Madden Developments Pty Ltd t/as Stroud Homes v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Madden Developments Pty Ltd t/as Stroud Homes v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2022] QCATA 95

PARTIES: MADDEN DEVLOPMENTS PTY LTD T/AS STROUD HOMES

(applicant/appellant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL121-20

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR076-19

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

5 July 2022

HEARING DATE:

14 December 2021

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal is refused.

2.   The appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – ERROR OF LAW – INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW – INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE’S FINDINGS OF FACT – where tribunal confirmed decision by QBCC to issue direction to rectify to builder – where builder asserted that alternative building solution had been adopted in respect of subject work – whether tribunal considered alternative building solution – where builder asserted unfairness in giving direction to rectify – whether tribunal considered all relevant matters in confirming decision of the QBCC to issue direction to rectify – whether tribunal discretion miscarried

Building Act 1975 (Qld), s 14(2), s 68A

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 72(5)

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 142(1), s 142(3)(b), s 146, s 147(1), s 147(2), s 147(3)

Cachia v Grech [2009] NSWCA 232

Ericson v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCA 391
Glenwood Properties Pty Ltd v Delmoss Pty Ltd [1986] 2 Qd R 388
Harrison & Anor v Meehan [2017] QCA 315
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
Laidlaw v. Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QCAT 70
Madden Developments Pty v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2020] QCAT 97
McIver Bulk Liquid Haulage Pty Ltd v Fruehauf Australia Pty Ltd [1989] 2 Qd R 577
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332
Officer JGB v Deputy Commissioner Gollschewski and Anor [2016] QCAT 348
Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Group Kildey Pty Ltd; Queensland Building and Construction Commission v JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd [2016] QCATA 10
QUYD Pty Ltd v Marvass Pty Ltd [2009] 1 Qd R 41
Sun v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 52
Woods v Multi-Sport Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 186 ALR 145

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

J Hewson instructed by Hearthstone Legal

Respondent:

R de Luchi instructed by Queensland Building and Construction Commission

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Madden Developments (the builder) constructed a townhouse for Mr and Mrs Pickering (the homeowners). The homeowners subsequently complained to the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) about defective building work. The QBCC decided to issue a direction to rectify to the builder relating to the failure by the builder to seal exterior masonry walls. The relevant walls were the side walls of the townhouse. The builder applied to the Tribunal to review the decision by the QBCC. The Tribunal confirmed the reviewable decision.[1]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Madden Developments Pty Ltd t/as Stroud Homes v Queensland B... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCATA 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Madden Developments Pty Ltd t/as Stroud Homes v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, the builder has appealed the Tribunal's decision which upheld a direction issued by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) to rectify certain building work. The dispute centred on the adequacy of the builder's waterproofing solution for the external walls of a townhouse, which failed to meet the performance requirements of the Building Code of Australia (BCA). The QBCC had issued a direction to rectify, which the builder contested, leading to the Tribunal's decision being appealed.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal erred in its finding that the builder's proposed alternative solution for waterproofing the external walls was inadequate. The court had to determine if the Tribunal appropriately considered the builder's claim that an alternative building solution had been adopted and if the Tribunal's discretion in confirming the QBCC's decision was correctly exercised. Additionally, the court examined whether the Tribunal had taken into account all relevant matters in confirming the decision of the QBCC to issue the direction to rectify.

The court found that the Tribunal was correct in its approach and findings. The builder had failed to provide appropriate expert evidence to demonstrate that the furring channel solution complied with the performance requirements of the BCA. The evidence presented by the builder's expert did not sufficiently show that the proposed solution met the required standards. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was sound, as it was based on the absence of expert approval for the alternative performance solution. Furthermore, the court upheld that the Tribunal had considered all relevant factors in confirming the QBCC's decision, and there was no miscarriage of discretion.

The final orders of the court were that leave to appeal was refused and the appeal was dismissed. The decision of the Tribunal was upheld, and the builder was required to rectify the identified defects in accordance with the QBCC's direction.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is refused.

