Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Macpherson v Maund and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1937] HCA 78
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal question before the High Court was whether the ultimate gift for the children of Peter Dunn, who attained the age of twenty-one years, was rendered void by the rule against perpetuities due to its position following prior limitations that were themselves void for remoteness. Specifically, the court had to determine if the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" indicated that the ultimate gift was contingent upon the failure of the preceding void gifts, or if it was an independent or alternative disposition intended to take effect regardless of the validity of those prior limitations.
The High Court, affirming the decision of Nicholas J. in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, held that the ultimate gift was valid. The court reasoned that the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" should be interpreted as meaning "subject to the operation of preceding dispositions, so far as they do operate." This interpretation meant that the ultimate gift was intended to take effect upon the failure of the preceding dispositions for any reason, including invalidity due to remoteness. Therefore, the ultimate gift was not dependent on or expectant upon the void limitations and was not affected by their invalidity. The court noted that the gift to Peter Dunn's children, by its nature, would vest within the perpetuity period, and its validity did not hinge on the success of the earlier, void trusts. The court ordered variations to the Supreme Court's declarations to accurately reflect the effect of its decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
The court held that the ultimate gift was not dependent on or expectant of the prior void trusts and was therefore valid. The words "and subject as aforesaid" indicated that the ultimate gift was to take effect unless displaced or prevented by the prior trusts. The ultimate gift was intended to take effect regardless of the validity of the prior trusts. The prior void trusts did not affect the validity of the ultimate gift, which complied with the rule against remoteness and vested within the permitted period. The court affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, with some variations to the declarations.
The case of Macpherson v Maund arose from a settlement and a will executed by Tertius Horatio Macpherson on 5 February 1936, with the settlement executed by his attorney on 10 February 1936. Macpherson passed away on 5 June 1936. The settlement and will contained similar trusts that were subject to challenge on the grounds of remoteness, which rendered some of the trusts void. The daughters of Macpherson appealed to the High Court against the Supreme Court's decision, which held that the void trusts did not affect the ultimate gift to the children of Peter Dunn. The High Court upheld the Supreme Court's decision, affirming that the ultimate gift was not dependent upon the void prior gifts. The Court varied the Supreme Court's order to more accurately reflect the outcome of the appeal, and the appellants were ordered to pay the costs of the respondents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the ultimate gift in the settlement and will is dependent upon or expectant of the prior void gifts for remoteness, rendering it invalid.
2. If the ultimate gift is not dependent upon the prior void gifts, whether it is valid as an independent or alternative gift.
3. How the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" should be interpreted in determining the validity of the ultimate gift.
4. Whether the ultimate gift is a disposition of residue or if it is contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts.
5. If the ultimate gift is contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts, whether the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" sufficiently conveys this contingency to render the gift invalid.
6. Whether the court should require clearer language to determine that the ultimate gift is dependent upon the prior gifts.
7. Whether the ultimate gift is dependent upon the prior gifts only to the extent that the quantity of the property passing varies according to whether the earlier gifts are effectual or not.
8. Whether the testator intended the children of Peter Dunn to take whatever was not effectually disposed of by the earlier dispositions.
Held
1. Whether the ultimate gift in the settlement and will is dependent upon or expectant of the prior void gifts for remoteness, rendering it invalid.
The court concluded that the ultimate gift is not dependent or expectant upon the prior void gifts for remoteness and is therefore valid.
2. If the ultimate gift is not dependent upon the prior void gifts, whether it is valid as an independent or alternative gift.
The court concluded that the ultimate gift is valid as an independent or alternative gift.
3. How the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" should be interpreted in determining the validity of the ultimate gift.
The court interpreted the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" to mean "subject to the operation of preceding dispositions, so far as they do operate."
4. Whether the ultimate gift is a disposition of residue or if it is contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts.
The court concluded that the ultimate gift is contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts.
5. If the ultimate gift is contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts, whether the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" sufficiently conveys this contingency to render the gift invalid.
The court concluded that the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" sufficiently conveys the contingency of the ultimate gift, and therefore, it does not render the gift invalid.
6. Whether the court should require clearer language to determine that the ultimate gift is dependent upon the prior gifts.
