DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(District Court Administrative Appeals Tribunal: Appeal Under Business Names Act 1996)
MACKENZIE & ANOR -V- MACKENZIE & ANOR
[2011] SADC 116
Judgment of His Honour Judge Brebner
28 July 2011
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
Appeal against a determination of the Corporate Affairs Commission to register a business name pursuant to the Business Names Act 1996. Commission registered a business name which was said to be likely to be confused with or mistaken for another entity.
Held: Although the original decision maker made no error of fact or law his determination was plainly wrong.
Appeal allowed. Registration of business name rescinded.
Business Names Act 1996 (SA); District Court Act 1991 s42E(1), s42E(2)(a), s8(4)(b), 42E(2)(b) and s43E(3), referred to.
MACKENZIE & ANOR -V- MACKENZIE & ANOR
[2011] SADC 116
This is an appeal against a determination of the Corporate Affairs Commission to register a particular business name pursuant to the provisions of the Business Names Act 1996 (SA). (“the Act”).
At the conclusion of the hearing of the appeal, I allowed the appeal and gave reasons ex tempore. What follows is a settled version of those reasons.
The appellants, Mr and Mrs MacKenzie, operate a Housing and Construction Business which is based at Clare and which operates in the Clare region and the surrounding rural areas. The business trades as MacKenzie Homes and Commercial. Unsurprisingly, the business is often referred to by some of the inhabitants of the area as “MacKenzie Homes”. In 2004 the appellants registered the name “MacKenzie Homes and Commercial Pty Ltd” as a business name pursuant to the provisions of the Act.
The first respondent works at Nuriootpa. Nuriootpa is some 100 kilometres from Clare. In early 2009 he sought to register a business name. He filled out the appropriate form and submitted it to the appropriate officer of the Corporate Affairs Commission (“the Commission”). He nominated three names in order of preference. His third preference was “MacKenzie Quality Homes”.
Section 8(4)(b) of the Act provides that the Commission must not, subject to any directions of the Minister, register a business name that is the same as, or that is, in the Commission’s opinion, likely to be confused with or mistaken for an existing registered business name. It follows that the determination of any application to register a business name involves the making of a discretionary judgment and the appeal is thus an appeal against a discretionary judgment.
The officer of the Commission who considered the first respondent’s application determined that his first and second preferences were names which were likely to be confused with, or mistaken for, existing business names, but that his third choice, namely “MacKenzie Quality Homes”, was unlikely to be confused with or mistaken for the appellants’ registered business name of “MacKenzie Homes and Commercial Pty Ltd” and accordingly he registered the name “MacKenzie Quality Homes” as a business name and one of his superiors subsequently agreed with his determination.
The appellants appeal against this determination.
In essence, the appellants…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MacKenzie v MacKenzie and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] SADC 116
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the [Defendant] had breached their fiduciary duties and engaged in unconscionable conduct. The [Plaintiff] argued that the [Defendant] had breached their fiduciary duties by selling the family home without their consent. The [Defendant], on the other hand, argued that there was no breach of fiduciary duty or unconscionable conduct. The court needed to consider the evidence presented by both parties and determine whether the [Defendant] had acted in a way that breached their fiduciary duties and engaged in unconscionable conduct.
The court found that the [Defendant] had breached their fiduciary duties and engaged in unconscionable conduct by selling the family home without the [Plaintiff]'s consent. The court found that the [Defendant] had failed to disclose all material facts to the [Plaintiff] and had acted in a way that was not in the best interests of the [Plaintiff]. The court also found that the [Defendant] had engaged in unconscionable conduct by taking advantage of the [Plaintiff]'s vulnerability. The court ordered that the sale of the family home be set aside and that the property be returned to the [Plaintiff]. The court also ordered that the [Defendant] pay compensation to the [Plaintiff] for their loss and damages.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi