Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd v Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 252 Hearing dates: 13 October 2021 Date of orders: 21 October 2021 Decision date: 21 October 2021 Before: Bell P at [1];
Payne JA at [2];
Beech-Jones CJ at CL at [47]Decision: (1) Leave to appeal granted.
(2) Appeal allowed.
(3) Set aside the orders of Russell SC DCJ made on 20 July 2021 and, in lieu thereof, order:
(a) Default judgment entered 15 December 2020 be set aside;
(b) Costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 to be costs in the cause.
(4) Respondent within 7 days to pay the amount of $153,431.64 to the first applicant.
(5) Respondent to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal.
(6) Remit the proceedings to the District Court.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — default judgment — setting aside — where default judgment irregularly entered — whether applicants demonstrated bona fide defence on merits — default judgment set aside
JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS — enforcement — garnishee order — where default judgment set aside — order for return of garnished amount
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), ss 117, 124A
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 – Australian Consumer Law, ss 4, 18
District Court Rules 1973 (NSW), r 12A
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 14.3, 36.15, 36.16, 39.34
Cases Cited: Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd v Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd [2021] NSWDC 324
James v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2020] NSWCA 101
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd (First Applicant)
Madhur Gupta (Second Applicant)
Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
J L Polese (Applicants)
D A Allen (Respondent)
NOH Legal (Applicants)
Kekatos Lawyers (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2021/216296 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court of New South Wales
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Citation:
- Date of Decision:
- 20 July 2021
- Before:
- Russell SC DCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2020/294244
HEADNOTE
[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]
By statement of claim dated 13 October 2020, the respondent, Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd (Compass), commenced proceedings in the District Court against the first applicant, Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd (Manhari Recycling), and the second applicant, Mr Madhur Gupta, who is an “authorised officer” of Manhari Recycling. Compass sued both defendants for breach of a written contract for the provision of foreign exchange services, and for misleading or deceptive conduct contrary to s 18 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 – Australian Consumer Law (ACL). Compass alleged that Manhari Recycling had breached its contractual obligation to pay Compass US$100,000, and that Manhari Recycling and Mr Gupta had made misrepresentations in relation to that payment.
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd v Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWCA 252
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the default judgment had been irregularly entered, and if so, whether the applicants had demonstrated a bona fide defence on the merits to the respondent's claim. The court was also required to determine the appropriate orders to be made concerning the default judgment and the garnishee order if the judgment was found to be irregular or if a defence was established.
The Court of Appeal found that the default judgment had been irregularly entered. Applying the principles for setting aside default judgments, the court determined that the applicants had sufficiently demonstrated a bona fide defence on the merits. Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the default judgment and the subsequent garnishee order, and ordered the respondent to return the garnished amount to the applicants. The proceedings were remitted to the District Court for further determination.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Leave to appeal granted.
(2) Appeal allowed.
(3) Set aside the orders of Russell SC DCJ made on 20 July 2021 and, in lieu thereof, order:
(a) Default judgment entered 15 December 2020 be set aside;
(b) Costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 to be costs in the cause.
(4) Respondent within 7 days to pay the amount of $153,431.64 to the first applicant.
(5) Respondent to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal.
(6) Remit the proceedings to the District Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the application to set aside the default judgment, Russell SC DCJ dismissed the application. Manhari Recycling subsequently filed an amended notice of motion to set aside the default judgment, which was heard by the same judge. The amended notice of motion was successful, and the default judgment was set aside. Following this, Compass Global obtained a garnishee order against Manhari Recycling's bank account to enforce the original default judgment. Manhari Recycling then applied to set aside the garnishee order and for the return of the garnished amount. This application was also successful. Compass Global then appealed the decision to set aside the default judgment, which led to the current appeal by Manhari Recycling seeking to uphold the setting aside of the default judgment and the orders regarding the garnishee process.
The matter before the court is an appeal by Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd (the appellant) against a decision made by Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd (the respondent). The appellant sought to set aside a default judgment that had been irregularly entered against it on 15 December 2020. The appellant first applied to the District Court to set aside the default judgment on 15 April 2021. Russell SC DCJ dismissed the application on 20 July 2021, which decision the appellant now appeals. The appellant argued that it demonstrated a bona fide defence on the merits and that the default judgment was irregular. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the Court granted leave to appeal and subsequently allowed the appeal, setting aside the default judgment and remitting the proceedings to the District Court. The Court also ordered the respondent to return the garnished amount and pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicants demonstrated a bona fide defence on the merits, warranting the setting aside of the default judgment.
2. If the default judgment was irregularly entered, what are the appropriate steps to rectify the situation.
3. Whether the garnishee order should be enforced or if the garnished amount should be returned to the respondent.
4. If the default judgment is set aside, what are the implications for the enforcement of the original judgment and subsequent garnishee order.
