Mahathevan and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Mahathevan and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2020] AATA 3381 (3 September 2020)

sDivision:                TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/4061

Re:Mahinthan Mahathevan

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member R Olding

Date:3 September 2020

Place:Sydney

1.    The implementation of the decisions under review is stayed until determination of the application for review or further order of the Tribunal.

2.    Order 1 is subject to the Applicant during the operation of the Order:

a.    not undertaking any tax agent services for new clients;

b.    notifying each existing client, in writing, before undertaking any new or continuing tax agent services for the client that:

i.his tax agent registration has been terminated;

ii.he has applied to the Tribunal for review of the termination decision;

iii.the Tribunal has stayed the implementation of the termination decision until the determination of the application for review;

and providing the client with a copy of, or link to, these reasons;

c.     not providing clients with any further explanation about the stays without the prior written consent of an officer of the Board;

d.    complying with all lodgement and payment obligations for the Applicant and his associated entities arising under taxation laws after the date of these orders;

e.    complying with any directions that may be made by the Tribunal in connection with the application for review.

3.    The Applicant’s request for a confidentiality order is refused.

...........[sgd].............................................................

Senior Member R Olding

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – STAY APPLICATION – termination of tax agent registration – where tax agent failed to comply with personal taxation and continuing professional education obligations – where allegations of fraudulent behaviour – prospects of success in application for review – stay granted subject to conditions

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – CONFIDENTIALITY ORDERS – where tax agent sought confidentiality orders pending determination of application for review – where tax agent largely admitted to failures to comply – confidentiality orders refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 35, 41

Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth), ss 2-5, 30-10, 40-25, 60-125, 70-10

CASES

Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 1250

Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] FCA 1235
Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 890

Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R J Olding

3 September 2020

  1. The applicant, Mr Mahathevan, has applied to the Tribunal for review of the decisions of the Tax Practitioners Board (“the Board”) to terminate his registration as a tax agent and that he may not apply for registration for a period of five years (collectively, the “termination decision”).

  2. These reasons concern Mr Mahathevan’s applications for:

    (a)a stay of the termination decision pending the outcome of the review of the termination decision; and

    (b)confidentiality orders.

  3. Particularly so far as there are allegations of denial of procedural fairness by the Board, this matter raises some issues that are canvassed in a recent decision of the Federal Court in Birdseye v Tax Practitioners…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mahathevan and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 3381
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Mahathevan for a stay of a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate his tax agent registration, pending his application for review of that decision. The dispute arose from allegations that Mr Mahathevan had assisted clients in making loan applications supported by false notices of assessment, and that he had failed to comply with his personal taxation lodgement and payment obligations, as well as lodgement obligations for associated entities. The application was heard by R Olding SM of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it was desirable to grant a stay of the Board's termination decision to secure the effectiveness of Mr Mahathevan's application for review. This required the Tribunal to consider several factors, including the prospects of success of the review application, the consequences for Mr Mahathevan if a stay were refused, the public interest, the consequences for the Board in carrying out its functions, and whether the review would be rendered nugatory without a stay. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's obligation to provide material capable of engendering the requisite opinion for granting a stay.

