Mackenzie v W Small Plant Hire (a Firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2001] QCA 277

COURT OF APPEAL

de JERSEY CJ
DAVIES JA
THOMAS JA

Appeal No 8716 of 2000

PETER THOMAS MACKENZIE                  Appellant
  (Plaintiff)

and

W SMALL PLANT HIRE (A Firm)             First Respondent
  (First Defendant)

and

DETAILED EXCAVATIONS PTY LTD            Second Respondent
  (Second Defendant)

and

W D G & E A SMALL  Third Respondent
  (Third Defendant)

BRISBANE

..DATE 18/07/2001

JUDGMENT

THE CHIEF JUSTICE:  The appellant appeals against a learned trial Judge's refusal of what the Judge regarded as the appellant's application made at the commencement of a trial for leave to amend his statement of claim.  The appellant's claim is for damages for personal injuries allegedly arising out of the respondent's negligence in the course of the appellant's employment. 

The appellant commenced his action by writ issued on 13 September 1991.  His statement of claim delivered on 13 September 1993 alleged that he suffered the injuries while using a bobcat to clear vegetation in the development of a golf course at Sanctuary Cove.

The issue arises from the appellant's attempt to broaden his particulars of negligence.  In the statement of claim he very clearly tied his case to the respondent's requirement that he carry out the work using a machine which lacked a properly functioning seat-belt.

The alleged negligence occurred over the period July to December 1988.  Having been commenced in September 1991, the action proceeded slowly over the years, and eventually in December 1999 the appellant's solicitors filed a request for trial dates.  The action first came on for trial on 10 July 2000 but was then adjourned because no Judge was available to hear it.  It later came on for trial on 11 September 2000.

After filing the request for trial dates in December 1999, the appellant's solicitors obtained in April 2000 a report in relation to the circumstances of the appellant's employment from an "accident investigation occupational health and safety consultant". 

Following from that the appellant's solicitors wrote to the solicitors for the respondent on, it seems, 16 June 2000 giving notice that at the forthcoming trial the appellant intended to amend the statement of claim to include further particulars of negligence.  The additional particulars essentially alleged negligence because of the respondent's failure to provide the appellant with a larger machine with which to do the work, such as a bulldozer.  The respondent's solicitors replied on 22 June 2000 stating that the respondent would, at the trial, object to any such amendment.

Dealing with the issue at the commencement of the trial on 11 September 2000, the learned Judge took the view that since the appellant's solicitors had, in September 1999, signed a request for trial dates, and because of the stipulation of Rule 380 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, the amendment foreshadowed by the later letter of June 2000 could be made only with the leave of the Court.

Additionally, one notes, Rule 470 provides that after a party has signed a request for trial dates, that party needs the Court's leave to amend a pleading.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mackenzie v W Small Plant Hire (a Firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mackenzie v W Small Plant Hire (a Firm), the appellant, Peter Thomas Mackenzie, sought damages for personal injuries allegedly arising from the respondents' negligence during his employment. The respondents were W Small Plant Hire (a Firm), Detailed Excavations Pty Ltd, and W D G & E A Small. The dispute centered on the appellant's attempt to broaden his particulars of negligence at the commencement of the trial. The original statement of claim alleged negligence due to the use of a machine without a properly functioning seat-belt. The appellant sought to amend his statement of claim to include further particulars of negligence, specifically regarding the provision of an inadequate machine for the work. The respondents objected to the amendment, and the trial judge refused to grant leave to amend, leading to the appellant's appeal against this decision.

The legal issue before the court was whether the trial judge correctly applied Rule 380 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which requires leave from the court to amend a pleading after a request for trial dates has been filed. The appellant argued that Rule 160, subrule (2) allowed for further particulars to be provided by correspondence, and since the respondents did not object to these particulars, the statement of claim should be deemed amended. The court considered the intent of the rules and concluded that once a request for trial dates is filed, any amendment must be sanctioned by a grant of leave from the court. The court also noted the substantial time lapse between the alleged negligence and the notification of the proposed amendment, the substantial departure from the pleaded case, and the potential prejudice due to the fading of recollections over time as significant factors against granting leave.

The court found no error in the trial judge's application of Rule 380 and upheld his decision to refuse leave to amend the statement of claim. The court emphasized the importance of facilitating the trial of issues comprehensively arising from the relevant circumstances while also considering the potential prejudice to the respondents if the amendment were allowed. The appeal was dismissed, and costs were awarded to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.