Magarry v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read
CITATION: Magarry v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch [2012] QCAT 378
PARTIES: Alan Jeffrey Magarry
(Applicant)
v
Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR249-11
MATTER TYPE: General administrative review matters
HEARING DATE: 11 May 2012
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: K O’Callaghan, Senior Member
DELIVERED ON: 21 August 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The decision to reject Mr Magarry’s application to renew his firearms licence number 10100485 and to revoke Mr Magarry’s collectors licence number 42000291 is set aside.

2.    Mr Magarry’s firearms license number 10100485 is renewed and his collectors licence number 42000291 is reinstated.

CATCHWORDS:

Review – Renewal of firearms licence – not a fit and proper person – breach of Weapons Act – importation of firearms – mental illness – post traumatic stress disorder

Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009, s 20
Weapons Act 1990, ss 10B(2)(a)(ii) and 3

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond & Ors (1994) ALR 56
Comalco Aluminium (Bellbay Ltd) v O’Connor & Ors (1995) 131
Director of Public Prosecutions [1991] 1 VR 51
Stowers v Smart  [2007] QDC 4

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: Alan Jeffrey Magarry represented by Mr Peter Kuskie of SK Lawyers
RESPONDENT: Queensland Police Service represented by Sergeant Clayton Bradford

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mr Magarry has asked the Tribunal to review the decision of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing Branch (QPS) to reject his application to renew his firearms license and to revoke his collectors license.

  2. The information notice advises that the decision was made on the basis that it was considered Mr Magarry was no longer a fit and proper person to hold a license due to it not being in the public interest. 

  3. Mr Magarry had a successful and exemplary career as a Queensland Police Officer from 1983 up until September 2009.  At this time he held the rank of inspector.  He achieved much in his career including receipt of Premier’s awards and recommendations from the Commissioner of Police.  He engaged in significant volunteer work particularly with indigenous youth in Mt Isa where he was stationed for some time. 

  4. He also endured significant torturous experiences as an officer – including attending fatal road accidents, one in which a motorcyclist was decapitated; a traumatic accidental fatal shooting, a road accident where a man’s arm had been torn off and Mr Magarry had to retrieve the arm.  On another occasion he was deployed by a defence force helicopter to recover decaying disfigured bodies from a plane crash where his safety was put at risk.  He was almost killed when an offender attempted to set fire to himself with fuel and a lighter.  He was the first officer on the scene of a murder suicide of three small children by their father and was charged with the task of notifying their grandparents.

  5. He had a long association with the use of firearms through his employment.  He had conducted weapons training courses and was an explosives expert.  He conducted other business…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Magarry v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCAT 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alan Jeffrey Magarry sought a review of the decision of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing Branch (QPS) to reject his application to renew his firearms license and to revoke his collectors license. The QPS had rejected Mr Magarry’s application on the basis that he was no longer a fit and proper person to hold a license due to it not being in the public interest. Mr Magarry had a successful and exemplary career as a Queensland Police Officer from 1983 up until September 2009. At this time he held the rank of inspector and had achieved much in his career including receipt of Premier’s awards and recommendations from the Commissioner of Police. He engaged in significant volunteer work particularly with indigenous youth in Mt Isa where he was stationed for some time. He also endured significant torturous experiences as an officer – including attending fatal road accidents, one in which a motorcyclist was decapitated; a traumatic accidental fatal shooting, a road accident where a man’s arm had been torn off and Mr Magarry had to retrieve the arm. On another occasion he was deployed by a defence force helicopter to recover decaying disfigured bodies from a plane crash where his safety was put at risk. He was almost killed when an offender attempted to set fire to himself with fuel and a lighter. He was the first officer on the scene of a murder suicide of three small children by their father and was charged with the task of notifying their grandparents. He had a long association with the use of firearms through his employment. He had conducted weapons training courses and was an explosives expert. He conducted other business activities which involved the use of firearms, one was the shooting of feral animals the other involved the making of plaques. In that business he was engaged by army and police services and their members to create plaques which exhibited moulds of weapons to commemorate events or achievements. His life began to unravel in September 2009 when customs officers intercepted four parcels at the Brisbane airport. The parcels were addressed to a “Roy Worchester” at Mr Magarry’s home address. They were labelled “marine parts” however on inspection they were found to contain parts and accessories belonging to a derivative of an M16 military assault rifle. A search warrant was executed at Mr Magarry’s house at which point several items were seized and concern was raised as to possible breaches of the Weapons Act 1990 regarding storage and possession of weapons. Mr Magarry was not at home at the time. He was on a shooting trip in Cairns. Mr Magarry participated in a disciplinary interview in September 2009 conducted by the internal investigation branch to answer questions in relation to the items seized under the warrant. The decision was made not to prosecute him or proceed with any misconduct charges as there was insufficient evidence to do so and it was determined that it was not in the public interest to do so. Following these events Mr Magarry suffered a severe breakdown and came under the care of psychiatrist Dr Greaves. He was stood down from the force in November 2009 and formally retired in June 2010. In July 2010 Magarry pleaded guilty in the Magistrates Court to three charges under the Customs Act 1901 (Cth): two charges of importing firearm parts and 1 charge of importing a prohibited firearm accessory. The Magistrate imposed a nominal punishment and no conviction was recorded. On the prosecutor’s appeal, Judge Griffin in the District Court found the Magistrate had erred and allowed the appeal however on rehearing he found that it was appropriate that no conviction be recorded. He made the decision accepting medical evidence that Mr Magarry’s actions were directly connected with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder he was suffering at the time. Although no conviction was recorded (which would have meant in effect automatic disqualification of Mr Magarry’s entitlement to hold a license) the QPS made the decision that in light of what had occurred Mr Magarry was no longer a fit and proper person to hold a license when considering the public interest. The Tribunal found that Mr Magarry’s purpose in importing the goods was not sinister, it was in fact for use in his business of constructing plaques. The Tribunal was guided by the findings of Judge Griffin based on the evidence of Dr Greaves that the acts of deception which lead to the offences were out of character and were closely connected to and a result of the post traumatic stress disorder he suffered from the tortuous experiences he had endured in his role as a police officer. Dr Greaves said Mr Magarry was still suffering from depression but was having treatment. He now had full insight into the effects that the post traumatic stress disorder had on his judgment making ability. She had no concerns regarding the possible misuse by Mr Magarry of weapons but rather said that it would be in the interests of his rehabilitation to continue to have access to his license so that he could continue to engage in his plaque making business and recreational shooting. The Tribunal found that there was no real prospect of Mr Magarry misusing his weapons and that his right to possess firearms was not a real risk to public and individual safety. The decision not to renew Mr Magarry’s firearms licence and to cancel his collectors licence should be set aside. His firearms licence should be renewed and his collectors licence reinstated.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established