Maloof v Uncle's Joint Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Maloof v Uncle's Joint Pty Limited [2015] NSWSC 389
Hearing dates:24 March 2015
Date of orders: 31 March 2015
Decision date: 31 March 2015
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Young AJA
Decision:

1. By consent I vary the order made in 360672 on 5 December 2013 in Tiba and Sarah and in 360586 on 19 December 2013 in the Frances proceeding by deleting paragraph 3(i) and inserting instead “(i) the payment of reasonable legal costs incurred in relation to producing documents on subpoena or notice to produce and retaining and instructing solicitors to act in proceedings 2010/36817, 2010/370107, 2013/360586 and 2013/360672”.
2. I dismiss Motion B (filed 20 October 2014) with costs.
3. I modify the freezing order by consent.
4. The costs of Motion A (filed 7 November 2014) be costs in the cause.
5. All the evidence of the defendants is to be served no later than 24 June 2015.
6. The matter is to go to the Registrar’s list on 21 April 2015,
(a) to fix a hearing date with a tentative estimate of nine days, and
(b) to put the matter in for pre-trial directions before the hearing judge some time after 24 June 2015, so the hearing time can be adjusted depending on what comes out of the extra evidence. The normal orders for hearing can then be made, which includes a court book being given to the judge at least three days before the hearing.

Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Statute of Uses, 1535 (Imp)
Cases Cited: Chancery in Topham v Portland (Duke) (1863) 1 De GJ & S 517; 46 ER 205
Kain v Hutton [2007] NZCA 199; [2007] 3 NZLR 349
Kain v Hutton [2008] NZSC 61; [2008] 3 NZLR 589
Re Burton’s Settlement [1955] Ch 82
Re Crawshay [1948] Ch 123
Re Wright [1920] 1 Ch 108
Texts Cited: GW Thomas, Thomas on Powers (Oxford University Press, 2nd edition, 2012)
JA McGhee (Ed), Snell's Equity (Sweet & Maxwell, 32nd edition, 2010)
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties:

2013/00360586
(Plaintiff) Frances Rita Maloof
(Defendants 1-4) Uncle's Joint Pty Limited ACN 148 176 792, Darren Pernice, Einasleigh Nominees Pty Limited ACN 001 547 575, Albert & May Pty Ltd ACN 001 102 067

2013/00360672
(Plaintiff 1) Tiba Clementine Maloof
(Plaintiff 2) Sarah Mariel Maloof
(Defendants 1-4) Uncle's Joint Pty Limited ACN 148 176 792, Darren Pernice, Einasleigh Nominees Pty Limited ACN 001 547 575, Albert & May Pty Ltd ACN 001 102 067
Representation:

Counsel:
(Plaintiffs) Mr C Harris SC with Mr ME Luitingh
(Defendants 1, 2, 4) Mr PD Herzfeld

Solicitors:
2013/00360586
(Plaintiff) Staunton & Thompson
(Defendants 1, 2, 4) Watson Mangioni Lawyers Pty Ltd

2013/00360672
(Plaintiffs 1-2) Knight Lawyers
(Defendants 1, 2, 4) Watson Mangioni Lawyers Pty Ltd
File Number(s):2013/00360586; 2013/00360672

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: These two pieces of litigation arise out of the trusts set up by and will made by the late Dr CJ Maloof (“

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maloof v Uncle's Joint Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 389
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New South Wales considered two motions filed in proceedings arising from disputes over the trusts set up by the late Dr CJ Maloof. The plaintiffs, Frances, Tiba, and Sarah Maloof, allege that they are entitled to exercise control over the CJ Maloof Family Trust and the Einasleigh Trust, which hold the majority of the deceased's assets. The defendants, including Uncle's Joint Pty Ltd, Darren Pernice, Einasleigh Nominees Pty Limited, and Albert & May Pty Ltd, argue that the trusts should be controlled by the other five children of Dr Maloof. The court was required to decide on two motions: Motion A, filed by the first, second, and fourth defendants, seeking orders to prevent the plaintiffs from relying on certain matters, and Motion B, filed by Albert & May Pty Ltd, seeking vacation or relaxation of certain freezing orders made by consent. The court examined the pleadings, the relevance of Peter Maloof's subjective beliefs, and the appropriateness of the freezing orders. The court found that Motion A should be dismissed, and Motion B should also be dismissed with costs. The court modified the freezing order by consent and ordered the defendants to serve their evidence by 24 June 2015. The matter was to go to the Registrar's list on 21 April 2015 to fix a hearing date and for pre-trial directions before the hearing judge.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves disputes arising from the trusts and will set up by the late Dr CJ Maloof, involving his children and other beneficiaries. Frances, Tiba, and Sarah (the plaintiffs) are three of Dr Maloof's children, contesting the control of two family trusts: the CJ Maloof Family Trust and the Einasleigh Trust. The other five children (the defendants) are contesting these claims. The plaintiffs argue that the trusts' principal asset, a 75% shareholding in Albert & May Pty Ltd (A & W), should be controlled by them, while the defendants argue that the shares should be controlled by the five children. The dispute stems from the deceased's actions prior to his death, including a codicil that altered shares distribution and the appointment and removal of trustees.

The case has been through multiple stages, including the filing of statements of claim by Frances and Tiba, and responses from the defendants. The current proceedings involve two notices of motion: Motion A filed by the first, second, and fourth defendants on 7 November 2014, and Motion B filed by A & W on 20 October 2014. Motion A seeks orders preventing the plaintiffs from relying on certain matters, while Motion B seeks vacation or relaxation of freezing orders made by consent. The case was heard by Young AJA on 24 March 2015, with written and oral submissions from counsel. The judge reserved his reasons and directions for the ongoing conduct of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the plaintiffs be required to amend their Reply to address certain defences raised by the defendants?
2. Can the plaintiffs contend that Peter was mistaken about material matters?
3. Should the freezing orders be modified or vacated to allow A & W to dispose of property?

Held
1. The plaintiffs are not required to amend their Reply to address certain defences raised by the defendants.
2. The plaintiffs can contend that Peter was mistaken about material matters.
3. The freezing orders are not to be modified or vacated to allow A & W to dispose of property.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that there was no justification for requiring the plaintiffs to amend their Reply to address the defences raised by the defendants. The court noted that the defence was actually an admission that Peter had the same purpose as alleged by the plaintiffs, which was to prevent the provisions of the deceased’s will from taking effect. The court also found that it was a most serious step to take at a preliminary hearing to deny a party the right at a trial to put forward the material he or she wishes to place before the court. This is only done in the most extreme case and this was not such a case. The court further found that the evidence which the defendants sought to exclude would be relevant to the issue as to whether in fact Peter held the beliefs that the defendants say he held. Therefore, Motion A should be dismissed with costs.

Regarding Motion B, the court found that the defendants had not shown any substantial reason for the freezing orders to be vacated or modified. The court noted that the plaintiffs’ complaint was that A & W was a company of which the executors of the deceased’s estate held 25% of the shares, the 75% holding the plaintiffs say should, were it not for the improper actions of the defendants, be controlled by them. The court found that the defendants' only substantial answer was that A & W had no requirement to hold annual meetings to elect directors, which was not sufficient. The court also found that A & W had mortgaged property to secure a loan of $250,000 and appeared to have used this part of the loan to pay very substantial legal costs not only of A & W but of the other defendants as well. The court noted that there was not yet any motion for contempt for breach of the freezing order. It may be it was breached, maybe not. The lawyers for the defendants should seriously review the position and, if they consider there may have been a breach, but only a technical breach, repay the loan forthwith to save their clients the risk of 28 days imprisonment or sequestration of the company assets which appear to be the standard punishment for deliberate contempt. Therefore, the court dismissed Motion B with costs.

The court also modified the freezing order by consent and ordered that the costs of Motion A be costs in the cause. The court further ordered that all the evidence of the defendants is to be served no later than 24 June 2015 and that the matter is to go to the Registrar’s list on 21 April 2015 to fix a hearing date with a tentative estimate of nine days. The court suggested to the registrar that he or she put the matter in for pre-trial directions before the hearing judge some time after 24 June, so the hearing time can be adjusted depending on what comes out of the extra evidence. The court further noted that it was bad advocacy not to give the judge every possible assistance to make his or her decision in one’s clients’ favour.