Neaves J.
10 January 13E6
Canberra
| For-the applicant and cross-respondent | - |
Counsel : Mr N.€. Francey
| Sollcitors: €or the respondents and the cross-clamant | Malcolm Johns and Company |
-
Counsel : Mr S .G. Finch
| Solicitors: Dupree Davey Watson | & | Assoclates |
| Dates of hearing | : | 20, 21 , 22, 23 May 1985 |
| S | ----="--- |
JCNXIFER 'y.LTiiEF YXE MAC!.;??.P
A2Flicant
| R . J . | HGEBS PTY. LIMITED |
Clrst r2spondent
ROEERT JO'r!!N HOEES
Second respondent
| R. | J. HOSES PTY. LIYITED |
Cross-claimant
JENNIFER CATHERINE MACKAY
Cross-respondent
MINUTE OF ORDER
| JUDGE MAKING ORDER : | Neaves J. |
| DATE OF ORDER | 10 January 1986 |
| WHERE MADE | Canberra |
| THE COURT ORDERS THAT: |
1. There be judgment for the applicant, Jennifer Catherine Mackay, against the first respondent,
|
| 2. | The application in | so far as It seeks relief |
against the second respondent, Robert John Hobbs.
be dlsmissed.
| J. | The cross-claim | by R. J. Hobbs Fty. | Limited |
aqainst Jennifer Catherine Mackay be dismissed.
| 4. | R. J. | FIobbs | Pty. Limited pay the applicant's |
costs of the application and of the cross-claim.
| N o t e : | Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. |
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
)
| NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY | ) | No. I; 19: | gf 1984 |
| > | |||
| GENERAL DIVISION |
.JENNIFEF( CAThE2INE MAi3KAY
Applicant
R.J. HOBDS PTY. LIMITED
First resp0nder.t
ROBE%T JOHN HOEES
Second respondent
R.J. HOESS PTY. LIMITED
Cross-claimant
| JENNIFER CATHERINE | MICKAP |
Cross-respondent
| m: Neaves J. | , |
| i |
| D B : | 10 January 1986 |
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
| This proceeding arises out | of | a transaction entered |
into in July 1983 whereby Jennifer Catherme Mackay ("the applicant") acquired a second-hand Silver Shadow Rolls-Royce motor vehicle (1974 model) registration number (N.S.W.) RR-081.
| The motor vehicle was offered for sale throuuh | R.J. Hobbs Pty. |
| Limited ("the first | respondent"), a | company which carried on |
2 .
| The applicant claims, pursuant | to | 5 . 3 2 of the |
Eractices Act 1974 (Cth) ("the Act"), to recover f r m the first respcndent and from Robert John Hobbs. the second respondent, the amount of loss or damage alleged to have been suffered by her by conduct that was done In contravention of sub-s.52(1) or
, ,~
| 5 . 5 3 of the Act. The basis of that claim is | an allegation that |
| ,.:v | .:v | .I |
| . | r ' : |
| .'..:.t . | . L ,,- | she was induced | .to enter into the transaction by certain |
| . ., ' | - , | representatlons in relation to the vehicle alleged to have been |
| , ' | . , | ,_ .. |
| :*.:l< . - I | , | a |
| , | I |
| . , | '.= . | ,made. to her | by Mr Hobbs, as agent f o r the first respondent. | It |
| , | 1 . | .~ |
| .> | - , |
| .. , is alleged | that | hose | representations | were false | and |
| -. . ' ' constituted misleading or deceptive conduct. | As pleaded, the |
| I | , . , . |
| . .~ | ~ i' I |
.
| c', | - .… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mackay, J.C. v R.J. Hobbs Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] FCA 2
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the credibility of the applicant's and the first respondent's witnesses and found that the applicant's evidence was less than satisfactory, particularly regarding her involvement in her business and the financial details of the transaction. The court preferred the version of events provided by the first respondent's witnesses, finding that the applicant was induced to purchase the vehicle based on agreements made with Brett Wyatt, not the first respondent. The court concluded that there was no evidence to support the applicant's claim that the first respondent made false representations that induced her to enter into the transaction.
Regarding the condition of the vehicle, the court found that the vehicle was indeed defective and not of merchantable quality, as it was significantly misaligned and unsafe to drive. The court accepted the evidence of experts who inspected the vehicle, confirming its unroadworthy condition. The court determined that the first respondent was liable for the breach of the implied condition of merchantable quality and awarded the applicant damages of $10,000.
The court also addressed the cross-claim filed by the first respondent against the applicant, seeking compensation for the amount it paid to Mercantile Credits Limited due to the applicant's failure to fulfill her obligations under the hire purchase agreement. The court found that the first respondent failed to establish the existence of a guarantee agreement or any loss suffered due to the applicant's default.
In conclusion, the court granted judgment in favour of the applicant against the first respondent for $10,000, dismissed the application against the second respondent, rejected the cross-claim by the first respondent, and ordered the first respondent to pay the applicant's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.