The court concluded that the language used in the instrument is sufficient to convey the dependency of the ultimate gift upon the prior gifts.
7. Whether the ultimate gift is dependent upon the prior gifts only to the extent that the quantity of the property passing varies according to whether the earlier gifts are effectual or not.
The court concluded that the ultimate gift is dependent upon the prior gifts only to the extent that the quantity of the property passing varies according to whether the earlier gifts are effectual or not.
8. Whether the testator intended the children of Peter Dunn to take whatever was not effectually disposed of by the earlier dispositions.
The court concluded that the testator intended the children of Peter Dunn to take whatever was not effectually disposed of by the earlier dispositions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court of Australia in Macpherson v Maund addressed several intricate issues concerning the validity of a trust established in a will and a deed of settlement. The central issue revolved around the interpretation of the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" and its implications for the ultimate gift's validity, particularly in light of prior gifts being void for remoteness.
The court first examined whether the ultimate gift in the settlement and will was dependent upon or expectant of the prior void gifts for remoteness, which would render it invalid. The court determined that the ultimate gift was not dependent upon the prior void gifts. It held that the ultimate gift was either independent of or alternative to the prior gifts. The court interpreted "and subject as aforesaid" to mean "subject to the operation of preceding dispositions, so far as they do operate," thus providing that the ultimate gift would take effect if the preceding dispositions failed for any reason, including invalidity. This interpretation ensured that the ultimate gift was not affected by the invalidity of the prior gifts, aligning with the principle that a gift is not dependent or expectant upon a prior limitation void for remoteness.
Secondly, the court considered whether the ultimate gift was valid as an independent or alternative gift. It concluded that the ultimate gift was valid as an independent or alternative gift. The court's interpretation of "and subject as aforesaid" supported this conclusion, as it allowed the ultimate gift to take effect unless prevented by the prior limitations. This interpretation was consistent with authorities such as In re Canning's Will Trusts, where a similar phrase was held to mean that the gift was to take effect unless displaced by prior limitations.
Furthermore, the court discussed how the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" should be interpreted in determining the validity of the ultimate gift. The court adopted the interpretation that the phrase meant the gift would take effect unless prevented by prior limitations, which allowed the ultimate gift to be valid even if the prior gifts were void. This interpretation was based on the natural meaning of the words and was consistent with the principle that a gift is not dependent or expectant upon a prior limitation void for remoteness.
In examining whether the ultimate gift was a disposition of residue or contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts, the court held that the ultimate gift was not contingent upon the failure of the prior gifts. Instead, it was a disposition of residue that would take effect unless prevented by the prior limitations. The phrase "and subject as aforesaid" was interpreted to convey that the ultimate gift was to take effect unless displaced by the prior limitations, thus not rendering the gift invalid.
The court also considered whether clearer language was required to determine that the ultimate gift was dependent upon the prior gifts. It held that clearer language was not necessary, as the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" sufficiently conveyed that the ultimate gift was to take effect unless prevented by the prior limitations. This interpretation was supported by the court's view that the natural meaning of the words provided that the ultimate gift was to take effect unless displaced by prior limitations.
Moreover, the court addressed whether the ultimate gift was dependent upon the prior gifts only to the extent that the quantity of the property passing varied according to whether the earlier gifts were effectual or not. The court concluded that the ultimate gift was not dependent upon the prior gifts in this manner. Instead, it held that the ultimate gift was to take effect unless prevented by the prior limitations, which meant that the quantity of the property passing varied according to whether the prior limitations were effective or not.
Finally, the court considered whether the testator intended the children of Peter Dunn to take whatever was not effectually disposed of by the earlier dispositions. The court held that the testator intended the children of Peter Dunn to take the trust premises unless the prior limitations operated to displace or prevent the limitation in their favor from taking effect. This interpretation was consistent with the principle that a gift is not dependent or expectant upon a prior limitation void for remoteness.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that an ultimate gift in a will or settlement is not invalid merely because it follows prior gifts that are void for remoteness. The ultimate gift is valid if it is interpreted as taking effect unless displaced by the prior limitations, and the phrase "and subject as aforesaid" should be interpreted in this manner. The court's decision affirmed the validity of the ultimate gift and distinguished prior authority that held ulterior limitations following void gifts for remoteness to be invalid.