Mangosteen Orchard Pty Ltd v Zieth

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mangosteen Orchard Pty Ltd v Zieth & Anor [2021] QDC 20

PARTIES:

MANGOSTEEN ORCHARD PTY LTD (ACN 160280811)

(applicant)

v

PETER JAMES ZIETH AND JULIE ANN ZIETH

(respondents)

FILE NO:

73/2021

DIVISION:

Brisbane

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 January 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 January, 19 January and 28 January 2021

JUDGE:

Sheridan DCJ

ORDER:

UPON THE APPLICANT GIVING THE USUAL UNDERTAKING AS TO DAMAGES, THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1.   Between the hours of 7:00am and 6:00pm commencing on Saturday, 30 January 2021 and continuing between the hours of 7:00am and 6:00pm each day thereafter, up until 6:00pm, Monday, 1 February 2021, the respondents grant such employees or agents of the applicant (other than Hoa Binh Xuan Ngo), as are reasonably necessary to enable the applicant to remove such chattels as it is permitted to remove by this order, such access to Lots 1 and 190 (excluding the farmhouse occupied by the respondents as their place of residence) on Registered Plan 804147 in the State of Queensland (the Farm) as may be reasonably necessary to enable the applicant to remove the chattels listed below from the Farm:

(a)        the roller conveyor (yellow frame) depicted in Photograph 3 exhibited to the Affidavit of David Kempton sworn 22 January 2021 (Kempton Affidavit);

(b)       the roller washer (blue frame) depicted in Photograph 4 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(c)        the hopper conveyor (blue) depicted in Photograph 5 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(d)       the weight grader (red top) depicted in Photograph 7 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(e)        the conveyor (yellow strip) which is depicted within the circle which appears in the version of Photograph 8 which is Exhibit “DK24” to the Kempton Affidavit;

(f)        the washer conveyor (stainless) depicted in Photograph 9 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(g)        the brush cleaning machine (blue red) depicted Photograph 9A exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(h)       the wash tank depicted in Photograph 10 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(i)         the circular grader depicted in Photograph 15 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(j)        the conveyor on legs depicted in Photograph 16 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(k)       the white bird nets depicted in Photographs 18 and 18A to 18D exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(l)         the 393 stackable fruit crates depicted in Photograph 19A exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit; and

(m)      such of the polystyrene boxes, depicted in Photographs 21 to 23 exhibited to the Kempton Affiavit and which are 18-litre boxes of the “UltraStak” brand but so as not to exceed 1000 in total. 

2.   In accessing the property as contemplated in Order 1, one only of the employees or agents of the applicant to whom access is granted may carry with them a mobile phone for the sole purpose of contacting Mr Ngo if any issue arises as to the identification of any of the items listed in Order 1 and the employee or agent in possession of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mangosteen Orchard Pty Ltd v Zieth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QDC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mangosteen Orchard Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought an interim injunction to remove specific chattels from the property of the respondents, Mr and Mrs Zieth, who own the Yum Yum Farm. The dispute centres on the ownership and use of various chattels that the applicant moved onto the Farm in 2016 and used for fruit harvesting. The respondents claim ownership or a right to retain certain chattels as payment for outstanding debts and damages, while the applicant insists that it is the rightful owner of the chattels in question. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant had established a prima facie case warranting the granting of an interim injunction and whether the balance of convenience favoured the applicant. The applicant needed to demonstrate that it had a reasonable chance of succeeding in establishing its ownership of the chattels and that the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction. The court considered the evidence provided by both parties, including affidavits, photographs, and correspondence, to assess the applicant's case.

The court found that the applicant had made out a prima facie case in respect of some of the chattels, as it had demonstrated a reasonable prospect of proving ownership. The court also determined that the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction, as the applicant needed immediate access to the chattels to continue its business operations. The court issued an interim injunction, allowing the applicant to remove specified chattels from the Farm during certain hours, subject to compliance with COVID-19 regulations. The court further ordered that the respondents must not remove the specified chattels from the Farm until after a certain date and set out a timetable for the filing of submissions and the review of the proceeding.

The court ordered that the applicant could remove specific chattels from the respondents' property, provided it gave the usual undertaking as to damages. The court also set out a timetable for the filing of submissions and the review of the proceeding. The interim injunction was granted to allow the applicant to remove the specified chattels from the Farm, recognising the urgency and importance of the matter to the applicant's business operations.

