Mackay and Secretary, Attorney General’s Department

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Mackay and Secretary, Attorney General’s Department [2020] AATA 4554 (12 November 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2020/2206          

Re:Geoffrey Mackay  

APPLICANT

AndSecretary, Attorney General’s Department

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D R Davies

Date:  12 November 2020

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Senior Member D R Davies

CATCHWORDS

EMPLOYMENT ENTITLEMENTS – Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012(Cth) – advance paid to employee – reconsideration of own motion by secretary – decision that employee was not eligible for advance paid – whether applicant was an employee of the relevant company or another company – tripartite labour hire agreement – applicant not an employee of the relevant company – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth)

CASES

Damevski v Giudice (2003) 133 FCR 438; [2003] FCAFC 252

Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (2011) 198 FCR 174; [2011] FCA 1176
Hollis v Vabu (2001) 207 CLR 21; [2001] HCA 44
Nguyen and A-N-T Contract Packers Pty Ltd (2003) 128 IR 241; [2003] NSWIRComm 1006
On Call Interpreters and Translators Agency Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No 3) (2011) 214 FCR 82; [2011] FCA 366
Plutus Payroll Australia Pty Ltd (in Liquidation), Re (2019) 139 ACSR 536; [2019] NSWSC 1171
Qian and Commissioner of Taxation, Re [2019] AATA 14
Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16; [1986] HCA 1
Vij v Cordina Chicken Farms Pty Ltd (2012) 265 FLR 365; [2012] FMCA 483

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Administrative Arrangements Order (Cth) made on 29 May 2019

Explanatory Memorandum to the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Bill 2012

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D R Davies

12 November 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Geoffrey Mackay seeks the review of the decision of the Respondent, the Secretary, Attorney General’s Department, that he was not eligible for an advance under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth).

  2. The issue is whether Mr Mackay was an employee of PPA Contractors Australia Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) or another company in the Plutus Payroll Group of Companies and was eligible for an advance under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth).

    Definitions

  3. In this decision:

    ·“Department” means the Attorney General’s Department.

    ·“FEG Act” means the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth).

    ·“Liquidators” means Timothy Norman, Salvatore Algeri and Ezio Senatore of Deloitte appointed as liquidators of the PP Group pursuant to the order of the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 9 October 2017.

    ·“Mr Anquetil” means Simon Anquetil from the PP Group.

    ·“Mr Mackay” means the Applicant, Geoffrey Mackay.

    ·“Mr Scarano” means Joe Scarano.

    ·“MJHQ” means MJHQ Pty Ltd ACN 164 461 723.

    ·“PPA” means Plutus Payroll Australia Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) ACN 169 205 127.

    ·“PPA Contractors” means PPA Contractors Australia Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) ACN 605 218 273.

    ·“PPA Services” means…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mackay and Secretary, Attorney General’s Department and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4554
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Mr. Mackay and the Secretary of the Attorney-General's Department concerning eligibility for an advance payment under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth). Mr. Mackay had received an advance payment, which the Secretary later reconsidered and decided he was not eligible for. The core of the dispute revolved around whether Mr. Mackay was an employee of PPA Contractors (or a related company) or Roni's Discount Variety Stores, given a tripartite labour hire arrangement.

The Tribunal was required to determine the true nature of the employment relationship between Mr. Mackay, PPA Contractors, and Roni's. Specifically, the legal issue was whether Mr. Mackay was an employee of PPA Contractors or any company within the PP Group at the time his employment ended, for the purposes of section 10 of the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act. This involved assessing various indicia to ascertain who exercised practical and legal control, who bore the characteristics of an employer, and who the worker was hired by, considering the totality of the relationship.

The Tribunal applied established legal principles for determining employment status in labour hire arrangements, examining factors such as the contractual relationship, the practical working relationship, and the allocation of rights and responsibilities. Despite the Letter of Engagement referring to PPA as the "employer," the Tribunal found that the terms, when considered in their entirety, suggested Roni's was the actual employer and PPA acted as a hiring partner, likely for payroll purposes. The goodwill generated by Mr. Mackay's work enured to Roni's benefit, not PPA's. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr. Mackay was an employee of Roni's, not PPA or any PP Group company, during the relevant period.