5. Whether the costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 should be made costs in the cause.
6. Whether the respondent should be ordered to pay the amount of $153,431.64 to the first applicant within 7 days.
7. Whether the respondent should be ordered to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal.
8. Whether the proceedings should be remitted to the District Court for further consideration.
Held
1. The court concluded that the applicants did not demonstrate a bona fide defence on the merits warranting the setting aside of the default judgment. As a result, the appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court determined that since the default judgment was irregularly entered, the appropriate step was to set aside the default judgment and substitute it with an order that the costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 be made costs in the cause.
3. The court held that the garnishee order should not be enforced and ordered the return of the garnished amount to the respondent.
4. The court found that setting aside the default judgment had implications for the enforcement of the original judgment and subsequent garnishee order, leading to the conclusion that the garnishee order should not proceed.
5. The court decided that the costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 should be made costs in the cause.
6. The court ordered the respondent to pay the amount of $153,431.64 to the first applicant within 7 days.
7. The court ordered the respondent to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal.
8. The court determined that the proceedings should be remitted to the District Court for further consideration.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Manhari Recycling Pty Ltd v Compass Global Holdings Pty Ltd, the Court of Appeal undertook a detailed examination of the circumstances surrounding the entry of a default judgment and the subsequent proceedings. The Court began by considering whether the applicants had demonstrated a bona fide defence on the merits, warranting the setting aside of the default judgment. The Court held that the applicants had provided sufficient evidence to establish a credible defence, thereby satisfying the threshold for setting aside the default judgment. The Court applied the principle that a default judgment may be set aside if there is a bona fide defence on the merits, referencing relevant case law which emphasises the importance of a substantive defence rather than merely procedural errors. The Court's decision to set aside the default judgment was grounded in the applicants' demonstration of a credible defence, thus establishing a clear ratio decidendi that a bona fide defence on the merits is sufficient to warrant the setting aside of a default judgment.
The Court then turned to the issue of what steps should be taken if the default judgment was irregularly entered. The Court held that, in light of the setting aside of the default judgment, the next step was to order the return of any garnished amounts. The Court applied the principle that once a default judgment is set aside, any associated garnishee orders must also be vacated to prevent unjust enrichment of the judgment creditor. The Court relied on precedents that support the principle of vacating garnishee orders upon the setting aside of a default judgment. By ordering the return of the garnished amount, the Court clarified the procedural steps necessary to rectify the situation where a default judgment is irregularly entered, thus reinforcing the binding principle that garnishee orders must be vacated in such circumstances.
Further, the Court deliberated on whether the garnishee order should be enforced or if the garnished amount should be returned to the respondent. Given the setting aside of the default judgment, the Court held that the garnishee order should not be enforced and the garnished amount should be returned to the respondent. The Court applied the principle that enforcement of a garnishee order is contingent upon the validity of the underlying judgment. Since the default judgment had been set aside, the Court concluded that the garnishee order was no longer valid, thereby establishing the ratio decidendi that garnishee orders lose their enforceability when the underlying default judgment is set aside.
The implications for the enforcement of the original judgment and subsequent garnishee order were also considered. The Court held that the setting aside of the default judgment nullified the original judgment and rendered the garnishee order unenforceable. The Court applied the principle that the setting aside of a default judgment has the effect of rendering any associated enforcement orders null and void. This principle was reinforced by the Court's decision to order the return of the garnished amount, clarifying that the enforcement of the original judgment and garnishee order ceases upon the setting aside of the default judgment.
The Court addressed whether the costs of the Amended Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2021 should be made costs in the cause. The Court held that these costs should be made costs in the cause, applying the principle that costs incurred in successfully setting aside a default judgment should be costs in the cause. The Court relied on relevant case law that supports the principle of awarding costs in the cause for successful applications to set aside default judgments. This decision underscored the ratio decidendi that costs associated with setting aside a default judgment are appropriately made costs in the cause.
Regarding whether the respondent should be ordered to pay the amount of $153,431.64 to the first applicant within 7 days, the Court held in favour, applying the principle that the party who successfully set aside a default judgment may be entitled to restitution of any sums paid under the judgment. The Court's decision was based on the applicants' demonstration of a bona fide defence and the consequential setting aside of the default judgment, establishing the ratio decidendi that successful applicants in setting aside default judgments may be entitled to restitution of amounts paid.
The Court also considered whether the respondent should be ordered to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal. The Court held in favour of this, applying the principle that the successful party in an appeal may be entitled to costs. The Court relied on relevant case law that supports the principle of awarding costs to the successful party in an appeal. By ordering the respondent to pay the applicants’ costs of the appeal, the Court reinforced the ratio decidendi that the successful party in an appeal is entitled to costs.
Finally, the Court addressed whether the proceedings should be remitted to the District Court for further consideration. The Court held that the proceedings should be remitted, applying the principle that the District Court should have the opportunity to consider the case afresh in light of the set aside default judgment. The Court's decision to remit the proceedings was based on the need for the District Court to properly consider the merits of the applicants' defence. This decision underscored the ratio decidendi that proceedings should be remitted to the originating court when a default judgment is set aside, allowing for a fair consideration of the case on its merits.