MAHROUS (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

MAHROUS (Migration) [2021] AATA 2821 (7 July 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Mr Ehab Mohamed Moustafa Kamal MAHROUS

CASE NUMBER:  1911957

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2019/1775365

MEMBER:Hugh Sanderson

DATE:7 July 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa.

Statement made on 07 July 2021 at 4:18pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa – Subclass 602 (Medical Treatment) – medically unfit to depart Australia and genuine intention to remain temporarily – long residence and other visa refusals, reviews and appeals – limited treatment for mental health issues, and continuing work – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 65
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2, cl 602.215

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 2 May 2019 to refuse to grant the applicant a Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The applicant applied for the visa on 10 April 2019. At that time, Class UB contained one subclass, Subclass 602 (Medical Treatment). The criteria for the grant of this visa are set out in Part 602 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations).

  3. The delegate refused to grant the applicant the visa because the delegate was not satisfied that the applicant was medically unfit to depart Australia and was not satisfied the applicant genuinely intended to remain in Australia temporarily and therefore did not meet the criteria in cl 602.215.

    Background

  4. The applicant is a citizen of Egypt and is currently 35 years old. He first arrived in Australia on 7 August 2007 holding a Student visa. He was granted a further series of Student visas, the last one expiring on 30 March 2012. Apart from two months in 2010, he has not departed Australia.

  5. The applicant applied for a Protection visa on 23 March 2012. That application was refused by the Department on 29 June 2012. The applicant withdrew an application for a review of that decision before the Tribunal on 27 May 2013.

  6. The applicant applied for a Partner visa on 20 June 2013. That application was refused by the Department on the basis that the applicant did not meet the Schedule 3 criteria and there were not compelling or compassionate circumstances for not applying that criteria. That decision was affirmed by the Tribunal (differently constituted) on review. The applicant made two successful appeals against the decisions of the Tribunal with the Tribunal on each time it was remitted to it affirming the Department’s decision. On the final occasion, the applicant’s appeal to the Full Federal Court was dismissed on 29 November 2018. The applicant then applied for Ministerial Intervention which was noted as being not referred on 22 February 2019. The applicant then applied for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MAHROUS (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2821
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a Subclass 602 Medical Treatment visa, heard by Hugh Sanderson. The applicant sought to remain in Australia temporarily for medical treatment, specifically for mental health issues, and claimed to be medically unfit to depart Australia. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the criteria for this visa, particularly concerning his medical condition and his genuine intention to remain in Australia temporarily.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant was medically unfit to depart Australia, as defined by clause 602.212(6) of the Migration Regulations 1994, and, if not, whether he genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose of the visa, as required by clause 602.215(1). The Tribunal also considered the applicant's compliance with visa conditions and any other relevant matters.