Orders

Orders of the court

UPON THE APPLICANT GIVING THE USUAL UNDERTAKING AS TO DAMAGES, THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1. Between the hours of 7:00am and 6:00pm commencing on Saturday, 30 January 2021 and continuing between the hours of 7:00am and 6:00pm each day thereafter, up until 6:00pm, Monday, 1 February 2021, the respondents grant such employees or agents of the applicant (other than Hoa Binh Xuan Ngo), as are reasonably necessary to enable the applicant to remove such chattels as it is permitted to remove by this order, such access to Lots 1 and 190 (excluding the farmhouse occupied by the respondents as their place of residence) on Registered Plan 804147 in the State of Queensland (the Farm) as may be reasonably necessary to enable the applicant to remove the chattels listed below from the Farm:

(a) the roller conveyor (yellow frame) depicted in Photograph 3 exhibited to the Affidavit of David Kempton sworn 22 January 2021 (Kempton Affidavit);

(b) the roller washer (blue frame) depicted in Photograph 4 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(c) the hopper conveyor (blue) depicted in Photograph 5 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(d) the weight grader (red top) depicted in Photograph 7 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(e) the conveyor (yellow strip) which is depicted within the circle which appears in the version of Photograph 8 which is Exhibit “DK24” to the Kempton Affidavit;

(f) the washer conveyor (stainless) depicted in Photograph 9 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(g) the brush cleaning machine (blue red) depicted Photograph 9A exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(h) the wash tank depicted in Photograph 10 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(i) the circular grader depicted in Photograph 15 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(j) the conveyor on legs depicted in Photograph 16 exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(k) the white bird nets depicted in Photographs 18 and 18A to 18D exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit;

(l) the 393 stackable fruit crates depicted in Photograph 19A exhibited to the Kempton Affidavit; and

(m) such of the polystyrene boxes, depicted in Photographs 21 to 23 exhibited to the Kempton Affiavit and which are 18-litre boxes of the “UltraStak” brand but so as not to exceed 1000 in total.

2. In accessing the property as contemplated in Order 1, one only of the employees or agents of the applicant to whom access is granted may carry with them a mobile phone for the sole purpose of contacting Mr Ngo if any issue arises as to the identification of any of the items listed in Order 1 and the employee or agent in possession of the mobile phone may take such photographs of the item for the purpose of sending such photograph to Mr Ngo.

3. In taking the steps contemplated in Order 1, the parties are not relieved from compliance with such laws and regulations concerning the COVID-19 pandemic as are in force.

4. Until further order, the applicant must not damage any of the items removed from the Farm, subject to fair wear and tear.

5. The respondents must preserve and must not remove from the Farm, any of the chattels listed in Order 1 above until after 6:00pm, Monday, 1 February 2021.

6. The applicant must file any submissions as to costs, of no more than 4 pages in length, excluding any attachments, by 4:00pm, Tuesday, 2 February 2021.

7. The respondent must file any submissions in response, of no more than 4 pages in length, excluding any attachments, by 4:00pm, Monday, 8 February 2021.

8. The applicant must file any submissions in reply, of no more than 2 pages in length, by 4:00pm, Wednesday, 10 February 2021.

9. The proceeding be listed for review before her Honour Judge Sheridan at 9:30am on Friday, 19 February 2021.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue to now be resolved by this court is whether the applicants should be permitted to remove any further chattels from the property on the basis of the further evidence provided to the respondents. Background The applicant operates a fruit harvesting and wholesaling business. The respondents are the owners of the Yum Yum Farm (the Farm) which is located outside of Innisfail. In 2015, the parties entered into an oral arrangement in respect of the harvesting of fruit on the Farm. There is now disagreement between the parties as to the precise nature of the arrangement, including whether Mr and Mrs Zieth leased or licensed the Farm to the applicant or whether the applicant merely was the purchaser of the fruit crop on the Farm. It is not in dispute that the respondents moved off the Farm and the applicant moved on to the Farm in 2016 and performed the first harvest of fruit on the Farm in 2017. In so doing, the applicant moved various harvesting equipment and chattels on to the Farm. In March 2020, Mr and Mrs Zieth returned to the Farm. Following their return to the Farm, the relationship between the applicant and Mr and Mrs Zieth deteriorated. Prior to the making of the application to the Court, correspondence was sent by the solicitors acting for the applicant to Mr and Mrs Zieth. It is clear from that correspondence that at all times the applicant was making a request to collect the packing line machines and the cherry picker, amongst other items, from the Farm. In correspondence sent by Julie Zieth on behalf of both respondents to the solicitor for the applicant dated 24 December 2020, access to the property was again denied and it was stated, “Property abandoned by your client at the end of the last season has been either appropriated by us in payment of outstanding debts and damages or disposed of at the Innisfail dump, your client is free to search there!” A further email was sent by Julie Zieth on 25 December 2020 attaching a spreadsheet of the respondents containing a “preliminary assessment of damages, fees, faults and charges resulting from unhonoured commitments to fruit sales and negligence by Binh and his company employees and officers using our equipment and facilities.” It was said that the amount claimed was a preliminary estimate only. A cherry picker was named in the spreadsheet; there was no reference to any packing line machines, or any components of those machines. Following the filing and service of the originating application, in correspondence from Julie Zieth to the solicitor for the applicant dated 14 January 2021, it was stated that the applicant may collect its belongings upon full payment of the invoice for storage. The invoice dated 14 January 2021 was for an amount of $143,000 including an amount of $13,000 for GST, and was said to be for “Storage Fees for Abandoned Equipment – June 2020 – December 2020 - 26 weeks @ $5000 pw + GST.” Previous monthly invoices for storage fees had been issued by the Zieths to the applicant. The monthly invoices were said to be for “Storage Fees for Processing Equipment” and were issued for an amount of $2200 including GST. A statement issued on 3 November 2020 incorporating the invoices issued between August and November 2020 said the total amount due was $12,752.30.Legal principles

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant has shown a prima facie case for the granting of an interlocutory injunction to access the property and remove specified chattels.
2. Whether the balance of convenience favours the granting of the interlocutory injunction to the applicant.
3. Whether the applicant has demonstrated that there is a serious question to be tried in relation to the ownership and entitlement to possession of the specified chattels.
4. Whether the applicant has provided adequate undertakings as to damages to mitigate any potential prejudice to the respondents if the injunction is granted.
5. Whether the applicant's request for the removal of additional chattels should be permitted based on the further evidence provided.

