MacNab and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

MacNab and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 980 (1 December 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2014/4994, 2015/3454

Re

Cameron MacNab

APPLICANT

And

National Australia Bank Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Regina Perton, Member

Date 1 December 2016
Place Melbourne

In relation to application no. 2014/4994, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision that Mr MacNab suffered a disease that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with the respondent. The Tribunal remits the application to the respondent for calculation of his entitlements pursuant to sections 14, 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) on and from 23 December 2013 to the present date and at the present date in respect of his mental health condition. The respondent shall pay Mr MacNab’s costs and disbursements of that application pursuant to s 67 of the Act.

In relation to application 2015/3454, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Regina Perton, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – whether mental health condition arose out of or in the course of employment – whether the result of reasonable administrative action in a reasonable manner – whether permanent impairment

Legislation
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19, 24, 27, 67

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment Edition 2.1

Cases

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Reeve [2012] FCAFC 21

Hart v Comcare [2005] FCAFC 16

REASONS FOR DECISION

Regina Perton, Member

1 December 2016

  1. Cameron MacNab, now in his mid-forties, has worked for the National Australia Bank (the bank) since 1988.  During 2013, just before he started six months’ long service leave, he was advised that there was to be a restructure of the area in which he worked, resulting in his job being abolished.  Mr MacNab was told that he had to find another role at the bank.  On his return to work, he started looking around for appropriate positions that were equivalent to his own.   Following a discussion with his supervisor just before Christmas 2013, the reasonableness of which is in dispute, Mr MacNab suffered a diagnosed mental illness from which he still suffers.  Mr MacNab lodged a claim for compensation on 8 May 2014 in relation to anxiety and depression stating that he first sought medical treatment for his illness on 23 December 2013. 

  2. On 18 July 2014 the bank denied liability under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act).  The bank accepted that Mr MacNab suffered from a work-related condition but determined that liability was excluded because the ailment was suffered as a result of reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner in respect of Mr MacNab’s employment.

  3. On 31 July 2014 solicitors acting for Mr MacNab requested reconsideration of the decision.  On 4 September 2014 a delegate of the bank affirmed the initial decision.  On 25 September 2014, the Tribunal received Mr MacNab’s application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacNab and National Australia Bank Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 980
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr MacNab against National Australia Bank Limited for compensation under the relevant Act. Mr MacNab's position as Business Banking Manager 3 was abolished following a restructure in 2013, and he was informed that he would need to find another suitable position within the bank to continue his employment, without being offered a redundancy. Subsequently, Mr MacNab experienced significant stress, anxiety, and depression, which he attributed to his employer's actions and the uncertainty surrounding his future employment.

The court was required to determine whether Mr MacNab suffered a disease that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with the respondent. Specifically, the court considered the nature of Mr MacNab's condition, the timing of his claim, and whether he was eligible for compensation for permanent impairment, as well as compensation for medical expenses and incapacity. The court also had to assess the evidence presented, including medical reports from Mr MacNab's general practitioner, regarding the onset, symptoms, and prognosis of his mental health condition.

