Mahamede v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2020] HCATrans 125

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Sydney  No S86 of 2020

B e t w e e n -

JALAL MAHAMEDE

Plaintiff

and

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Defendant

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

Second Defendant

EDELMAN J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

FROM BRISBANE BY VIDEO CONNECTION TO SYDNEY

ON TUESDAY, 1 SEPTEMBER 2020, AT 9.30 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

HIS HONOUR:   By an application filed on 29 May 2020 the plaintiff seeks various forms of relief against the Minister for Home Affairs and the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs.  For the reasons that I now publish I dismiss the application.

The orders are:

1.The plaintiff’s application be dismissed under r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth).

2.        The plaintiff play the costs of the defendants.

I publish those orders.  I direct that the reasons as published be incorporated into the transcript.

The plaintiff is currently held in immigration detention.  He brings this application by common solicitors with several others whose applications I decide today in Kazemi v Minister for Home Affairs[1], Khan v Minister for Home Affairs[2], and Mokhlis v Minister for Home Affairs[3].  The relief sought in this Court's original jurisdiction is for a writ of habeas corpus, declarations and injunctions.

The plaintiff is from Iran and arrived by boat in Australia in July 2013. He was subsequently transferred to Nauru. In 2018, he was assaulted in Nauru. He lost some of his teeth, was knocked unconscious, and has been suffering headaches since the assault. On 22 October 2019, the plaintiff was transferred to Australia pursuant to s 198B of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to receive medical treatment.

Since the plaintiff does not hold a visa, he is an unlawful non‑citizen pursuant to s 14 of the Migration Act. Sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act require that he be held in immigration detention whilst he is in Australia, and he has been so held since his arrival in October 2019.  The plaintiff’s evidence is that at the time of his arrival in Australia for medical treatment he was told by his case officer that an application was being made for him to reside in the community and that this would take four to six months.  He says that his medical treatment finished at the end of 2019.  The defendants’ evidence is that during 2020 the plaintiff has been treated by a dentist and a general practitioner and that he has ongoing treatment for impaired vision, asthma, chronic pain in his left knee, and mental health concerns.

Section 197AB of the Migration Act empowers the Minister to make a residence determination that would allow the plaintiff to reside at a specified place instead of being held in immigration detention. Section 197AC(1) provides that in such circumstances the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mahamede v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] HCATrans 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, an Iranian national who arrived in Australia in 2013 and was subsequently transferred to Nauru, sought various forms of relief in the High Court of Australia against the Minister for Home Affairs and the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs. The plaintiff, who had been assaulted in Nauru in 2018 and transferred to Australia in October 2019 for medical treatment, was being held in immigration detention as an unlawful non-citizen. He alleged that his continued detention, particularly in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and inadequate social distancing, was causing him severe mental and physical harm and constituted a breach of the duty of care owed to him by the defendants.

The legal issues before the Court included whether the plaintiff was entitled to a writ of habeas corpus for his release from immigration detention, whether declarations and injunctions should be granted restraining the Minister from breaching a statutory or common law duty of care by holding him in indefinite custody causing him severe harm or placing him at risk of self-harm, and whether it was in the public interest for the Minister to consider exercising the power under s 197AB of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to make a residence determination allowing him to reside in the community. The defendants contended that the plaintiff's application lacked any arguable basis for the relief sought and should be dismissed under rule 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), or alternatively, remitted to the Federal Circuit Court.

The Court dismissed the plaintiff's application, finding that it did not disclose any arguable basis for any of the relief sought. This decision was made pursuant to rule 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), with the Court's reasoning being consistent with its decisions in related cases heard concurrently. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the defendants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff in this case, Jalal Mahamede, is an Iranian national who arrived in Australia by boat in July 2013 and was subsequently transferred to Nauru. In 2018, he was assaulted in Nauru, resulting in physical injuries and ongoing health issues. He was transferred to Australia on 22 October 2019 under section 198B of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to receive medical treatment. Since he does not hold a visa, he is considered an unlawful non-citizen under section 14 of the Migration Act. As a result, he has been held in immigration detention since his arrival in Australia, as required by sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act.

The plaintiff claims that upon his arrival in Australia, he was informed by his case officer that an application for him to reside in the community was being made, with an expected processing time of four to six months. He asserts that his medical treatment concluded at the end of 2019. However, the defendants' evidence indicates that the plaintiff has received ongoing treatment for various health conditions, including dental care, general practitioner services, impaired vision, asthma, chronic knee pain, and mental health concerns throughout 2020. Despite these health needs, the plaintiff's case has not yet been referred to the defendants for consideration of a residence determination under section 197AB of the Migration Act.

The plaintiff argues that he is suffering severe mental and physical harm due to his detention and that the conditions of his detention do not allow for appropriate social distancing. He contends that his continued detention breaches the duty of care owed to him by the defendants. He seeks a writ of habeas corpus for his release from immigration detention, declarations regarding the severe pain or suffering caused by his detention, and injunctions to prevent the Ministers from breaching their duty of care by continuing to detain him. Additionally, he requests a declaration that it is in the public interest for the Ministers to consider exercising their power under section 197AB of the Migration Act in his case.

