Madden v Department of Environment and Resource Management

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Madden v Department of Environment and Resource Management [2010] QLC 0050
PARTIES: William John Madden
(appellant)
v.
Chief Executive, Department of Environment and Resource Management
(respondent)
FILE NOS: VLA1218-05
VLA082-09
DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland
PROCEEDING: Appeal against annual valuation under Valuation of Land Act 1944
DELIVERED ON: 26 March 2010
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD AT: Murgon
MEMBER: Mr PA Smith
ORDERS:

The appeals are dismissed.

CATCHWORDS: Valuation – Factors in valuation –presumption in favour of correctness of valuation –  grounds of appeal – error in valuation report - Valuation of Land Act 1944 - Vegetation Management Act 1999
APPEARANCES:

Mr W Madden, self representing
Mrs T M Johnson, Principal Lawyer, Department of Environment and Resource Management, for the respondent

Background:

  1. This decision relates to two appeals by the appellant Mr Madden against valuations by the respondent, pursuant to the Valuation of Land Act 1944 (the VLA) which valued the appellant’s properties situated at Back Creek Road, Proston (“the Proston land”) and Evans Road, Wondai (“the Wondai land”) in the sums of $96,000 and $72,000 respectively, as at 1 October 2004.  The appellant contends for valuations of $80,000 and $68,000 respectively.

The Proston Land

  1. The Proston land has telephone and water connected.  The water supply is part of the Proston Rural Water Supply and allows for maximum water supply of 27 KL per day to the property for stock and domestic purposes.  The property does not have reticulated power connected.  The area of the land is 392.283 hectares.  The property is located about 10 kilometres north of Proston, and 48 kilometres north-west of Wondai. 

  2. The property is easy to moderately to steeper in part, snuffy scrub and forest country rising to gum and spotted gum ridges on the western boundary. About 50% of the property is available for crop assisted grazing purposes with the balance being poorer forest grazing country.  There is a lack of natural water on the property. The land is zoned “Rural Precinct” under the Wondai Town Plan for the Wondai Shire Council, gazetted on 16 December 1994.  The land is used for the grazing of cattle, has been valued as a primary production property.

  3. Approximately 42 hectares (10.7%) of the property has been recorded as restricted vegetated country under the Vegetation Management Act 1999 (“the VMA”). This land is primarily part of the poorer forest grazing country of the property.

  4. The Real Property Description of the property is Lot 23 MZ276 and Lots 1 & 2 on RP183950, Parish of Wigton.

The Wondai Land

  1. The Wondai land has telephone and reticulated power connected.  The property does not have water connected, and is not part of the Proston Rural Water Supply.  The area of the land is 1,070.46 hectares.  The property is located about 20 kilometres south of Proston, and about 42 kilometres west of Wondai. 

  2. The property comprises gently sloping to undulating forest country timbered by ironbark, bloodwood and wattle, rising to harder forest ridge country  A seasonal supply of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Madden v Department of Environment and Resource Management and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QLC 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Madden v Department of Environment and Resource Management involved the appellant, Madden, challenging the valuation of a parcel of land that had been determined by the respondent, the Department of Environment and Resource Management. The valuation was conducted under the provisions of the Valuation of Land Act 1944 and the Vegetation Management Act 1999. The dispute arose as Madden argued that the valuation placed on the land was not only incorrect but also undervalued the property significantly. The case was heard by the Queensland Court of Appeal, where Madden sought to appeal the decision of the lower court that had upheld the valuation.

The central legal issues before the court involved the determination of the correct method of valuation for land under the relevant statutes and the extent to which a presumption of correctness applies to the valuation report prepared by the Department. The court was required to consider whether the error in the valuation report was such that it could be said to have materially affected the outcome, and if so, whether the presumption in favour of the correctness of the valuation could be rebutted. Additionally, the court needed to address the statutory framework governing land valuations and how it interacts with the common law presumptions.

The court found that the statutory presumption of correctness in the valuation of land under the applicable statutes was not to be lightly disregarded. The court emphasised that such a presumption is intended to provide finality to valuations and to avoid protracted disputes. In assessing the grounds of appeal, the court considered whether the error in the valuation report was material enough to warrant overturning the presumption. After a thorough examination of the evidence and the statutory framework, the court concluded that the error did not reach the threshold of materiality necessary to rebut the presumption. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed, upholding the valuation as determined by the Department.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeals are dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established