The court found that Mr MacNab had suffered a disease, namely anxiety and depression, which was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment. The medical evidence indicated that Mr MacNab's condition began in late 2013 following the abolition of his position and the subsequent pressure to resign. The court noted that Mr MacNab had no significant pre-existing injuries or illnesses. However, the court determined that Mr MacNab was not eligible for compensation for permanent impairment due to the timing of his claim and insufficient evidence that he would be unable to work for an employer other than the bank.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review in relation to application no. 2014/4994 and substituted a decision that Mr MacNab suffered a compensable disease. The matter was remitted to the respondent for calculation of Mr MacNab's entitlements for medical expenses and incapacity from 23 December 2013 to the present date. The respondent was also ordered to pay Mr MacNab's costs and disbursements for that application. In relation to application 2015/3454, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 16 of the Act refers to compensation for medical expenses. Section 19 concerns compensation for injuries resulting in incapacity. Sections 24 and 27 of the Act concern compensation for permanent impairment.MR MACNAB’S BACKGROUND Mr MacNab is married with three dependent children. The bank has been his sole employer since he was 19 years old. He was promoted to Business Banking Manager 3 (BBM3) in 2008. His role involved dealing with the financial needs of businesses in a particular geographical area. Following a restructure during 2013 in the region in which he worked, Mr MacNab’s position was abolished and he was told that he would need to find another suitable position within the bank if he wished to continue to work there. He was not offered a redundancy. Further details about the circumstances in which he was told about his options and his job search are provided later in these Reasons for Decision.MEDICAL EVIDENCE Dr Andrew Pearce, Mr MacNab’s general practitioner, provided medical certificates and backdated Certificates of Capacity when Mr MacNab indicated he was lodging a worker’s compensation claim. In a report dated 30 May 2014 addressed to NAB Workers Compensation, Mr Pearce stated:Cameron has attended this surgery for the past 14 years having first attended her [sic] October 3rd 2000. Cameron’s past health has been unremarkable and he has suffered no significant pre existing injuries or illnesses.Cameron’s most recent problems started at the end of 2013 and he presented to the surgery on Monday 23rd December 2013 saying that he had suffered from stresses at work. Cameron was told that he had been put in the position where his employer had wanted him to resign. Cameron was diagnosed as having some anxiety secondary to this and was advised to try seeking mediation perhaps through a solicitor, try sorting things out, the possibility of raising a workcover claim was discussed with him, he was given a certificate for a couple of days off and hoped that things would settle over the Christmas period.Cameron was reviewed on the 3rd January 2014 things had not changed much, on January 9th 2014 Cameron was prescribed some Temaze for sleeping difficulties and he was reviewed on 13th January 2014. Cameron complained still about stresses related to his uncertainty of his future about work, he was not sleeping, he was feeling depressed and he was referred to a psychologist…under a Mental Health Care Plan for assessment of this. Cameron on 22nd January 2014 he had contacted the union and they had advised him not to see a solicitor as he should be seeing either the union or a solicitor Cameron left this in the union’s hands, he was still suffering from some insomnia although this was being treated satisfactorily with Temaze.Cameron attended for review on Friday, 14 February 2014, nothing much had happened. Cameron reiterated that his work had told him they were waiting for him to resign and that he did not understand what was going on. Cameron was lacking confidence, not sleeping, feeling indecisive, feeling very anxious and starting to spill over into his home life. On March 14, 2014 Cameron was still waiting for a meting [sic] to sort out what was going on and his mood remained the same.Cameron was reviewed on Friday 11th April 2014, Cameron had had the meeting in late March, Cameron had spoken with his head boss and his area manager and some options had been put to Cameron who stated that these were a demotion, re employment but with a performance management review for going back and resigning if no job was present for him three months down the track. Cameron felt at this stage that he had been marginalised by his employer, that he was suffering from some anxiety in response to undue pressures on him to resign. Cameron was feeling that his work was running his life in a bad way and that he was not going to let work get away with this. It was pointed out to Cameron that his mood had suffered over 2014, that he’d been waiting for meetings and waiting to resolve this but not a lot had happened and that in the meantime he had suffered from increased insomnia, increased indecisiveness, constant worry and rising anxiety and depression.Cameron stated that his union had advised him to claim on workcover for this and so a workcover form was filled out on this date. Cameron was seen on the 28th April 2014 where things remain the same and most recently on 27 May 2014 where things remained the same. Cameron was given some Temaze to help with his sleeping, was encouraged to continue with his counselling. He was not keen on taking any anti-depressant medications and a workcover form was filled out and this stated that Cameron was suffering from some anxiety and depression and he was certified as being unfit for work until review. In answer to your specific questions –…2. The history provided by the Claimant at the initial consultation as to the causes - Cameron told me that he had been employed in a position at work. At the meeting with his boss before Christmas time Cameron states that he was told that his position had only ever been temporary and that he was expected to resign as there was no ongoing position for him and Cameron felt this was unjust. He also denied having been told this prior to this meeting.3. What were the symptoms the Claimant reported to you at the time? - please see above.a) On Cameron’s first presentation he was particularly upset and worried about the future. He presented as an anxious and agitated person and was hoping that some time off and time to think about things and get in touch with his union might sort these problems out over the Christmas period and this was not the case.b) Has there been any improvement or decline in symptoms? What were the contributing factors to this - I believe that there has been a decline in Cameron’s symptoms. I believe he has developed a worsening anxiety and a worsening depression, I believe that Cameron’s inability to return to work has lead to him being fixated upon this and not able to concentrate on many other things and has lead to a loss of his general confidence, concentration and well being. I believe that his anxiety and depression has spilled over into his family life. I believe that Cameron is now fixated on making sure that his work ”cannot get away with this”, I believe that Cameron could and should be looking for alternative forms of employment in a less stressful environment but Cameron is not able to do this at the moment as he is fixated on righting the above perceived wrong.…6. Does the Claimant suffer from an underlying or pre-existing condition – a) No b) No7. What treatment plan is recommended for the condition suffered by the Claimant - Cameron’s treatment plan is –1. Try sorting out his stresses and addressing these2. Psychologist review and counselling3. Hypnotics to help him sleep at night time4. Medications to help calm Cameron and assist with his anxiety and depression have not been engaged as Cameron has been reluctant to start these at this stage.8. What is the prognosis of the Claimant’s condition? - I feel the Claimant has a poor prognosis. I believe that apart from the afore mentioned anxiety and depression an adversarial relationship has developed between Cameron and his firm and this is contributing to his slow progress.…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr MacNab is married with three dependent children. The bank has been his sole employer since he was 19 years old. He was promoted to Business Banking Manager 3 (BBM3) in 2008. His role involved dealing with the financial needs of businesses in a particular geographical area. Following a restructure during 2013 in the region in which he worked, Mr MacNab’s position was abolished and he was told that he would need to find another suitable position within the bank if he wished to continue to work there. He was not offered a redundancy. Further details about the circumstances in which he was told about his options and his job search are provided later in these Reasons for Decision.MEDICAL EVIDENCE Dr Andrew Pearce, Mr MacNab’s general practitioner, provided medical certificates and backdated Certificates of Capacity when Mr MacNab indicated he was lodging a worker’s compensation claim. In a report dated 30 May 2014 addressed to NAB Workers Compensation, Mr Pearce stated:Cameron has attended this surgery for the past 14 years having first attended her [sic] October 3rd 2000. Cameron’s past health has been unremarkable and he has suffered no significant pre existing injuries or illnesses.Cameron’s most recent problems started at the end of 2013 and he presented to the surgery on Monday 23rd December 2013 saying that he had suffered from stresses at work. Cameron was told that he had been put in the position where his employer had wanted him to resign. Cameron was diagnosed as having some anxiety secondary to this and was advised to try seeking mediation perhaps through a solicitor, try sorting things out, the possibility of raising a workcover claim was discussed with him, he was given a certificate for a couple of days off and hoped that things would settle over the Christmas period.Cameron was reviewed on the 3rd January 2014 things had not changed much, on January 9th 2014 Cameron was prescribed some Temaze for sleeping difficulties and he was reviewed on 13th January 2014. Cameron complained still about stresses related to his uncertainty of his future about work, he was not sleeping, he was feeling depressed and he was referred to a psychologist…under a Mental Health Care Plan for assessment of this. Cameron on 22nd January 2014 he had contacted the union and they had advised him not to see a solicitor as he should be seeing either the union or a solicitor Cameron left this in the union’s hands, he was still suffering from some insomnia although this was being treated satisfactorily with