Malcolm Fischer and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Fischer and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2016] AATA 610 (16 August 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2014/6550

Re

Malcolm Fischer

APPLICANT

And

K & S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 16 August 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes its decision that Mr Fischer is entitled to compensation for his lumbar disc extrusion which became symptomatic on 26 July 2014, he having previously been compensated for similar symptoms diagnosed as back strain in September 2011. Liability is attracted under s 14 of the Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1999 and compensation under s 16 and s 19.

...............[sgd]................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – injury arising out of employment – significant contribution by employment to an ailment – compensable back/buttock injury in 2011- liability accepted and compensation paid – recurrence of symptoms 2014 – massive disc extrusion – surgical intervention required – s 14 liability found – decision set aside

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Goward v Commonwealth (1957) 97 CLR 355

Gregory v Comcare (1997) 72 FCR 196

Hatzimanolis v ANI Corp Ltd (1992) 173 CLR 473

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Bowden (2012) 206 FCR 207

Thom Or Simpson v Sinclair [1917] AC 127

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

16 August 2016

  1. Mr Fischer lodged a claim for compensation on 4 August 2014, having suddenly developed severe lower back, right buttock and leg pain on 26 July 2014.  He claimed this arose from his work as a freight truck driver over the preceding six days.  In 2011 he had suffered a similar but shorter lived episode of pain in the right buttock and leg with some back pain which had been accepted as an injury, being a muscle strain, arising out of employment. Liability had been accepted and compensation had been paid for that injury. 

  2. On 13 October 2014, the Senior Workers’ Compensation Manager of the Respondent determined that on the evidence then before him the Respondent was not liable under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) in respect of right sciatica, reported to have been sustained on 26 July 2014.  The basis for the determination appears to have been that the onset of symptoms occurred on a day that he was on leave and had not been complained of to Mr Fischer’s general practitioner who saw him on 28 July 2014. The Respondent further relied on the opinion of Associate Professor Steadman who considered the development of severe right sided sciatica was a natural progression of pre-existing pathology. 

  3. At Mr Fischer’s request, the determination was reviewed. It was affirmed on 14 November 2014. Mr Fischer lodged an application for review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 18 December 2014.

  4. At the hearing Mr Fischer was represented by Mr Mark Carey of counsel instructed by Ms Irina Jovic of Maurice Blackburn solicitors. K & S Freighters was represented by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Malcolm Fischer and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 610
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Malcolm Fischer against his employer, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd, before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Mr Fischer, an interstate truck driver since 2001, alleged that his employment had caused or significantly contributed to a disc injury. The dispute centred on whether Mr Fischer's employment as a long-haul truck driver, involving long hours, repetitive heavy lifting, and exposure to poorly designed truck seats, had led to his current debilitating back condition.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Fischer's L5/S1 disc extrusion constituted an aggravation of a pre-existing work-related disc injury and whether his employment had significantly contributed to this condition. The central legal issue was the causal link between Mr Fischer's occupational duties and his diagnosed spinal injury, particularly in light of a prior, similar episode of pain in 2011.

The Tribunal's reasoning was heavily influenced by the expert medical evidence presented. Dr Thomas Kossman, an orthopaedic spinal surgeon, opined that Mr Fischer's employment, with its repetitive handling of heavy goods and prolonged driving in ergonomically poor seats, had led to his disc degeneration and extrusion. Dr Kossman considered the delay between Mr Fischer's last day of active work and the onset of pain to be insignificant in establishing a causal relationship. He further stated that the nature of the occupation, involving prolonged sitting interspersed with heavy lifting, likely resulted in a loss of core strength, making Mr Fischer more vulnerable to disc damage. The Tribunal noted that had Dr Kossman seen Mr Fischer in 2011 with evidence of an annular tear, he would have advised a job change.

