Machuca v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
CITATION: Machuca v Brisbane City Council [2017] QCAT 19
PARTIES: Israel Antonio Quintanilla Machuca
(Applicant)
v
Brisbane City Council
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR227-16
MATTER TYPE: General administrative review matters
HEARING DATE: On the papers
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member Hughes
DELIVERED ON: 24 January 2017
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:
  1. The Application is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL - JURISDICTION – REVIEWABLE DECISIONS – where application for food licence – where change of licensed premises – where Applicant sought to amend licence application rather than pay fee for new application - where enabling Act required ‘original decision’ and internal ‘review decision’ before applying for external review – where email exchange between applicant and council responded to applicant’s enquiries, reflected an exchange of views and did not constitute an ‘application’ leading to an ‘original decision’ or internal review – where to construe otherwise would be contrary to purpose of enabling Act – where no ‘reviewable decision’ under an enabling Act

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 48A
Food Act 2006 (Qld), s 8, s 9, s 74, s 85, s 236, s 237, s 238, s 239, s 241
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 17

Cayless v. Gold Coast Waterways Authority [2016] QCAT 16
Inki Group Pty Ltd v. Brisbane City Council [2015] QCAT 32
The Bell Hotel Pty Ltd v. Brisbane City Council [2012] QCAT 320

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to section 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act).

REASONS FOR DECISION

What is this Application about?

  1. Israel Machuca applied to the Brisbane City Council for a licence for his food stall and also for where the food is separately prepared. He paid an application fee of $733 for each licence. The Council approved his applications, but then the operator preparing his food moved premises.

  2. Mr Machuca believes he should be able to apply to amend the food preparation licence to the new premises, without having to again pay the full application fee of $733. He is willing to pay $155, which he estimates would cover the cost of a reinspection.

  3. Mr Machuca has applied to the Tribunal to review what he says is a ‘decision’ of the Council. In response, the Council has applied to dismiss Mr Machuca’s application for review on the grounds that there is no ‘reviewable decision’.

Who can apply to the Tribunal for review?

  1. The Tribunal only has jurisdiction to review a ‘reviewable decision’ under an enabling Act.[1] The enabling Act here is the Food Act 2006 (Qld).

    [1]        Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 17.

  2. Mr Machuca submitted that because the Council emailed him on 19 August 2016 about his food licence, an ‘internal review’ of an ‘original decision’ of 12 August 2016 “was undertaken as required under the Act” and “the section 241 requirement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Machuca v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCAT 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Machuca, the applicant, sought to amend his application for a food licence after changing the premises. Brisbane City Council, the respondent, refused to consider the amendment. The dispute reached the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The primary issue before the QCAT was whether the email exchange between Machuca and the Council constituted an "original decision" and "review decision" under the Food Act 2006 (Qld) that would permit QCAT to exercise its jurisdiction to review the Council's decision. Machuca argued that the email exchange was an "original decision" by the Council that required an amendment to his food licence application. The Council contended that the email was not an "original decision" but rather a response to Machuca's enquiry. The QCAT found that the Council's email was not an "original decision" about an amendment to Machuca's food licence, as it was not in response to an application for a licence or amendment as required by the Act. The Tribunal also found that the email did not constitute a "review decision" as there had been no internal review process undertaken by the Council. The QCAT concluded that Machuca had not satisfied the jurisdictional requirements to seek external review of the Council's decision, and therefore dismissed the application for lack of jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Chapter 9 of the Act governs reviews. Section 241 falls within Chapter 9 and provides for whom may apply for external review by the Tribunal. Section 241 provides (my underlining) that a person who has applied for the review of an original decision under part 1 and is dissatisfied with the review decision may apply to the Tribunal to review the review decision.[3] [3] Food Act 2006 (Qld), s 241(1). Part 1 of Chapter 9 provides an initial internal review process by the Council. A person must undertake this process before applying to the Tribunal – by first applying to the Council to internally review an ‘original decision’. Section 241 only then provides a right to apply to the Tribunal for review of that ‘review decision’.[4] [4] The Bell Hotel Pty Ltd v. Brisbane City Council [2012] QCAT 320 at [6]. Before a person can apply to the Tribunal for external review, section 241 therefore requires: 1.An ‘original decision’ by Council; and2. A ‘review decision’ by Council. The Council’s email to Mr Machuca of 12 August 2016 reads:Unfortunately the advice you have received from Maria[5] is correct – the food business licence is attached to an address / premises and if you move premises you need to apply for a new food business licence.I have spoken with Ellen and neither of us are (sic) aware of The Greenhive Kitchen’s intention to relocate.If you require any further assistance please feel free to reply by email.[6] [5] From the operator preparing the food.[6] Email Rudi Martin, Senior Environmental Health Officer to Israel Machuca dated 12 August 2016. The Tribunal is not satisfied that this is an ‘original decision’ about an amendment to Mr Machuca’s food licence,[7] because it is not in response to any application for a licence or amendment as required by the Act.[8] [7] Food Act 2006 (Qld), s 74.[8] Food Act 2006 (Qld), s 85(1)(d), (2). In his submissions filed with the Tribunal, Mr Machuca referred to “an application to amend the licence based on the change of premises, as permitted under section 74 of the Act, was made on the 12 August 2016”.[9] [9] Applicant’s Submission In Reply To The Application To Dismiss Proceedings filed 28 November 2016 at [13]. However, Mr Machuca did not file with the Tribunal any ‘application to amend’ under section 74 of the Act. Instead, Mr Machuca’s submissions noted that his “request also sought information on the application process…” and quoted an email to the Council on 12 August 2016.[10] [10] Applicant’s Submission In Reply To The Application To Dismiss Proceedings filed 28 November 2016 at [13]. Section 74 of the Act specifically requires that an application for amendment be accompanied by the licence and comply with section 85. Section 85 of the Act then requires an application for a licence or amendment to be in the approved form, signed by the applicant and accompanied by the prescribed fee.[11] [11] Food Act 2006 (Qld), s 85(2). The Council informed the Tribunal of no prescribed fee for an amendment, other than for a minor amendment.[12] For the purposes of this application to dismiss, I will interpret this as meaning that Mr Machuca was not required to pay a prescribed fee to amend his application for a licence.[12] Application To Dismiss Proceedings at [28].