Temaze.Cameron attended for review on Friday, 14 February 2014, nothing much had happened. Cameron reiterated that his work had told him they were waiting for him to resign and that he did not understand what was going on. Cameron was lacking confidence, not sleeping, feeling indecisive, feeling very anxious and starting to spill over into his home life. On March 14, 2014 Cameron was still waiting for a meting [sic] to sort out what was going on and his mood remained the same.Cameron was reviewed on Friday 11th April 2014, Cameron had had the meeting in late March, Cameron had spoken with his head boss and his area manager and some options had been put to Cameron who stated that these were a demotion, re employment but with a performance management review for going back and resigning if no job was present for him three months down the track. Cameron felt at this stage that he had been marginalised by his employer, that he was suffering from some anxiety in response to undue pressures on him to resign. Cameron was feeling that his work was running his life in a bad way and that he was not going to let work get away with this. It was pointed out to Cameron that his mood had suffered over 2014, that he’d been waiting for meetings and waiting to resolve this but not a lot had happened and that in the meantime he had suffered from increased insomnia, increased indecisiveness, constant worry and rising anxiety and depression.Cameron stated that his union had advised him to claim on workcover for this and so a workcover form was filled out on this date. Cameron was seen on the 28th April 2014 where things remain the same and most recently on 27 May 2014 where things remained the same. Cameron was given some Temaze to help with his sleeping, was encouraged to continue with his counselling. He was not keen on taking any anti-depressant medications and a workcover form was filled out and this stated that Cameron was suffering from some anxiety and depression and he was certified as being unfit for work until review. In answer to your specific questions –…2. The history provided by the Claimant at the initial consultation as to the causes - Cameron told me that he had been employed in a position at work. At the meeting with his boss before Christmas time Cameron states that he was told that his position had only ever been temporary and that he was expected to resign as there was no ongoing position for him and Cameron felt this was unjust. He also denied having been told this prior to this meeting.3. What were the symptoms the Claimant reported to you at the time? - please see above.a) On Cameron’s first presentation he was particularly upset and worried about the future. He presented as an anxious and agitated person and was hoping that some time off and time to think about things and get in touch with his union might sort these problems out over the Christmas period and this was not the case.b) Has there been any improvement or decline in symptoms? What were the contributing factors to this - I believe that there has been a decline in Cameron’s symptoms. I believe he has developed a worsening anxiety and a worsening depression, I believe that Cameron’s inability to return to work has lead to him being fixated upon this and not able to concentrate on many other things and has lead to a loss of his general confidence, concentration and well being. I believe that his anxiety and depression has spilled over into his family life. I believe that Cameron is now fixated on making sure that his work ”cannot get away with this”, I believe that Cameron could and should be looking for alternative forms of employment in a less stressful environment but Cameron is not able to do this at the moment as he is fixated on righting the above perceived wrong.…6. Does the Claimant suffer from an underlying or pre-existing condition – a) No b) No7. What treatment plan is recommended for the condition suffered by the Claimant - Cameron’s treatment plan is –1. Try sorting out his stresses and addressing these2. Psychologist review and counselling3. Hypnotics to help him sleep at night time4. Medications to help calm Cameron and assist with his anxiety and depression have not been engaged as Cameron has been reluctant to start these at this stage.8. What is the prognosis of the Claimant’s condition? - I feel the Claimant has a poor prognosis. I believe that apart from the afore mentioned anxiety and depression an adversarial relationship has developed between Cameron and his firm and this is contributing to his slow progress.…

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal therefore finds that Mr MacNab is not eligible to be compensated for permanent impairment based on the timing of his claim and insufficient evidence that he would be unable to work for an employer other than the bank.DECISION In relation to application no. 2014/4994, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision that Mr MacNab suffered a disease that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with the respondent. The Tribunal remits the application to the respondent for calculation of his entitlements pursuant to sections 14, 16 and 19 of the the Act on and from 23 December 2013 to the present date and at the present date in respect of his mental health conditions. The respondent shall pay Mr MacNab’s costs and disbursements of that application pursuant to s 67 of the Act. In relation to application 2015/3454, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established