The Tribunal found that the applicant did not meet the criteria for being medically unfit to depart Australia, as he was only 35 years old and had not applied for a permanent visa that he appeared eligible for, other than health criteria. Furthermore, the Tribunal expressed significant concerns about the medical reports submitted by the applicant's doctor, finding that they uncritically accepted the applicant's claims regarding his mental health issues. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had demonstrated an ability to work while in Australia, which contradicted the assertion of being medically unfit to depart. Consequently, the applicant was required to meet the general criteria for the visa, including a genuine intention to remain temporarily. Given the concerns about the medical evidence and the applicant's history, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant did not meet the requirements for the grant of the visa.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided that the decision under review should be affirmed.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The Subclass 602 Medical Treatment visa is for persons seeking to visit or remain in Australia temporarily for medical treatment or related purposes. The issue in this case is whether the applicant is medically unfit to depart Australia and, if he is not, whether he genuinely intends to remain in Australia temporarily for the purpose of the visa.Is the applicant unfit to depart Australia? An applicant is required to meet the criteria in cl 602.215 unless they meet the criteria in cl 602.212(6). Clause 602.212(6) relates to an applicant being medically unfit to depart Australia. It requires that the applicant:·is in Australia;·has turned 50;·has applied for a permanent visa in Australia and appears to have met all the criteria for that visa other than the health criteria but has been refused the visa; and·is medically unfit to depart Australia due to a permanent or deteriorating disease or condition evidenced in writing by a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth. The applicant is 35 years old. There is no information that would indicate the applicant has applied for any other visa to be able to reside in Australia or that he would be eligible to apply for any other visa to remain in Australia. Accepting the claims made by the applicant as to the medical condition he claims to be suffering from at its highest, there is nothing to indicate that any condition the applicant is suffering from would make him medically unfit to depart Australia. He has shown himself to be able to work while he has been in Australia. Given the above findings, the requirements in cl 602.212(6) are not met. Accordingly, the applicant is required to meet the criteria in cl 602.215(1) and the exemption in cl 602.215(2) does not apply.Does the applicant have a genuine intention to stay temporarily for the visa purpose? Clause 602.215(1) requires that the applicant genuinely intends to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa is granted. The Tribunal must have regard to whether the applicant has complied substantially with the conditions of the last held Substantive visa or any subsequent Bridging visa, as well as the applicant’s intention to comply with the conditions to which the Subclass 602 visa would be subject and any other relevant matter. This requirement will not apply if the applicant is medically unfit to depart Australia as described in cl 602.212(6). As set out above, the applicant does not meet the criteria in cl 602.212(6). The basis of the applicant’s claim to meet the criteria in cl 602.212(2) to be granted a Medical Treatment visa is on the basis that he seeks to obtain medical treatment for mental health issues associated with depression and anxiety as set out in the reports from Dr Abu-Arab. The Tribunal has significant concerns as to the assessment by Dr Abu-Arab of any medical condition suffered by the applicant. Dr Abu-Arab appears to accept uncritically the claims made by the applicant as to the basis for any mental health issues he claims to be suffering from. In the report dated 7 December 2018, Dr Abu-Arab refers to the claims made by the applicant that the applicant played a significant emotional and psychological support for his wife. It was reported that they intend to continue to live together. It was reported that one of the concerns the applicant had, causing his depression, was the inability of his wife to safely live with him in Egypt while any offshore application was being processed. The applicant’s relationship with his wife and her child are repeated in the report from Dr Abu-Arab dated 1 April 2019. No mention is made in that report that the applicant’s relationship with the sponsor of his Partner visa had ended.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the findings above, the applicant does not meet the requirements for the grant of the visa. The decision under review must be affirmed.