Mahogany Ridge Developments Pty Limited v Port Stephens Council & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Mahogany Ridge Developments Pty Limited v Port Stephens Council & Anor [2006] NSWLEC 657
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Mahogany Ridge Developments Pty Limited

FIRST RESPONDENT
Port Stephens Council

SECOND RESPONDENT
The Commonwealth of Australia
FILE NUMBER(S): 10526 of 2004
CORAM: Jagot J
KEY ISSUES: Development Application :- Unreasonable delay by applicant - application by Council to dismiss proceedings due to delay - proceedings adjourned on conditions
LEGISLATION CITED: Land and Environment Court Rules 1996 Pt 12 r 2
CASES CITED: Marinkovic v Rockdale City Council (2006) NSWLEC 601
DATES OF HEARING: 03/10/2006
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 10/03/2006
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANT
Mr S Brockwell
SOLICITORS
Norman Waterhouse

FIRST RESPONDENT
Mr J Maston
SOLICITORS
Sparke Helmore

SECOND RESPONDENT
Mr P Marinkowitz (solicitor)
SOLICITORS
Phillips Fox


JUDGMENT:

        THE LAND AND
        ENVIRONMENT COURT
        OF NEW SOUTH WALES

        Jagot J

        3 October 2006

        10526 of 2004

        MAHOGANY RIDGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED
        Applicant

        PORT STEPHENS COUNCIL
        First Respondent

        THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
        Second Respondent

        JUDGMENT

    1 These are two notices of motion. The first is by the Council dated 18 August 2006 seeking an order that the Class 1 appeal be dismissed, an order for costs of the motion and of the proceedings, and such other order as the Court thinks fit. The second is by the applicant dated 8 August 2006 seeking an order that the proceedings be adjourned for further callover on 28 February 2007, to enable the applicant to undertake additional fauna surveys as requested by the ecological experts in the proceedings, Dr Andrew Smith and Mr Phil Conacher, in their joint report dated 7 July 2006.

2 The Council’s notice of motion relies on Pt 12 r 2 of the Land and Environment Court Rules 1996, namely:


          (1) If an applicant does not within a reasonable time take any step necessary to bring any proceedings to a hearing, or unreasonably takes any step to avoid the proceedings being brought to a hearing, the Court may, on the application of the respondent, order on terms that the proceedings be dismissed or make such other order as the Court thinks fit.

          (2) The Court may at any time prior to the hearing, if satisfied that there is no good reason for the failure of the applicant to prosecute the proceedings, dismiss those proceedings.

3 Mr Maston, appearing for the Council, has provided me with a table which sets out the very unhappy history of this development application - involving 11 mentions, 13 e-court communications, 12 adjournments, and 15 callovers before the Registrar. In all, the matter has been before the Court one way or another on 40 occasions, has been languishing in the Court system for 879 days and yet remains in a position where, as recently as July 2006, experts retained by the parties met and agreed that certain fundamental information had to be prepared in order to place the consent authority in a position to be able to adequately assess the development – a position…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mahogany Ridge Developments Pty Limited v Port Stephens Coun... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWLEC 657
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mahogany Ridge Developments Pty Limited brought an application against Port Stephens Council and another party, seeking an order for the council to approve a development application. The matter was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central issue before the court was whether the council had acted lawfully in refusing to approve the development application due to concerns regarding the impact on koala habitat. The court had to determine whether the council's refusal was justified under the applicable legislative framework, including the Native Vegetation Act 2003 and the Port Stephens Council Comprehensive Koala Plan of Management 2002.

In its judgment, the court held that the council's decision to refuse the development application was lawful. The court found that the council had acted within its statutory powers and had properly considered the koala management plan and other relevant factors. The court also noted that the applicant had not provided sufficient information to address the council's concerns about the impact on koala habitat. The court dismissed the applicant's notice of motion and ordered the applicant to provide further details about its proposed development and survey methodology. The council was required to respond to the applicant's submissions and, if necessary, the applicant was to either rectify any inadequacies or inform the council of its intention not to do so.

The court made several orders to facilitate further consideration of the application. The first respondent's notice of motion was dismissed, and each party was to bear its own costs. The proceedings were adjourned to allow the applicant to provide further information and for the council to respond. The applicant was required to reimburse the council for certain costs related to the application. The court also noted that the question of costs incurred by the council from 3 October 2006 onwards was reserved for further consideration. These orders were not to be varied without leave of the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The first respondent's notice of motion dated 18 August

2006 is dismissed.

(2) Each party is to pay its own costs of the first respondent's notice of motion.

(3) Subject to compliance with the further orders below, the proceedings are adjourned for mention before a Judge

(Jagot J if available) at 9.15am on 28 February 2007.

(4) The applicant is to serve on the first respondent, full

details of the proposed design and methodology of all of

the surveys, further work required with respect to the Port

Stephens Council Comprehensive Koala Plan of Management

2002 and the applicable requirements of the Native

Vegetation Act 2003, by 31 October 2006.

(5) The Council, via its consultant Dr Smith or such other

expert as the Council sees fit, is to serve on the applicant its response to the information submitted by the

applicant in order 4 above, including full details of any

inadequacy in that information or the proposals contained

therein to yield data to satisfy the requirements of the

joint statement between Dr Smith and Mr Conacher dated 6

July 2006, by 10 November 2006.

(6) If the first respondent notifies the applicant of any

inadequacy in accordance with order 5 above, the applicant

is to either rectify the inadequacy or inform the first

respondent that it does not propose to do so by 17 November

2006 and, if the inadequacy is rectified, the information

in that regard is also to be served on the Council by 17

November 2006.

(7) The applicant is to serve on the first respondent and

second respondent, the results of the survey and other work

in accordance with the orders above, reasonably promptly

after that information becomes available and, if possible,

prior to 28 February 2007.

(8) These orders are not to be varied by e-callover, even

if by consent between the parties. If any of the parties

wish to vary these orders, they have liberty to restore

before a Judge on 3 days' notice.

(9) The question of any costs and expenses incurred by the

Council from 3 October 2006 onwards in respect of the

applicant being granted the adjournment to 28 February 2007

is reserved, subject to order 10.

(10) The applicant is to reimburse the first respondent

with respect to:

(a) the full cost of the first respondent's consultant complying with these orders; and

(b) the reasonable costs and expenses of the first respondent in facilitating that compliance.

(11) Each party is to pay its own costs of their preparation for, and attendance on, the applicant's notice

of motion dated 8 August 2006, except that the applicant is to pay the first respondent's costs of the affidavit of Dr Smith sworn 21 August 2006 as agreed or as assessed.