In his reasoning, the SM noted that Mr Mahathevan had largely admitted to failures in meeting his personal and associated entity lodgement obligations, although these were now up to date. Regarding the more serious allegations of assisting clients with false notices of assessment, the SM found that while there was no direct evidence of Mr Mahathevan's involvement, the Board had relied on limited evidence. The SM concluded that there was a reasonable prospect that the Tribunal would not be satisfied these serious allegations were made out, and that a stay was desirable to ensure the effectiveness of the review. Consequently, a stay of the termination decision was granted, subject to conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Where the Board terminates a tax agent’s registration following an investigation, the Board may also determine a period of not more than five years in which the tax agent may not re-apply for registration.[8][8] TASA, s 40-25.Staying decisions The making of an application to the Tribunal to review a decision does not, in itself, affect the operation of a decision.[9] However, a party to a proceeding before the Tribunal, subject to exceptions that do not arise in this case, may apply for a stay of a decision under subsection 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the “AAT Act”), which states:The Tribunal may, on request being made by a party to a proceeding before the Tribunal (in this section referred to as the relevant proceeding), if the Tribunal is of the opinion that it is desirable to do so after taking into account the interests of any persons who may be affected by the review, make such order or orders staying or otherwise affecting the operation or implementation of the decision to which the relevant proceeding relates or a part of that decision as the Tribunal considers appropriate for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review.(Emphases added.)[9] AAT Act, s 41(1). The considerations to which I consider it is appropriate for the Tribunal to have regard in determining whether to make a stay order are:(a)The prospects of success of the application for review;(b)The consequence for the applicant of refusing a stay;(c)The public interest;(d)The consequences for the respondent in carrying out its functions depending on whether a stay is granted;(e)Whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory if a stay where not granted; and (f)Other relevant matters.[10][10] Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798, 4. Consistent with the inclusion of “other relevant matters” at subparagraph (f) above, and as Logan J emphasised in Birdseye, these considerations are neither prescriptive nor exhaustive of the matters that I may take into consideration. The statutory task required of the Tribunal is to form an opinion whether it is desirable to grant the stay or related relief as it considers appropriate for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review. As Logan J stated in Birdseye at [23]:…an applicant for a stay is in no way required to demonstrate that he, she or it, as the case may be, must succeed on an application for review on the merits of the decision. At most, all that one must show is that there is a basis in the material before the Tribunal for forming the opinion that it is “desirable”, in order to preserve the effectiveness of the review, to grant a stay. . .”[11][11] [2020] FCA 1235, 23. In approaching that task, I must bear in mind that, the Tribunal’s role being administrative in nature and in the absence of any statutory imposition, there is no formal onus upon an applicant to prove the case for a stay. Nevertheless, “there must be some material before the Tribunal which is reasonably capable of engendering the requisite opinion”[12] as to the desirability of granting a stay. Such material may be found in the material before the Board or in additional evidence introduced on behalf of Mr Mahathevan or which “at least can be shown to be reasonably in prospect of being introduced”.[13][12] Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] FCA 1235, 25.[13] Birdseye v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] FCA 1235, 24.Relevance of denial of procedural fairness

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For reasons that were not explained, Mr Mahathevan did not provide an affidavit in support of the stay application. However, his solicitor, Mr Vasilios Fragos, filed five affidavits which he deposed he was authorised to make on behalf of Mr Mahathevan. One of those affidavits exhibited a copy of Mr Mahathevan’s submissions to the Board before it made the termination decision.(a) Assisting eight clients to make loan applications to the Australia & New Zealand Banking Corporation supported by false notices of assessment of income tax (the “ANZ allegations”). Mr Mahathevan’s submissions to the Board deny this allegation. He does not seem to deny that false notices of assessment were provided to the bank but says any falsification was undertaken without his knowledge or approval. It is neither possible nor appropriate to reach a firm conclusion at this time on whether this allegation is made out. However, based on the materials before the Tribunal, which Mr O’Mahoney, who appeared for the Board, confirmed represent all relevant materials on this issue,[15] it is true to say that there is no direct evidence of Mr Mahathevan’s involvement in the falsification of the notices.[15] Transcript, page 23, lines 9-10. The Board was only able to speak to one of the eight clients. The record of the telephone call suggests that the relevant documents were provided to Mr Mahathevan by the client.[16] That is one of the bases on which the Board accepted the allegation. Two responses to formal information notices were received, each denying Mr Mahathevan assisted with the mortgage application, but their probative value may be in some doubt due to the apparently identical handwriting on each response.[17][16] T5, pages 595-596.[17] T5, pages 597-8. Obviously, the fate of these allegations will depend upon the written and oral evidence, including the foreshadowed cross-examination of Mr Mahathevan, in the hearing of the application for review. On the material currently before the Tribunal that was drawn to my attention, I accept there is a reasonable prospect the Tribunal will not be satisfied these serious allegations are made out.(b) Failing to meet various taxation lodgement and payment obligations.Failure to meet individual lodgement obligations So far as they relate to his own lodgement obligations as an individual, the uncontested allegations are that Mr Mahathevan:(a)failed to lodge PAYG Payment Summary Annual Returns (“PSARs”) for the 2016 and 2017 income years; and(b)failed to lodge, by their respective due dates, activity statements for the periods ending:i.March 2012 to December 2013; ii.June and December 2014;iii.June 2015;iv.June 2017;v.June 2018; andvi.December 2018. Based on affidavit evidence from Mr Fragos attaching copies of Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) entries, these personal obligations are now up to date. The Board did not suggest otherwise.Failure to meet lodgement obligations for associated entities Mr Mahathevan failed to ensure income tax returns for seven associated entities were lodged by their respective due dates, involving failure to lodge almost 30 returns as required.