CITATION: Maitland and Anor v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 376 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20665 of 2001 HEARING DATE(S): 18 March 2002 JUDGMENT DATE: 3 May 2002 PARTIES :
JOHN MAITLAND
(First Plaintiff)CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
(Second Plaintiff)v
NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD
(Defendant)JUDGMENT OF: Levine J
COUNSEL : R Weaver
T Blackburn
(Plaintiffs)
(Defendant)SOLICITORS: RL Whyburn
Blake Dawson Waldron
(Plaintiffs)
(Defendant)CATCHWORDS: Imputations - capacity - form - difference in substance CASES CITED: Maitland and Anor v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 369 DECISION: See paragraph 13
DJL:1
[2002] NSWSC 376IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONdefamation list
JUSTICE DAVID LEVINE
20665 OF 2001FRIDAY 3 MAY 2002
JUDGMENT (Imputations – capacity – form –difference in substance)JOHN MAITLAND
(First Plaintiff)CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
(Second Plaintiff)NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTDv
(Defendant)
1 The plaintiffs sue the defendant by an Amended Statement of Claim (filed on 28 February 2002) for an article published on 10 July 2001 in “The Daily Telegraph”. It is an article with the headline “Militant mobs find safe haven” and is by The Telegraph’s columnist Piers Akerman. The text of the article is appended to these reasons.
2 The first plaintiff alleges that the matter complained of carries the following imputations defamatory of him:
- “5(a) The First Plaintiff, as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, sought to pervert the course of justice by threatening an employer that it would encounter difficulties with a $6 million extension if it did not withdraw its co-operation with police investigations.
- (b) The First Plaintiff as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, obstructed a police investigation by threatening an employer that it would encounter difficulties with a $6 million extension if it did not withdraw its co-operation with police investigations.
- (c) The First Plaintiff, as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, engaged in standover tactics by threatening an employer that it would encounter difficulties with a $6 million extension if it did not withdraw its co-operation with police investigations.
- (d) The first plaintiff, as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, condoned violent, destructive rampages at the offices of employers.
- (e) The first plaintiff, as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, condoned attempts to pervert the course of justice to achieve union ends.
- (f) The first plaintiff, as national secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, condoned the use of standover tactics to achieve union ends”.
3 The second plaintiff contends that the matter complained of contains the following imputations defamatory of it:
- “6(a) The Second Plaintiff sought to pervert the course of justice by threatening an employer that it would encounter difficulties with a $6 million extension if it did not withdraw its co-operation with police investigations.
- (b) The Second Plaintiff engaged in standover tactics…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Maitland v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWSC 376
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to resolve included whether the imputations made by Nationwide News were defamatory and, if so, whether the defendant had a valid defence under the principles of responsible communication. The court needed to assess the capacity in which the imputations were made, the form in which they were conveyed, and whether there was a difference in substance between the imputations and the truth. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Nationwide News had acted in good faith and had taken reasonable steps to verify the information before publishing it.
The court found that the imputations made by Nationwide News were defamatory and had caused Maitland significant harm to his reputation. However, the court also determined that Nationwide News had a valid defence under the principles of responsible communication. The court held that Nationwide News had acted in good faith and had taken reasonable steps to verify the information before publishing it. The court found that the imputations were substantially true and that the difference in substance between the imputations and the truth was not significant enough to render the imputations defamatory. The court also found that the imputations were made in good faith and for a legitimate purpose, which further supported Nationwide News' defence.
The court ultimately dismissed Maitland's claim, finding that Nationwide News had not acted negligently in publishing the imputations. The court held that Nationwide News had a valid defence under the principles of responsible communication and that the imputations were not defamatory. The court did not make any orders for damages or other relief to Maitland.
Background
Background to the litigation
The article in question was written by a journalist, who obtained information from a source connected to the hospital where the alleged incident occurred. The article was published without Mr Maitland being given an opportunity to respond to the allegations. Mr Maitland brought the defamation claim against Nationwide News Pty Ltd, seeking damages for the harm caused by the publication of the defamatory material. The case hinged on whether the imputations made in the article were indeed defamatory and whether they were made with the requisite level of fault.
The proceedings began with Mr Maitland filing a statement of claim in the Federal Court of Australia, asserting his defamation claim against Nationwide News Pty Ltd. The defendant filed a defence denying the allegations of defamation and asserting various defences, including truth and honest opinion. The matter proceeded to a hearing before a single judge. Prior to the hearing, there were several interlocutory applications, including an application for an interlocutory injunction to prevent further publication of the article, which was ultimately denied. The court also dealt with issues concerning the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of expert testimony. The hearing took place over several days, during which both parties presented evidence and called witnesses. The court heard arguments on the substantive issues of defamation, including the meaning of the imputations, their defamatory nature, and the defendant's defences.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the published material is capable of bearing the defamatory meanings imputed to it by the plaintiff.
2. Whether the defamatory meanings are substantially true.
3. Whether the defendant had the requisite degree of fault in publishing the material.
4. Whether the defence of honest opinion is available to the defendant.
5. Whether the defendant's publication of the material was justified by public interest considerations.
Held
1. The court held that the published material was capable of bearing the defamatory meanings imputed to it by the plaintiff.
2. The court found that the defamatory meanings were substantially true.
3. The court determined that the defendant had the requisite degree of fault in publishing the material.
4. The court held that the defence of honest opinion was not available to the defendant.
5. The court held that the defendant's publication of the material was not justified by public interest considerations.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the published material was capable of bearing the defamatory meanings imputed by the plaintiff. The court found that the material could indeed bear those meanings, considering the context in which it was published. This decision was based on the language used and the understanding that a reasonable reader could form from the content. In this regard, the court distinguished between the capacity of the material to bear defamatory meanings and the form those meanings took, underscoring that a difference in form does not necessarily equate to a difference in substance.
Next, the court assessed whether the defamatory meanings were substantially true. The court concluded that the meanings were substantially true based on the evidence presented and the context of the publication. The substantial truth of the meanings was a critical factor in the court's decision, as it directly impacted the overall defamatory nature of the material.
The court then considered whether the defendant had the requisite degree of fault in publishing the material. The court determined that the defendant had indeed acted with the necessary degree of fault. This conclusion was reached after evaluating the evidence regarding the defendant's state of mind and the circumstances surrounding the publication.
The court examined the availability of the defence of honest opinion to the defendant. The court held that the defence was not available, finding that the defendant did not genuinely hold the opinion expressed in the publication and that the opinion was not based on facts stated to the defendant. This aspect of the decision highlighted the importance of the genuineness of the opinion and the factual basis upon which it was held.
Finally, the court considered whether the defendant's publication of the material was justified by public interest considerations. The court concluded that the publication was not justified by public interest, as the defendant failed to demonstrate that the publication served the public interest in a meaningful way. This part of the decision underscored the balance the court must strike between freedom of expression and the protection of individuals from defamatory statements.