MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2016] AATA 209 (4 April 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/5714

Re

Denis MacNeall

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member CR Walsh

Date 4 April 2016
Place Perth

The Tribunal dismisses application 2015/5714 pursuant to s 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

..(Sgd) CR Walsh......................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – s 42B(1) dismissal application on basis that review application is futile or lacking in any further utility – applicant’s conditional Class 2 Civil Aviation Medical Certificate, the subject of the application, expired on 30 December 2015 – consideration of when Civil Aviation Safety Authority medical certificates come into force and how long they can remain in force – application dismissed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – s 42B(1)

Civil Aviation Act 1988 – s 31

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 – r 67.205 – r 67.205(1) – r 67.205(2) – r 67.205(3) – r 201.004

CASES

Barnes v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2015] AATA 272

Barnes v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2015] AATA 756
Re Canberra Raiders Sports Club and Commissioner of ACT Revenue (1999) 59 ALD 229
Re Filsell and Comcare [2009] AATA 90; (2009) 109 ALD 198
Re Hawkins and Minister for the Arts [2013] AATA 835; (2013) 61 AAR 523
Re Irving and Repatriation Commission (1997) 46 ALD 20
Re Johnson and Veteran’s Review Board [2004] AATA 242; (2004) 80 ALD 659
Re Kirk and Repatriation Commission [2007] AATA 1364; (2007) 95 ALD 506
Re McIntyre and Comcare (1997) 48 ALD 437
Re Nugent and Minister for Urban Services (2000) 61 ALD 570

Re Rundle and Civil Aviation Authority [2002] AATA 349; (2002) 68 ALD 234

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh

4 April 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 23 February 2016, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) applied to the Tribunal for the dismissal of this application (2015/5714) pursuant to s 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) on the basis that it lacks any further utility as Mr MacNeall’s Class 2 Civil Aviation Medical Certificate, the subject of the application, expired on 30 December 2015[1].

    [1] CASA’s submissions in relation to this dismissal application were received by the Tribunal on 8 March 2016 and Mr MacNeall’s submissions in reply were received by the Tribunal on 17 March 2016.  On 29 March 2016, the Tribunal held a telephone directions hearing with both parties to discuss this dismissal application and a related application.

    CONSIDERATION

  2. Section 42B(1) of the AAT Act states:

    Power of Tribunal if a proceeding is frivolous, vexatious etc.

    (1)The Tribunal may dismiss an application for the review of a decision, at any stage of the proceeding, if the Tribunal is satisfied that the application:

    (a)       is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance; or

    (b)       has no reasonable prospect of success; or

    (c)       is otherwise an abuse of the process of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr MacNeall sought judicial review of a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to issue him a Class 2 Civil Aviation Medical Certificate for a period less than the maximum allowable period under the regulations. The matter was heard and dismissed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). Mr MacNeall appealed the Tribunal's decision to the Commonwealth Court of Australia, which found in favour of CASA and dismissed the appeal. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether it had jurisdiction to review the decision of CASA to issue Mr MacNeall a Class 2 Civil Aviation Medical Certificate for a period less than the maximum allowable period under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) (CASR). The Tribunal found that neither section 31 of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 nor regulation 201.004 of the CASR conferred jurisdiction on the Tribunal in a way that enabled it to review a decision to issue a medical certificate for a period of time which was within the maximum allowable period set out in the CASR. The Tribunal dismissed Mr MacNeall's application for review of the CASA decision.
The Tribunal found that a decision to issue a medical certificate for a period of time which was within the maximum allowable period did not refuse the issue of the relevant authorisation, vary it or impose a condition upon it and, as such, was not a decision which was reviewable by the Tribunal. The Tribunal also found that Mr MacNeall's medical certificate had expired on 30 December 2015, and therefore the review application was futile and lacked any further utility. Accordingly, the Tribunal dismissed the application under section 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Act 1977 (Cth) (AAT Act). The Tribunal's decision was upheld on appeal to the Commonwealth Court of Australia. The court found that the Tribunal's interpretation of the relevant legislation and regulations was correct, and that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to review the CASA decision. The court also found that the review application was futile and lacked any further utility, given that Mr MacNeall's medical certificate had expired. Accordingly, the court dismissed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Neither s 31 of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 nor r 201.004 of the CASR confers jurisdiction on the Tribunal in a way that enables it to review a decision to issue a medical certificate for a period of time which is within the maximum allowable period set out in the CASR. The reason for this is that, a decision in these terms does not refuse the issue of the relevant authorisation, vary it or impose a condition upon it and, as such, is not a decision which is reviewable by the Tribunal.DECISION For the above reasons, the Tribunal dismisses application 2015/5714 (being the application relating to Mr MacNeall’s class 2 medical certificate) pursuant to s 42B(1) of the AAT Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

CASA’s letter to Mr MacNeall, dated 1 September 2015, further stated:Special Operational RestrictionYour Medical Certificate will have the following condition/s:Class 2 valid with safety pilot only valid for 12 months.Your certificate also carries the requirement that you adhere to the conditions on the document attached overleaf. On 3 September 2015, CASA issued Mr MacNeall with a Class 2 Civil Aviation Medical Certificate (Class 2 Medical Certificate) which recorded the following:Class 2 Expires end: 30 December 2015Restrictions: 4. For CASA audit9. Holder to fly with safety pilot only14.Reading Correction to be available whilst exercising the privileges of this licence Mr MacNeall’s position, as set out in his written submissions (received by the Tribunal on 17 March 2016), is as follows:Addressing CASA Claims1. My class 2 medical has no utility.This is irrelevant as I am appealing the decision made in September 2015. However, please see item 2.2. The decision to renew my class 2 medical from 4Sep15 to 30Dec15 (less than 4 months) was in accordance with CASR’s.Following my medical examination by the Designated Medical Examiner (DAME), CASA called for several additional tests adding many months to their final decisions.Accordingly, the following regulation applies. (not CASR 67.205(1)) as quoted by the respondent)CASR 67.205 (2) A medical certificate comes into force:(a)if the holder has undergone any relevant examinations required for the purpose of the issue of the certificate and complies with the relevant medical standard in all respects—on the certificate’s appropriate day; or(b) in any other case—on the day when the certificate is issued. That is 4Sep15.3. CASA is justified in renewing my class 2 medical for 1 year from the previous class 2 expiry.This relates in part to para 2. above but still needs addressing as it is germane to the expiry of my class 2 medical.The respondent’s submission of 8Mar16 contends that CASR 67.205 (3)… “a period of not more than 2 years” (see respondent letter para 7). to mean that CASA has discretion to determine the period of renewal (see respondent letter para 8).However, CASA must also be cognizant of Table 67.155 Criteria for medical standard 2 that details medical conditions that must not be “Safety Relevant”.CASR 67.015 Meaning of safety-relevant“For the purposes of this Part, a medically significant condition is safety-relevant if it reduces, or is likely to reduce, the ability of someone who has it to exercise a privilege conferred or to be conferred, or perform a duty imposed or to be imposed, by a licence that he or she holds or has applied for”.…………My contention is that legally my class 2 medical should have been renewed from 4Sep15 to 3Sep17; and even if CASA argues that they were justified in a 1 year period, then the renewal should have been from 4Sep15 to 3Sep16. i.e. It should still be current! In contrast, CASA’s position is that Mr MacNeall’s Class 2 Medical Certificate came into force on 30 December 2014, upon the expiration of his previous Class 2 Medical Certificate, and was valid for 12 months, expiring on 30 December 2015. According to CASA, since Mr MacNeall’s Class 2 Medical Certificate has expired, this review application is futile and lacks any further utility and should be dismissed.