2. The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The builder has appealed the decision of the Tribunal. The decision of the Tribunal at first instance Before turning to the findings by the learned member it is appropriate to say something about the relevant requirements in respect of the particular building work the subject of the direction to rectify. The Building Code of Australia (BCA) is a uniform set of technical provisions for the design and construction of buildings and other structures. A building solution must meet performance requirements. A building solution is an alternative solution, or a solution which complies with the ‘deemed-to-satisfy provisions’ or a combination of the two. An ‘alternative solution’:(a)must comply with performance requirements; or(b)the solution is at least the equivalent to the deemed-to-satisfy provisions. An ‘alternative solution’ must be shown to comply with relevant performance requirements through one of, or a combination of, assessment methods one of which is ‘expert judgement’. Section A2.3 of the BCA provides: Deemed-to-Satisfy Solution (1) A solution that complies with the Deemed-to-Satisfy Provisions is deemed to have met the Performance Requirements. (2) A Deemed-to-Satisfy Solution can show compliance with the Deemed-to-Satisfy Provisions through one or more of the following Assessment Methods: (a) Evidence of suitability in accordance with Part A5 that shows the use of a material, product, plumbing and drainage product, form of construction or design meets a Deemed-to-Satisfy Provision. (b) Expert Judgement.[2] [2]Ibid, [44]. Under Schedule 3 of the BCA, Expert Judgement means: … the judgement of an expert who has the qualifications and experience to determine whether Performance Solution or Deemed-to-Satisfy Solution complies with the Performance Requirements.[3][3]Ibid, [45]. Performance Requirement P2.2.2 of the Building Code of Australia (BCA) provides that a roof and external wall must prevent the penetration of water that could cause unhealthy or dangerous conditions or loss of amenity for applicants or undue dampness or deterioration of building elements.[4] [4]Appeal Book, page 705. Part 3.3.4.0 of the BCA provides, inter alia, that performance requirement P2.2.2 is satisfied for weatherproofing of masonry if it is carried out in accordance with Australian Standard (AS) 3700 or AS 4773 Parts 1 and 2. This is the ‘deemed-to-satisfy solution’.[5] [5]Appeal Book, page 705. Where an alternative waterproofing system is proposed as an ‘alternative solution’ to that described in Part 3.3.4, the proposal must comply with Performance Requirement P2.2.2. The learned member made the following findings:(a)The rendering and painting of the side walls of the dwelling was not within the contractual scope of works;[6][6]Reasons, [23].(b)The development approval for the townhouse provided as standard conditions that masonry construction comply with Part 3.3 of the Building Code of Australia (BCA), which part extends to waterproofing requirements;[7] [7]Ibid, [28].(c)The builder had adopted an alternative performance solution to prevent water ingress in the form of the installation of furring channels on the inside of the block walls;[8](d)Compliance with performance requirements for external masonry walls can be achieved either by using the deemed to satisfy solution or another performance solution – referred to by the learned member as an ‘alternative performance solution’;[9](e)The power of the QBCC to issue a direction to rectify arises in circumstances where the QBCC is satisfied that building work is defective or incomplete[10] and is not confined to circumstances where an evident failure is first manifested;[11](f)BCA Part 2.2.2 is satisfied for weatherproofing of masonry if it is carried out in accordance with a number of Australian Standards, none of which included the solution adopted by the builder;[12](g)In the absence of appropriate expert evidence, the use by the builder of furring channels between the masonry walls and plasterboard was not an acceptable alternative performance solution;[13] (h)It was unnecessary for the Tribunal to determine whether the builder had suggested to the homeowners that a waterproofing product, Xypex, be added to the concrete filler of the masonry blocks as this solution would not have prevented moisture from passing through the blocks and through the mortar joints between the blocks;[14](i)The builder understood it had waterproofing obligations in respect of the block walls;[15](j)The builder knew its statutory obligations and failed to address those obligations, first in drawing up the contract and then in carrying out the building work;[16](k)It was not unfair to issue a direction to rectify to the builder;[17](l)The offer by the builder to return to seal the walls was not made until well after the internal review decision by the QBCC directing rectification.[18][8]Ibid, [38], [39].[9]Ibid, [40].[10]Ibid, [36].[11]Ibid, [37].[12]Ibid, [43].[13]Ibid, [46].[14]Ibid, [53].[15]Ibid, [55].[16]Ibid, [56].[17]Ibid, [57].[18]Ibid, [58].The grounds of appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The grounds of appeal relied upon by Madden Developments raise questions of law, questions of fact, and questions of mixed law and fact. ConsiderationGround of appeal 1 - the Tribunal erred in finding that the alternative solution relied upon by the builder was inadequate to weatherproof the walls. Central to the proceedings below and this appeal is whether the builder adequately addressed the issue of weatherproofing the external walls of the dwelling. It cannot be contentious that the builder’s solution to the issue of weatherproofing the exterior walls of the dwelling was not a ‘deemed to satisfy solution’. A building solution, in this case the weatherproofing of the external block walls, was required to be either a deemed to satisfy solution or an alternative (or performance) solution.[31] For the builder to establish a deemed to satisfy solution it was required to demonstrate that the furring channel solution complied with AS 3700 or AS 4773 Parts 1 and 2. The evidence of the QBCC’s expert, Mr Blackman, was that the furring channel solution was not a deemed to satisfy solution. It does not appear that the builder led any evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, for the builder to establish that the building solution was compliant it was required to demonstrate that the furring channel was an alternative solution.[31]I will refer in these reasons to an ‘alternative solution’ which has the same meaning as a ‘performance solution’. Earlier in these reasons I referred to the requirement for an alternative solution to comply with performance requirements through one of, or a combination of, assessment methods. The builder argued below that the installation of a furring channel between the block wall and the internal wall, creating a cavity between the two walls, was an alternative solution. The learned member found:[46] There is no evidence that an appropriate expert, such as the certifier, has approved the alternative performance solution suggested by the builder. In the absence of evidence of independent expert approval of an alternative solution, the builder’s use of furring channels between masonry and plasterboard was not an acceptable alternative performance solution.[32][32]Op cit 13. It is not contentious in this appeal that the learned member was correct in approaching the determination of the issue whether the furring channel solution was an alternative performance solution by reference to Part A2.3 of the BCA. The evidence of Mr Chapman, the builder’s nominee, was that the alternative performance solution had been installed ensuring the performance provisions of ‘p2.2.2 of the National Construction Code’.[33] This was effectively the extent of the builder’s evidence on the issue.[33]Appeal book, p 131. In written submissions the builder said of the furring channel solution:The construction … is an appropriate alternative solution was (sic) has met the performance requirements of P2.2.2 of the BCA.[34][34]Appeal book, p 764.