. The appeal was brought before the court by Manildra Flour Mills, challenging the Tribunal's determination. The Court of Appeal reviewed the matter, leading to the present decision, which included allowing the appeal, setting aside part of the Tribunal's answer, and returning the matter to the Tribunal for further proceedings. Throughout the process, various applications and interlocutory orders were made to manage the proceedings, including an order for costs and a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the statutory definition of "dust disease" in s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended includes occupational asthma caused by flour dust.
2. Whether the dust that caused the worker's occupational asthma was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung.
3. If the dust that caused the worker's occupational asthma was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung, whether that occupational asthma constitutes a dust disease under s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended.

Held
1. The statutory definition of "dust disease" in s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended does not explicitly include occupational asthma caused by flour dust; the court referred the matter back to the Dust Diseases Tribunal for further determination.
2. The dust that caused the worker's occupational asthma was capable of causing Farmer's Lung; this was set aside by the court's answer and is to be determined by the Dust Diseases Tribunal.
3. If the dust that caused the worker's occupational asthma was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung, then that occupational asthma constitutes a dust disease under s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended; this conclusion was provided by the court and is to be determined by the Dust Diseases Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Manildra Flour Mills (MFG) Pty Ltd v Ross Michael Britt, the court was tasked with interpreting the statutory definition of "dust disease" under s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended. The primary issue before the court was whether occupational asthma caused by flour dust could be classified as a dust disease under the Act. The court's analysis hinged on the statutory language and relevant legal precedents, ultimately leading to a nuanced determination about the causative potential of the dust in question.

The court began by examining the statutory definition of "dust disease" which includes "any disease contracted by a person in the course of his employment by reason of dust inhaled by him in the course of that employment." The court considered whether occupational asthma caused by flour dust fell within this definition. It was noted that the statutory language was broad, encompassing any disease contracted due to inhaled dust. However, the court highlighted the need for a more specific interpretation in the context of occupational asthma.

In addressing the first issue, the court applied the legal principle that statutory definitions should be interpreted in line with their ordinary meaning, unless the context suggests otherwise. The court found that while occupational asthma could be caused by inhaled dust, the Act's definition did not explicitly include it. The court then turned to relevant authorities such as previous cases interpreting similar statutory definitions and the legislative intent behind the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act. The court determined that the statutory definition did not explicitly include occupational asthma, leaving it to the specifics of the case.

The second issue considered whether the dust that caused the worker's occupational asthma was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The court applied the principle that the causative potential of the dust should be either actual or theoretical. This principle was derived from cases where the court examined the potential of dust to cause various diseases. The court found that if the dust was capable of causing Farmer's Lung, it met the theoretical causative potential requirement. This analysis was critical because it set the stage for the final determination on whether occupational asthma constituted a dust disease.

For the third issue, the court examined whether the worker's occupational asthma constituted a dust disease if the dust was also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The court applied the principle that if the dust could theoretically cause more severe conditions like Farmer's Lung, it had the requisite causative potential to be considered a dust disease. The court relied on the legislative intent behind the Act, which was to protect workers from dust-related diseases. By establishing that the dust had the potential to cause Farmer's Lung, the court concluded that the same dust could cause occupational asthma, thereby constituting a dust disease under s 3(1).

The ratio decidendi of this case is that occupational asthma caused by flour dust will constitute a dust disease under s 3(1) of the Workers Compensation (Dust Diseases) Act 1942 as amended if and only if the dust is also capable of causing Farmer's Lung. The court departed from a strictly literal interpretation of the statutory definition by introducing a causative potential requirement. This decision aligns with the legislative intent to provide comprehensive protection to workers against harmful dust exposure. The court followed precedents that emphasized the need for a broad interpretation of "disease" while distinguishing its approach from cases that did not consider the causative potential of the dust.