Based on the evidence, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review. It determined that Mr Fischer's L5/S1 disc extrusion was an aggravation of a pre-existing work-related disc injury significantly contributed to by his employment. Consequently, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd was ordered to pay compensation pursuant to sections 14, 16, and 19 of the SRC Act for medical treatment expenses and weekly payments for incapacity, as well as the applicant's costs and disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal was provided with the documents lodged in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T‑documents) and both parties tendered exhibits a list of which is appended to this decision. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from Mr Fischer. Mr Fischer called Mr Thomas Kossman to give evidence. K & S Freighters called Dr Anthony Kam, a radiologist, Associate Professor Peter Steadman, an orthopaedic surgeon, and Mr Jason Randall the National Line Haul Manager to give evidence for the Respondent. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Fischer has worked as an interstate driver of B-Double freight haulage vehicles (trucks) for K & S Freighters since 2001. His duties have included driving from Melbourne to Brisbane, Sydney and Adelaide. This has involved a daily minimum of nine hours driving but can involve up to 17 hours in the truck on any day. These hours represent driving periods, rest breaks, waiting times at depots and times spent loading and unloading the trailer. Given the length of time involved in the delivery services, Mr Fischer takes with him a mattress, his personal belongings, clothing and a portable refrigerator weighing in the vicinity of 20 to 25 kilograms. Mr Fischer has described in detail his duties on his interstate runs. These include a pre-trip inspection of the vehicle, loading of the vehicle and strapping down the load using various steel dogs, chains and straps. The tightening of the latter is said to require considerable force. Throughout the entire procedure lifting appears, according to his statement (Exhibit A1), to be limited to 15 kilograms. Whenever vehicles are changed the driver is required to switch all his normal gear to the new truck. As previously stated this includes bedding, belongings, clothes and the refrigerator. While Mr Fischer has performed various duties in runs to Brisbane and Sydney, it is the Mount Gambier/Adelaide/Melbourne run which is involved in his claim. Mr Randall has given evidence as to the details of Mr Fischer’s normal run between Melbourne and Mount Gambier. Mr Randall said it was his understanding that Mr Fischer lived in Horsham. He would load or, as the case might be, unload his freight in Mount Gambier on a Friday. He would then travel to Horsham, were he stayed overnight and proceeded either back to Melbourne or, on reverse trips, to Mount Gambier on the Sunday. There was however an arrangement whereby every second Friday Mr Fischer needed to return home to Horsham by 2.00pm so that he could spend the weekend with his daughter in accordance with a custodial direction. The freight transported between Mount Gambier and Melbourne was almost exclusively steel products produced by One Steel. Mr Fischer gave evidence that while in Melbourne he stayed with his current partner in Blackburn South. He had earlier stayed with a former partner, from whom he separated in January 2012. From that date Mr Fischer had shared custody of his daughter. Mr Fischer sought consideration from his employers’ to be placed on local delivery work as opposed to interstate work in order to spend more time with his child. As this did not eventuate, despite K & S Freighters’ efforts, he endeavoured to return to Melbourne at a reasonable time on alternate Fridays.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As noted above, Mr Fischer could be required to be in the truck for up to 17 hours in a stretch. He has been particularly aware of more recent problems with the seating in various trucks he has driven. This he said commenced in early July when a faulty seat in his vehicle had to be replaced. In the week leading up to the onset of the right sciatica, Mr Fischer having been required to he drive at least three different trucks in the course of that week. He has described the seating as being uncomfortable, worn and the padding frayed, dislodged and poor in terms of support.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMr Fischer Mr Fischer’s evidence has been summarised under BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION. Only the evidence relevant to the claim has been included. Other health issues alleged by the Respondent such as sleep apnoea and treated hypertension are not relevant. Mr Thomas Kossman, orthopaedic spinal surgeon Mr Kossman saw Mr Fischer on 23 May 2015 at the request of his solicitors. He provided a report made on the same date (Exhibit A3). Mr Kossman obtained the same medical history that Mr Fischer gave to the Tribunal including the past history of a similar bout of pain occurring in September 2011. At the time of the appointment Mr Fischer was still suffering from lumbar back pain radiating to his right leg that varied in intensity depending on his level of activity. Mr Kossman did not have access to the actual MRI scans which had been provided with the report of 13 September 2014, showing a massive paracentral disc prolapse impinging on the right L5/S1 nerve roots. At the time of the appointment Mr Fischer’s symptoms were partially controlled with the use of analgesics in the form of Panadeine Forte and Endone. Mr Kossman considered Mr Fischer’s prognosis to be guarded given his persisting debilitating symptoms then of more than 9 months duration. He opined that Mr Fischer would require a surgical L5/S1 discectomy. Mr Kossman was of the opinion that Mr Fischer’s employment as a truck driver, the repetitive handling of heavy goods and long haul driving in ergonomically poorly designed truck seats had led to his disc degeneration and extrusion. It was recommended that Mr Fischer be referred to a spinal surgeon for discectomy. In his oral evidence before the Tribunal Mr Kossman confirmed his written opinion. In addition, Mr Kossman gave evidence that the delay in symptom production from the last day of active work on 24 July 2014 until the onset of back, buttock and right leg pain on 26 July was of no significance in terms of the causal relationship. Mr Kossman considered the nature of Mr Fischer’s occupation and the required sitting for hours, associated with heavy lifting intermittently, resulted in the loss of core strength and rendered Mr Fischer more vulnerable to disc damage. He was also of the opinion that had Mr Fischer undergone an MRI in 2011 it was highly likely this would have shown at least an annular tear in the L5/S1 disc. Mr Kossman said that had he seen Mr Fischer with those results in 2011, he would have instructed him to change his job.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Had the opinions of Mr Kossman and Associate Professor Steadman not been essentially in agreement, the Tribunal given the absence of objective evidence in the form of radiological imaging in 2011, would have considered the claim under s 5A(1)(b) or (c).CONCLUSION For these reasons, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review. In substitution, the Tribunal determines that:(a)Mr Fischer’s massive L5/S1 disc extrusion is an aggravation of a pre-existing work related disc injury which has been significantly contributed to by his employment. (b)The Respondent is liable to pay:(i)Compensation pursuant to s 14 of the SRC Act; and(ii)The costs of medical treatment expenses pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act; and(iii)Weekly payments of compensation in respect of incapacity pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act. The Respondent is ordered to pay the Applicant’s costs and disbursements in respect of the proceedings pursuant to s 67 of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.