This matter came before the High Court of Australia as an application for a writ of habeas corpus, declarations, and injunctions against the Minister for Home Affairs and the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs. The plaintiff, an Iranian national who had arrived in Australia by boat in July 2013 and had been held in immigration detention since his transfer from Nauru in October 2019, filed an application on 29 May 2020. This application was heard by Edelman J in the High Court's original jurisdiction. The plaintiff, represented by common solicitors with several others in related cases, sought relief on the basis of alleged severe mental and physical harm caused by his detention and the conditions within the detention facility. The application was dismissed, and the plaintiff ordered to pay the defendants' costs, with the Court finding that the application did not disclose an arguable basis for the relief sought. This decision followed similar rulings in related cases such as Kazemi v Minister for Home Affairs and Khan v Minister for Home Affairs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff have an arguable basis for the relief of a writ of habeas corpus?
2. Does the plaintiff have an arguable basis for the declarations sought regarding the harm caused by his detention?
3. Does the plaintiff have an arguable basis for the injunctions sought to restrain the Minister from breaching a duty of care?
4. Does the plaintiff have an arguable basis for the declaration that it is in the public interest for the Minister to consider exercising the s 197AB residence determination power?
5. Should the application be dismissed pursuant to r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), or remitted to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia for determination?

Held
1. The plaintiff does not have an arguable basis for the relief of a writ of habeas corpus; the application was dismissed.
2. The plaintiff does not have an arguable basis for the declarations sought regarding the harm caused by his detention; the application was dismissed.
3. The plaintiff does not have an arguable basis for the injunctions sought to restrain the Minister from breaching a duty of care; the application was dismissed.
4. The plaintiff does not have an arguable basis for the declaration that it is in the public interest for the Minister to consider exercising the s 197AB residence determination power; the application was dismissed.
5. The application should be dismissed pursuant to r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth); the application was dismissed and the plaintiff ordered to pay the costs of the defendants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiff in this case, currently held in immigration detention, sought relief from the High Court in the form of a writ of habeas corpus, declarations, and injunctions. The High Court dismissed the application pursuant to r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth) and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs. The Court found that the plaintiff's application did not disclose an arguable basis for any of the relief sought in any of the three categories. The plaintiff's case was considered alongside three other cases, which were also dismissed on the same grounds.

The Court's reasoning regarding the plaintiff's request for a writ of habeas corpus focused on the principle that habeas corpus is a remedy available to challenge the lawfulness of detention, but only if the detention itself is unlawful. The plaintiff's detention was authorised under the Migration Act, and the Court found that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence to suggest that his detention was unlawful. The Court applied the legal principle that habeas corpus is not available to challenge the merits of a decision to detain, but only the lawfulness of the detention itself. Therefore, the plaintiff did not have an arguable basis for the relief of a writ of habeas corpus.

The Court's reasoning regarding the plaintiff's request for declarations and injunctions focused on the principle that such relief is only available if the plaintiff can demonstrate that there is a real and imminent risk of harm. The Court found that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence to suggest that he was at a real risk of harm as a result of his detention. The Court applied the legal principle that declarations and injunctions are only available if the plaintiff can demonstrate a real and imminent risk of harm, and that the risk must be more than theoretical or speculative. Therefore, the plaintiff did not have an arguable basis for the declarations and injunctions sought.

The Court's reasoning regarding the plaintiff's request for a declaration that it is in the public interest for the Minister to consider exercising the s 197AB residence determination power focused on the principle that such a declaration is only available if the plaintiff can demonstrate that there is a real and imminent risk of harm, and that the Minister's failure to exercise the power would result in that harm. The Court found that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence to suggest that there was a real and imminent risk of harm, or that the Minister's failure to exercise the power would result in that harm. The Court applied the legal principle that a declaration is only available if the plaintiff can demonstrate a real and imminent risk of harm, and that the risk must be more than theoretical or speculative. Therefore, the plaintiff did not have an arguable basis for the declaration sought.

In reaching its decision, the Court relied on prior authority, including the decision in Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth[4], which established that habeas corpus is not available to challenge the merits of a decision to detain, but only the lawfulness of the detention itself. The Court also relied on the decision in Al-Kateb v Godwin[5], which established that declarations and injunctions are only available if the plaintiff can demonstrate a real and imminent risk of harm, and that the risk must be more than theoretical or speculative. The Court followed these authorities in finding that the plaintiff did not have an arguable basis for any of the relief sought.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an application for relief under the original jurisdiction of the High Court will be dismissed pursuant to r 25.09.1 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth) if it does not disclose an arguable basis for any of the relief sought. This principle applies regardless of the category of relief sought, and applies equally to applications for habeas corpus, declarations, injunctions, and declarations regarding the exercise of statutory powers. The Court departed from no prior authority in reaching this decision.

[4][2011] HCA 25.[5][2004] HCA 37.