JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: MAK INDUSTRIAL WATER SOLUTIONS PTY LTD -v- DOHERTY [No 2] [2023] WASC 279
CORAM: QUINLAN CJ
HEARD: 24 JULY 2023
DELIVERED : 24 JULY 2023
PUBLISHED : 26 JULY 2023
FILE NO: CIV 2234 of 2022
BETWEEN: MAK INDUSTRIAL WATER SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
BRENDAN DOHERTY
First Defendant
BWATER PTY LTD
Second Defendant
MICHAEL HARTNETT
Third Defendant
KYLE MATTHEWS
Fourth Defendant
MICHAEL HARTNETT
First Plaintiff by Counterclaim
KYLE MATTHEWS
Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim
AND
MAK INDUSTRIAL WATER SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
Defendant by Counterclaim
Catchwords:
Employment law – Summary judgment – Counterclaim for employment entitlements – Counterclaim for payment for share redemption – Whether no real question to be tried – Whether triable issue as to claim for equitable set-off – Stay of execution of judgments
Legislation:
Rules of the Supreme Court, O 14
Result:
Summary judgment granted
Stay of execution granted
Category: B
Representation:
Original Action
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | J F Park |
| First Defendant | : | T O Coyle |
| Second Defendant | : | T O Coyle |
| Third Defendant | : | T O Coyle |
| Fourth Defendant | : | T O Coyle |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Dentons Australia |
| First Defendant | : | Capital Legal |
| Second Defendant | : | Capital Legal |
| Third Defendant | : | Capital Legal |
| Fourth Defendant | : | Capital Legal |
Counterclaim
Counsel:
| First Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | T O Coyle |
| Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | T O Coyle |
| Defendant by Counterclaim | : | J F Park |
Solicitors:
| First Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | Capital Legal |
| Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | Capital Legal |
| Defendant by Counterclaim | : | Dentons Australia |
Cases referred to in decision:
Absolute Analogue Inc v Sundance Resources Ltd [No 3] [2014] WASC 283
Burnet v Francis Industries plc [1987] 1 WLR 802
Exchequer Australia Pty Ltd v Leopardi [2021] WASC 340
Field Camp Services Pty Ltd v Site Accommodation Pty Ltd [No 2] [2012] WASCA 27
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] HCA 69; (1964) 112 CLR 125
GR Engineering Services Ltd v Investmet Ltd [2021] WASCA 136
Industrial Rollformers Pty Ltd v Ingersoll-Rand Australia Ltd [2001] NSWCA 111
James v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 37 FCR 445
MAK Industrial Water Solutions Pty Ltd v Doherty [2023] WASC 146
New Resources Holdings Pty Ltd v Lunt [No 3] [2008] WASC 221
Palaniappan v Westpac Banking Corporation [2016] WASCA 72
State Bank of Victoria v Parry [1989] WAR 240
Sutton Investments Pty Ltd v Realistic Investments Pty Ltd [2017] WASCA 14
Table of Contents
Introduction
Summary judgment
The evidence
Mr Hartnett's claims in the counterclaim
Mr Hartnett's Contract of Employment
Mr Hartnett's long service leave
Mr Hartnett's August commission
Mr Hartnett's Plan Share Redemption
Plan Rules
Mr Hartnett's calculation of the Prevailing Price
MAK Water's calculation of the Prevailing Price
Which calculation of the Prevailing Price is correct?
Preliminary conclusions as to Mr Hartnett's entitlements
Mr Matthews' claims in the counterclaim
Mr Matthews' Contract of Employment
Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MAK Industrial Water Solutions Pty Ltd v Doherty [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] WASC 279
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, in its judgment, reaffirmed the established legal principles governing equitable set-off. It held that for a set-off to be recognised, the countervailing claims must be closely connected to and challenge the plaintiff's claims to such an extent that they impeach the plaintiff's entitlement. The court emphasised that the mere existence of cross-claims does not suffice; there must be a recognised equitable ground for protection. Furthermore, the court underscored that in resisting a summary judgment application based on set-off, the defendant must provide evidence that allows the court to make an informed assessment of the likely quantum of the counterclaims. In this case, the court found that the defendant's counterclaims were not sufficiently connected to the plaintiff's claims to qualify as equitable set-off, as they did not directly challenge the plaintiff's entitlement or meet the criteria for equitable intervention. Additionally, the evidence provided by the defendant was deemed insufficient to enable an assessment of the likely quantum of the counterclaims.
Consequently, the Full Court dismissed the defendant's attempt to resist summary judgment by invoking equitable set-off. The court granted the plaintiff's application for summary judgment, finding that the defendant had failed to establish an arguable defence on the basis of set-off. The court ordered that the plaintiff's claims were to be determined on their merits, and that the defendant's counterclaims would be considered at a later stage in the proceedings if they were pursued further. This decision underscores the stringent requirements for invoking equitable set-off in the context of contractual disputes and the necessity for defendants to provide robust evidence to support their claims when resisting summary judgment.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
To give rise to a set-off, the claims to be set off must, generally, be so closely connected that the countervailing claim impeaches the entitlement to the originating claim. As Buss JA (as his Honour then was) said in Palaniappan v Westpac Banking Corporation:[56]An equitable set-off is available where the party claiming the set-off can establish a recognised equitable ground for being protected, to the relevant extent, from the other party's demand. The set-off must essentially be bound up with and go to the root of, challenge, call in question or impeach the title of the other party. The mere existence of a cross-claim or cross-demand is not sufficient to establish an equitable set-off. There must be a recognised ground for equitable intervention (beyond the mere existence of a cross-claim or cross-demand) so that the equity of the party claiming the set-off impeaches the title of the other party to the legal demand which it is seeking to enforce. See J & S Holdings Pty Ltd v NRMA Insurance Ltd (1982) 61 FLR 108, 127 (Blackburn, Deane & Ellicott JJ); James v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 37 FCR 445, 457 - 462 (Gummow J); Hazcor Pty Ltd v Kirwanon Pty Ltd (1995) 12 WAR 62, 67 - 68 (Kennedy J, Malcolm CJ & Murray J agreeing); HP Mercantile Pty Ltd v Dierickx [2013] NSWCA 479; (2013) 306 ALR 53 [136] (Emmett JA, Beazley P relevantly agreeing & Meagher JA agreeing); Hawes v Dean [2014] NSWCA 380 [59] - [65] (Barrett JA, Bathurst CJ & McColl JA agreeing).[56] Palaniappan v Westpac Banking Corporation [2016] WASCA 72 [50] (Buss JA). Importantly, a mere counterclaim amounting to a cross action will not amount to a defence (by way of set-off) to a plaintiff's claim. Moreover, it is necessary for the parties resisting a summary judgment application on the grounds of a set-off to enable the court to make some assessment of the likely quantum of the claim. In this regard, as the Court of Appeal said in Field Camp Services Pty Ltd v Site Accommodation Pty Ltd [No 2]:[57]In seeking to resist an application for summary judgment based on an equitable set‑off, the defendant must not only establish that it has an arguable claim on breach, but must also put before the court sufficient evidence to enable the court to make some assessment of the likely quantum of the defendant's claim. A defendant will not, in seeking to resist a summary judgment application, establish an arguable defence of set‑off if the evidence in support of the quantum of its claim is so vague, uncertain and lacking in substance, that the court is unable to make any informed assessment of its likely quantum and whether the quantum is likely to reach or exceed the level of the plaintiff's claim in debt: Melbourne Glass Pty Ltd v Coby Constructions Pty Ltd (1997) 14 BCL 409, 418 ‑ 419.[57] Field Camp Services Pty Ltd v Site Accommodation Pty Ltd [No 2] [2012] WASCA 27 (Field Camp). In the present case, MAK Water's alleged set-off is said to arise from MAK Water's claims in the primary action for breach of the defendant's contracts of employment, breach of fiduciary duty and use of confidential information.