The Tribunal affirmed the Secretary's decision that Mr. Mackay was not eligible for an advance under section 10 of the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act. The application for review was therefore unsuccessful. The Tribunal noted the potential hardship for Mr. Mackay and suggested the Secretary might consider this in relation to any arrangements for the repayment of the advance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent, in its Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions[18] at paragraph 3.3, has referred to a number of cases which have identified a variety of indicia to be assessed in considering the totality of the relationship between the putative employer, the host business and the labour hire company.[19] Having regard to those cases and the other cases to which I have previously referred, I consider that the matters set out by the Respondent are appropriate to consider as part of the totality of the relationship between the parties. Those matters are:[18] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions.[19] Damevski; Nguyen and A-N-T Contract Packers Pty Ltd (2003) 128 IR 241; [2003] NSWIRComm 1006 (Nguyen); Re Qian and Commissioner of Taxation [2019] AATA 14 (Qian); Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (2011) 198 FCR 174; [2011] FCA 1176 (Ramsey);Vij v Cordina Chicken Farms Pty Ltd (2012) 265 FLR 365; [2012] FMCA 483 (Cordina).(a)The role of the labour hire company and whether it acts as an intermediary between the clients and workers[20];(b)The role of the labour hire company and whether it merely acts as an ‘agent’ of the employer[21];(c)The legal contractual relationship between the worker and the labour hire company[22] ’bare formalities’ are not sufficient[23] and ‘self-characterisation ‘ is not always determinative[24];(d)The working relationship between the worker and the labour hire company[25];(e)The practical and legal control exercised over the worker[26];(f)Who bears the rights and characteristics of an employer – the labour hire company, or its client[27];(g)Who the worker was hired by[28];(h)The fixing and paying of remuneration[29]; and(i)The worker’s state of mind.[30][20] Damevski at [174].[21] Damevski; Ramsey at [120][22] Damevski; Qian at [104].[23] Ramsey at [94], [98].[24] Qian at [96].[25] Damevski at [71].[26] Damevski at [68]; Cordina at [62].[27] Damevski at [102]; Ramsey at [98].[28] Damevski at [174]; Ramsey at [68-69] and Nguyen.[29] Damevski at [6], [174]; Qian at [102].[30] Cordina at [61-63].FACTS The evidence before the Tribunal comprises the eight exhibits which were admitted by the consent of the parties which include Exhibit 1 the Tribunal Documents. The hearing was conducted by Microsoft Teams in accordance with the Tribunal’s Practice Direction - Covid-19 Special Measures Practice Direction - Freedom of Information, General and Veterans’ Appeals Divisions.[31] Mr Mackay appeared at the hearing and gave evidence to the Tribunal under affirmation. In giving his evidence, he impressed me as an articulate and honest witness. The handwritten submissions which he made orally to the Hearing are Exhibit 8.[31] The Hon Justice D G Thomas, President, 27 April 2020. Mr Mackay gave evidence that he commenced working for Roni’s on 16 December 2008. He said there was an employment contract at that time between him and Roni’s but he has been unable to find a copy of it. He said that there were two Roni’s stores in Castle Hill and that he oversaw both of them.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The goodwill which Mr Mackay created by the performance of his worker store manager enured to the benefit of Roni’s. It did not benefit PPA.CONCLUSION Having regard to the matters referred to above and the real substance and totality of the relationship of the parties, in the present case I am satisfied that in performing the work for Roni’s in the period between 19 January 2015 and 14 May 2017 Mr Mackay was not an employee of PPA nor any company in the PP Group. I am satisfied that during this period the true nature of the relationship between the parties was that Mr Mackay was the employee of Roni’s. I find that for the purposes of s10 of the FEG Act, Mr Mackay was not an employee of PPA nor any company in the PP Group at the time his employment ended on 14 May 2017. I find that Mr Mackay was therefore not eligible for an advance under s10 of the FEG Act. I appreciate that this decision may cause Mr Mackay some hardship. It was reasonable for Mr Mackay to believe that he was an employee of PPA or a PP Group Company when he made his claim under the FEG Act because the Letter of Engagement referred to PPA as his employer. It is most unfortunate that through no fault on the part of Mr Mackay the review by the Secretary of the Eligibility Decision did not occur until some two years after that Eligibility Decision was made and pursuant to which Mr Mackay received the advance. The Secretary may wish to consider these matters in relation to any arrangements made for repayment of the advance. It follows that the application for review is unsuccessful. Therefore, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As I previously mentioned, in his FEG claim Mr Mackay stated that his former employer’s ABN was 63 605 218 273 which is that of PPA Contractors and that the name of his former employer was Plutus Payroll.[44] In his evidence, Mr Mackay said that he got that ABN from his payslip and he put the name Plutus Payroll because that was the name on his contract. [44] Exhibit 1, Tribunal Documents, T5, page 52.CONSIDERATION The Respondent contends that, having regard to the entirety of the relationship between PPA Contractors (and the PP Group) and Mr Mackay, the Tribunal should not be satisfied that Mr Mackay was an employee of PPA Contractors nor any PP Group company and, rather, the Tribunal should be satisfied he was an employee of Roni’s.[45][45] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions paragraph 6.1. Mr Mackay contends that under the Letter of Engagement, PPA retained the ultimate right of control of him as its employee by way of its contractual right to set hours of work, assign work duties and job location and the right to terminate his employment. He contends that he worked for the direct benefit of PPA as its employee.[46] In his submissions to the Tribunal, Mr Mackay also contended that all of the criteria in the Plutus Payroll decision for a finding that a worker was not an employee of PPA were not met in his case and that he was an employee of PPA.[47] [46] Exhibit 1, Tribunal Documents, T18, page 264, paragraphs 19 and 20.[47] Exhibit 8, Submissions of Applicant.Letter of Engagement I will firstly consider the terms of the Letter of Engagement. As I have mentioned earlier, the Letter of Engagement:·“States that the offer of employment is ‘in the position of Roni’s Discount Variety Stores (‘the Manager’) under Labour Hire through our hiring partner Plutus Payroll Australia Pty Ltd (“the employer”)”.·Roni’s is described as “the manager” and PPA as “the employer”:·Provides that the manager and/or employer reviews remuneration;·Obligations are stated to be owed to the manager and employer;·The employer or manager may terminate employment;·It is signed by each of Mr Anquetil of PPA and Mr Scarano of Roni’s;·It refers to the offer of employment as being from Roni’s and the computer internet and email usage policy and health and safety policy refer only to Roni’s and employees of Roni’s;·The computer internet and email usage policy has an acknowledgment signed by the employee that acceptance of the policy is a condition of employment with Roni’s. I consider that the terms of the tripartite Letter of Engagement, despite the use of the terms ‘manager’ to describe Roni’s and ‘employer’ to describe PPA, do not clearly establish that Mr Mackay is an employee of PPA. In fact, the matters referred to in the previous paragraph suggest that the employer is Roni’s and that PPA is Roni’s “hiring partner” and is probably acting as agent of Roni’s in relation to payroll matters. There is no other agreement between any of the parties.Totality of Relationship