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Medical Treatment (Visitor) (Class UB) visa.Hugh SandersonMemberATTACHMENTMigration Regulations 1994Schedule 2602.212 (1) The requirements in one of subclauses (2) to (8) are met.Medical treatment(2)All of the following requirements are met:(a) the applicant seeks to obtain medical treatment (including consultation), other than treatment for the purposes of surrogate motherhood, in Australia;(b) arrangements have been concluded to carry out the treatment;(c) if the treatment is an organ transplant:(i)the donor of the relevant organ is accompanying the applicant to Australia; or(ii)all requisite arrangements to effect the donation of the organ have been concluded in Australia;(d) the applicant is free from a disease or condition that is, or may result in the applicant being, a threat to public health in Australia or a danger to the Australian community;(e) arrangements have been concluded for the payment of all costs related to the treatment and all other expenses of the applicant’s stay in Australia, including the expenses of any person accompanying the applicant;(f) either:(i) the payment of those costs will not be a charge on the Commonwealth, a State, a Territory or a public authority in Australia; or(ii)evidence is produced that the relevant government authority has approved the payment of those costs.Organ donor(3)All of the following requirements are met:(a) the applicant seeks to donate an organ for transplant in Australia;(b) if the organ recipient is also an applicant, the requirements described in subclause (2) are met in relation to the organ recipient;(c) the applicant satisfies public interest criterion 4005;(d) arrangements have been concluded for the payment of all costs related to the organ transplant and all other expenses of the applicant’s stay in Australia, including the expenses of any person accompanying the applicant;(e) either:(i)the payment of those costs will not be a charge on the Commonwealth, a State, a Territory or a public authority in Australia; or(ii)evidence is produced that the relevant government authority has approved the payment of those costs.Support person(4)All of the following requirements are met:(a) the applicant seeks to give emotional and other support to an applicant in relation to whom:(i)the requirements described in subclause (2) or (3) are met; or(ii)the requirements described in subclause 675.212(2) or (3) are met; or(iii)the requirements described in subclause 685.212(2) or (3) are met;(b) the person to whom the applicant is to provide support holds:(i)a Subclass 602 visa on the basis that the requirements described in subclause (2) or (3) have been met; or(ii)a Subclass 675 (Medical Treatment (Short Stay)) visa on the basis that the requirements described in subclause 675.212(2) or (3) have been met; or(iii)a Subclass 685 (Medical Treatment (Long Stay)) visa on the basis that the requirements described in subclause 685.212(2) or (3) have been met;(c) the applicant satisfies public interest criterion 4005.Western Province of Papua New Guinea(5)All of the following requirements are met:(a) the applicant is a citizen of Papua New Guinea;(b) the applicant resides in the Western Province of Papua New Guinea;(c) the Department of the government of Queensland that is responsible for health has approved the medical evacuation of the applicant to, or treatment of the applicant in, a hospital in Queensland.Unfit to depart(6) All of the following requirements are met:(a) the applicant is in Australia;(b) the applicant has turned 50;(c) the applicant has applied for a permanent visa while in Australia;(d) the applicant appears to have met all the criteria for the grant of that visa, other than public interest criteria related to health;(e) the applicant has been refused the visa;(f) the applicant is medically unfit to depart Australia due to a permanent or deteriorating disease or health condition, as evidenced by a written statement to that effect from a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth.Financial hardship(7)All of the following requirements are met:(a) one of the following applies:(i)the requirements described in paragraphs (2)(a) to (c) are met in relation to the applicant;(ii)the requirements described in paragraphs (3)(a) and (b) are met in relation to the applicant;(iii)the requirements described in paragraphs (4)(a) and (b) are met in relation to the applicant;(iv)the requirements described in subclause (5) are met in relation to the applicant;(v)the requirements described in paragraphs (6)(a) to (e) are met in relation to the applicant;(b) the applicant is in Australia;(c) the applicant holds:(i)a Subclass 602 visa; or(ii)a Subclass 675 (Medical Treatment (Short Stay)) visa; or(iii)a Subclass 685 (Medical Treatment (Long Stay)) visa;(d) the applicant is suffering financial hardship as a result of changes in the applicant’s circumstances after entering Australia;(e) the applicant, or a member of the applicant’s immediate family, is likely to become a charge on the Commonwealth, a State, a Territory or a public authority in Australia;(f) the applicant, or a member of the applicant’s immediate family, cannot leave Australia for reasons beyond his or her control;(g) the applicant has compelling personal reasons to work in Australia;(h) the applicant satisfies public interest criterion 4005.Compelling personal reasons(8)All of the following requirements are met:(a) one of the following applies:(i)the requirements described in paragraphs (2)(a) to (c) are met in relation to the applicant;(ii)the requirements described in paragraphs (3)(a) and (b) are met in relation to the applicant;(iii)the requirements described in paragraphs (4)(a) and (b) are met in relation to the applicant;(iv)the requirements described in subclause (5) are met in relation to the applicant;(v)the requirements described in paragraphs (6)(a) to (e) are met in relation to the applicant;(b) the applicant is in Australia;(c) the applicant has compelling personal reasons for the grant of the visa;(d) the applicant satisfies public interest criterion 4005, other than paragraph 4005(1)(c).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.