Held
1. Whether the applicant has shown a prima facie case for the granting of an interlocutory injunction to access the property and remove specified chattels.
The court concluded that the applicant had made out a prima facie case for the granting of an interlocutory injunction, allowing access to the property and the removal of specified chattels.

2. Whether the balance of convenience favours the granting of the interlocutory injunction to the applicant.
The court determined that the balance of convenience did favour the granting of the interlocutory injunction to the applicant.

3. Whether the applicant has demonstrated that there is a serious question to be tried in relation to the ownership and entitlement to possession of the specified chattels.
The court found that there was a serious question to be tried in relation to the ownership and entitlement to possession of the specified chattels.

4. Whether the applicant has provided adequate undertakings as to damages to mitigate any potential prejudice to the respondents if the injunction is granted.
The court required the applicant to give the usual undertaking as to damages before granting the interlocutory injunction.

5. Whether the applicant's request for the removal of additional chattels should be permitted based on the further evidence provided.
The court declined to permit the removal of additional chattels beyond those specified in the interlocutory injunction, based on the further evidence provided.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The central issue in this case was whether the applicant, Mangosteen Orchard Pty Ltd, should be granted an interlocutory injunction to access the property and remove specified chattels from the Farm, owned by the respondents, Mr and Mrs Zieth. The court's decision hinged on several key considerations, each of which will be explored in turn. Firstly, the court examined whether the applicant had shown a prima facie case for the granting of an interlocutory injunction. The applicant needed to demonstrate that it had a strong likelihood of success on the merits of its claim at the final hearing. In this case, the applicant had provided evidence of a prior oral arrangement with the respondents regarding the harvesting of fruit on the Farm. The applicant's affidavits and photographs established that it had moved various chattels onto the Farm and that these chattels were now in the possession of the respondents. The court found that the applicant had demonstrated a prima facie case, given the existence of the prior arrangement and the applicant's ownership of the chattels in question.

Secondly, the court assessed whether the balance of convenience favoured the granting of the interlocutory injunction. This involved weighing the respective hardships that would be suffered by each party if the injunction was granted or denied. The applicant argued that it needed immediate access to the property to retrieve its chattels, which were essential to its business operations. The respondents, on the other hand, contended that they had a legitimate interest in retaining possession of the chattels until the final determination of the dispute. The court found that the balance of convenience favoured the applicant, as the immediate removal of the chattels was necessary to prevent significant financial loss and disruption to the applicant's business.

Thirdly, the court considered whether the applicant had demonstrated that there was a serious question to be tried in relation to the ownership and entitlement to possession of the specified chattels. The applicant needed to show that the issues of ownership and entitlement were not frivolous or vexatious. The evidence presented by the applicant, including the affidavits and photographs, supported the assertion that the chattels belonged to the applicant. The court was satisfied that the applicant had demonstrated a serious question to be tried, as the evidence suggested a plausible claim to ownership of the chattels.

Fourthly, the court examined whether the applicant had provided adequate undertakings as to damages to mitigate any potential prejudice to the respondents if the injunction was granted. The applicant was required to assure the court that it would compensate the respondents for any losses incurred as a result of the injunction. The applicant provided an undertaking to pay storage fees for the chattels until the final determination of the dispute. The court accepted this undertaking as sufficient to address the potential prejudice to the respondents.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether the applicant's request for the removal of additional chattels should be permitted based on the further evidence provided. The applicant sought to remove additional chattels beyond those initially listed in the application. The court considered the new evidence provided by the applicant and found that it did not alter the balance of convenience or the other factors considered in the interlocutory injunction application. The court was satisfied that the applicant had met its burden of demonstrating a need for the additional chattels and that the balance of convenience still favoured granting the injunction.

In summary, the court's decision to grant the interlocutory injunction was based on the applicant's demonstration of a prima facie case, the balance of convenience favouring the applicant, the existence of a serious question to be tried, the provision of adequate undertakings as to damages, and the applicant's justification for the removal of additional chattels. The court's decision establishes the binding legal principle that in cases involving disputes over the ownership of chattels where immediate action is necessary to prevent significant financial loss and disruption to the applicant's business, an interlocutory injunction may be granted if the applicant can demonstrate a prima facie case, the balance of convenience favours the granting of the injunction, there is a serious question to be tried, and adequate undertakings as to damages are provided.