OFFICIAL NOTICE
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Application : No. 708104 in the name of MADNESS GAMING PRODUCTS, INC.
Title: Method and Apparatus for Random Prize Selection in Wagering Games
Action: Opposition under Section 59 by B.C.D. MECANIQUE LTEE
Decision: Issued .
Abstract
The opposition was upheld on the ground that the invention does not involve an inventive step in light of the prior art. The grounds that the application lacks novelty and does not comply with section 40 were not upheld.
The invention relates to a method and apparatus in which a wagering game, such as "Blackjack" ("the underlying game") is overlain by another game in the form of a random jackpot game in which the awarding of a prize is based upon a predetermined event occurring in the underlying game. The set of prizes from which the random jackpot prize is selected in the random jackpot game is also predetermined.
The method claims where found to be novel and to involve an inventive step. However, the apparatus claims, which make extensive use of means plus function language, were found to lack an inventive step when properly construed.
One document which was relied on to establish lack of an inventive step was a patent document allegedly accessible to the public in the Dominican Republic Patent Department. While the document may have been open to public inspection in this way a few months before the priority date of the present claims, the evidence suggested that no publication beyond this had occurred before that date. The document was in the Spanish language. This document was found to be not one that it could reasonably be expected to be ascertained by the person skilled in the art.
The claims of the opposed application were found to be entitled to their claimed priority date which resulted in another document relied on to establish lack of inventive step not being prior art information for the purposes of subsection 7(2) of the Patents Act (inventive step) due to it having a later publication date than the claimed priority date.
Costs were awarded against the applicant.
PATENTS ACT 1990
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Re:Patent No. No. 708104 in the name of MADNESS GAMING PRODUCTS, INC., and opposition thereto by B.C.D. MECANIQUE LTEE under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990.
BACKGROUND
Application 708104 was filed under the Patent Cooperation Treaty as International Application PCT/US97/05185 by Madness Gaming Products, Inc. on 28 March 1997, claiming priority from United States applications 60/014,657 and 08/761,492 filed on 2 April 1996 and 6 December 1996, respectively. Australia was one of the countries designated. PCT/US97/05185 was published under the PCT as WO 97/36658, and in Australia was allocated the application number 24275/97. The application entered the national phase of processing on 16 September 1998, having undergone international preliminary examination under the PCT. After being subjected to modified examination based on a granted United States Patent, the application…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Madness Gaming Products, Inc v B.C.D. Mecanique Ltee and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] APO 70
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The invention relates to a method and apparatus in which a wagering game, such as "Blackjack" ("the underlying game") is overlain by another game in the form of a random jackpot game in which the awarding of a prize is based upon a predetermined event occurring in the underlying game. The set of prizes from which the random jackpot prize is selected in the random jackpot game is also predetermined. The method claims where found to be novel and to involve an inventive step. However, the apparatus claims, which make extensive use of means plus function language, were found to lack an inventive step when properly construed. One document which was relied on to establish lack of an inventive step was a patent document allegedly accessible to the public in the Dominican Republic Patent Department. While the document may have been open to public inspection in this way a few months before the priority date of the present claims, the evidence suggested that no publication beyond this had occurred before that date. The document was in the Spanish language. This document was found to be not one that it could reasonably be expected to be ascertained by the person skilled in the art. The claims of the opposed application were found to be entitled to their claimed priority date which resulted in another document relied on to establish lack of inventive step not being prior art information for the purposes of subsection 7(2) of the Patents Act (inventive step) due to it having a later publication date than the claimed priority date. Costs were awarded against the applicant.
The court's decision was that the opposition was upheld in part, and the applicant was given sixty days to propose amendments to overcome its shortcomings. If suitable amendments were not filed within that time, the application would be refused. Costs were awarded against the applicant.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi