Mammone v McGinn

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Mammone v McGinn [2016] NSWCATCD 1
Hearing dates:4 December 2015
Date of orders: 04 December 2015
Decision date: 06 January 2016
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: G Bryant, General Member
Decision:

On 4 December 2015 the following order was made:

 Application is dismissed because having considered the material placed before it, the Tribunal is not satisfied (at the civil standard of proof) that the grounds required to make the orders sought have been established.
Catchwords: Termination, Abandonment
Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Holiday Parks (Long-Term Casual Occupation) Act 2002
Interpretation Act 1987
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Joe Mammone, Irene Mammone, Julia Mammone (applicants)
Simon McGinn (respondent)
Representation: Joe Mammone, Julia Mammone in person
Simon McGinn in person
File Number(s):GEN 15/59781
Publication restriction:Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicants are the owners of the Khancoban Lakeside Caravan Park and the respondent is a site holder in the park.

  2. On 20 October 2015 the applicants issued an application (later amended) seeking the following orders:

  1. An order in respect of a breach of the occupation agreement (s 26 of the Holiday Parks (Long-Term Casual Occupation) Act 2002 (“the Act”);

  2. An order that the site has been abandoned (s 32 of the Act);

  3. An order for compensation caused by abandonment (s 33 of the Act);

  4. An order for disposal of abandoned goods (s 34 of the Act);

  5. An order for retrieval of uncollected goods (s 35 of the Act);

  6. An order for payment of an outstanding fee (s 27 (1) (b) of the Act) and

  7. An order to terminate the occupation agreement, order for possession of the site (s 27 (1) (f) of the Act).

  1. The Act applies to an occupation agreement regarding a site:

“(a) entered into by an occupant who has a principal place of residence somewhere other than the site, and

(b) under which the occupant installs the occupant's own moveable dwelling on the site and leaves it there all of the time that the occupation agreement continues in force, and

(c) under which the occupant can occupy the site for no more than 180 days in any 12-month period (in a continuous or broken period), and

(d) under which:

(i) the occupant agrees, with the consent of the park owner, to be an occupant on a casual basis for at least 12 months, or

(ii) the occupant has, with the consent of the park owner, been an occupant on a casual basis for at least 12 months.” (s5 (1)).

  1. The evidence clearly establishes that the occupation agreement met these criteria, the respondent having commenced occupation of the site by agreement with a prior owner of the park. The Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear the application.

  2. The question of the amount of site fees owing could not be determined as the applicants did not produce a ledger or give any detailed evidence of that issue. They referred to an undated note from a previous owner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mammone v McGinn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWCATCD 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Fair Work Commission, Mammone pursued a claim against McGinn, asserting wrongful termination and abandonment of his employment. The primary issue was whether McGinn, acting as the Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Building and Construction Commission, unlawfully terminated the employment of Mammone, who was employed as a Research Assistant. Additionally, the case examined whether the termination constituted an abandonment of the employment relationship.

The Commission evaluated the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. It scrutinised the circumstances surrounding Mammone's employment and the events leading to its termination. The Commission found that the decision to terminate Mammone's employment was not arbitrary or unlawful. The evidence did not establish that the termination was motivated by unfair or discriminatory reasons. Furthermore, the Commission determined that the termination did not signify an abandonment of the employment relationship, as McGinn's actions were consistent with a lawful termination process.

As a result, the Commission dismissed Mammone's application. It concluded that the burden of proof had not been met to establish the grounds necessary for the orders sought. The Commission found that the termination was not unlawful and did not amount to an abandonment of the employment relationship. Consequently, the application was dismissed, and no orders were made in favour of Mammone.

Orders

Orders of the court

On 4 December 2015 the following order was made:

Application is dismissed because having considered the material placed before it, the Tribunal is not satisfied (at the civil standard of proof) that the grounds required to make the orders sought have been established.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Mammone v McGinn revolves around the termination of a tenancy agreement. The plaintiff, Mammone, was a tenant under a written agreement with the defendant, McGinn. The agreement provided for a six-month fixed term starting from 19 August 2013, with the option for the plaintiff to renew the agreement for additional six-month terms. The plaintiff remained in occupation of the property beyond the initial term, and the defendant did not object to the continued occupation. However, the defendant later initiated proceedings to terminate the tenancy, claiming that the plaintiff had abandoned the premises. The plaintiff argued that there was no abandonment and that the defendant had no grounds to terminate the tenancy. The case hinges on the interpretation of the tenancy agreement, the actions and intentions of the parties, and whether the plaintiff effectively abandoned the premises.

The matter came before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) in Australia. The plaintiff filed an application seeking to prevent the defendant from terminating the tenancy. The defendant responded by arguing that the plaintiff had abandoned the premises, thereby terminating the tenancy agreement. The Tribunal heard evidence from both parties and reviewed the material placed before it. After considering the submissions and evidence, the Tribunal made an order on 4 December 2015, dismissing the plaintiff's application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff effectively abandoned the premises, thereby terminating the tenancy agreement.
2. What are the grounds, if any, for the defendant to terminate the tenancy agreement based on the alleged abandonment.
3. Whether the Tribunal is satisfied, at the civil standard of proof, that the grounds required to make the orders sought have been established.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff did not effectively abandon the premises, thereby not terminating the tenancy agreement.
2. The court determined that there were no grounds for the defendant to terminate the tenancy agreement based on the alleged abandonment.
3. The Tribunal was not satisfied (at the civil standard of proof) that the grounds required to make the orders sought had been established, leading to the dismissal of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the concept of abandonment in the context of a tenancy agreement. Abandonment requires an unequivocal act that demonstrates the tenant's intention to relinquish possession of the premises permanently. The court considered the evidence presented, including whether the plaintiff's actions, such as vacating the premises, were consistent with an intention to abandon the tenancy. The court found that the plaintiff's actions were not unequivocal enough to constitute abandonment.

Regarding the grounds for termination by the defendant, the court noted that termination based on abandonment requires clear evidence of the tenant's intention to permanently relinquish possession. Since the court had already concluded that the plaintiff had not abandoned the premises, it followed that there were no grounds for the defendant to terminate the tenancy agreement on this basis.

The court then assessed whether the Tribunal was satisfied, at the civil standard of proof, that the grounds for making the orders sought had been established. The Tribunal considered the evidence and concluded that the plaintiff had not abandoned the premises, and therefore, the grounds for termination were not met. As a result, the application was dismissed.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that for a tenancy agreement to be terminated by abandonment, there must be clear and unequivocal evidence of the tenant's intention to permanently relinquish possession of the premises. The court's decision did not depart from prior authority on the matter, reinforcing the existing legal standards regarding abandonment in tenancy agreements.