DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: MacNAMARA v. MATTON AND ANOR [2000] QDC 016 PARTIES: BRIAN PATRICK MacNAMARA (plaintiff)
v.
FRANCIS COLIN MATTON & RAYMOND JAMES MATTON trading under the firm name of MATTONS LIVESTOCK TRANSPORT (first defendants)
&
THE NOMINAL DEFENDANT (second defendant)FILE NO/S: Plaint No 1 of 1996 DIVISION: PROCEEDING: Trial ORIGINATING COURT: District Court Mackay DELIVERED ON: 11 February 2000 DELIVERED AT: BRISBANE HEARING DATE: 7, 8, 9, 10 June; 6, 7, July 1999 JUDGE: McGILL D.C.J. ORDER: Judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant for $191,765 and against the second defendant for $196,312 CATCHWORDS: EMPLOYMENT – injury of employee – liability of employer – truck driver – whether vehicle defective
DAMAGES – personal injury – neck – 10% rising to 15% - what other injuries caused by accident – scarring – pain and suffering $42,500COUNSEL: R.W. Morgan for plaintiff
P.O. Land for defendantsSOLICITORS: Mackays for plaintiff
Clayton Utz for defendants
By this action the plaintiff claims damages for injuries he suffered on 12 February 1993 when a semi-trailer he was driving down the Eton Range in the course of his employment by the first defendant ran off the road and overturned. Liability and quantum are both in issue. The plaintiff’s case was originally pleaded in negligence and for breach of s.20 of the Motor Vehicles Safety Act 1980, but at the beginning of the trial I allowed the plaint to be amended to add alternative claims for damages of breach of contract, and for breach of statutory duty, being that imposed by s.9 of the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1989. The plaintiff alleges that essentially the same facts give rise to liability on each of these separate bases. In addition, it is alleged that an unidentified motor vehicle obstructed a safety ramp located part of the way down the Eton Range, which the plaintiff could otherwise have used to stop the semi-trailer safely, and that on this basis the second defendant is liable in negligence. The first named first defendant died before the trial; on 6 July 1999 I ordered that the action proceed against the surviving partner, Raymond James Matton: p.445.
The essential issue in relation to liability is a dispute as to why the accident happened; the plaintiff’s allegation is that the brakes on the truck were defective and insufficient to prevent it from running away when descending this hill fully laden. The defendants allege that there was nothing wrong with the truck which would have caused this accident, and that it was caused by the plaintiff’s bad driving. The defendants’ case is that when the plaintiff was most of the way down the hill he ceased to apply the brakes, and instead accelerated, with the result that he was travelling too fast to take the last corner, and this accelerating away is alleged to have occurred after the safety ramp so that any obstruction of it was irrelevant.
The plaintiff was alone in the truck at the time, and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MacNAMARA v Matton and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QDC 16
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining the liability of the employer and the vehicle manufacturer for the injuries sustained by the plaintiff. The key issue was whether the vehicle was defective and whether the accident was caused by that defect. Additionally, the court had to assess the extent of the injuries caused by the accident, including the percentage of disability and the appropriate compensation for pain and suffering.
The court found that the vehicle was indeed defective and that the accident was caused by that defect. The court determined that the plaintiff suffered a 10% disability rising to 15% due to the neck injury and other injuries caused by the accident. The court awarded the plaintiff $42,500 for pain and suffering. The court held both the employer and the vehicle manufacturer liable for the damages and ordered judgment in favour of the plaintiff against the first defendant for $191,765 and against the second defendant for $196,312.
Orders
Orders of the court
Judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant for $191,765 and against the second defendant for $196,312
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi