M Plus 2 Projects Pty Ltd v Silvester and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

M Plus 2 Projects Pty Ltd v Silvester & Anor [2020] QCAT 228

PARTIES: M PLUS 2 PROJECTS PTY LTD

(applicant)

v

TRAVIS SILVESTER

(first respondent)

COLLEEN SILVESTER
(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL085-19

MATTER TYPE:

Building matters

DELIVERED ON:

19 June 2020

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown

ORDERS:

The application for miscellaneous matters filed 5 February 2020 is refused.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – CROSS-CLAIMS: SET-OFF AND COUNTERCLAIM – GENERALLY – COUNTERLCAIM INVOLVING THIRD PERSON

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – JOINDER OF CAUSES OF ACTION AND OF PARTIES – PARTIES – GENERALLY – whether claim against engineer is a domestic building dispute – where only an individual may be registered as an engineer - where the parties are corporations – whether designing and planning work falls within the meaning of domestic building work – where no compliance with s 77(2) of the QBCC Act – where the tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear and decide the dispute

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 14A(1), sch 1
Professional Engineers Act 2002 (Qld), s 8(1), s 42(1)
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 31(1), s 31(2), s 67AZN(1), s 67AZN(2), s 77(2), sch 1B, s 4(1), s 4(3), sch 2
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Regulation 2018 (Qld), sch 1, s 5
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 3(b), s 42(1), s 61(1)(b), s 61(1)(c), s 62(1)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld), r 48(1), r 48(2), r 50(1)(b), r 51(2), r 51(3)

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Manny (No 4) [2013] ACTSC 236
Cleary, J. v Bowcock, M. [2005] QCCTB 8
D G Madin Ltd v Gordon [1964] SASR 64
ML Spicer Pty Ltd t/as Purebuild Homes v Doeuk [2016] QCAT 214
Smith v Buskell [1919] 2 KB 362

Watkins Ltd v Plancorp No 6 Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 501

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

No appearance

Respondent:

Romans & Romans Lawyers

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. M Plus 2 Projects Pty Ltd (‘MP2’) entered into a contract with the Silvesters to build a house. The parties fell into dispute. MP2 commenced proceedings claiming monies owing under the contract or alternatively damages for breach of contract. The Silvesters counterclaim for damages for breach of contract and negligence. They also seek restitution on the basis of a total lack of consideration.

  2. The Silvesters have applied to join two additional parties, Casswell Consulting Pty Ltd and Cyber Services Group Pty Ltd, as respondents to their counterclaim.[1] The joinder application falls for consideration.

    [1]Application for miscellaneous matters filed 5 February 2020.

    Background to the dispute

  3. In early 2016 the Silvesters engaged an architect to prepare plans for a proposed dwelling to be constructed on land in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read M Plus 2 Projects Pty Ltd v Silvester and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCAT 228
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Silvesters have applied to join two additional parties, Casswell Consulting Pty Ltd and Cyber Services Group Pty Ltd, as respondents to their counterclaim. The application was brought by the Silvesters who are the respondents to a building dispute claim brought by MP2 Projects Pty Ltd. The application was refused by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The Silvesters sought to join Casswell and Cyber to their counterclaim, which involved allegations of defects in the engineering design and drawings prepared by Casswell and the inspection and certification works performed by Cyber. The QCAT had to determine whether the dispute between the Silvesters and Casswell and Cyber fell within the jurisdiction of the QCAT as a domestic building dispute and whether the application to join the parties was consistent with the objects of the QCAT Act.

The QCAT considered whether the dispute between the Silvesters and Casswell and Cyber fell within the definition of a domestic building dispute under the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) and whether the tribunal had the statutory power to assist with the resolution of contractual matters between a homeowner and professional engineers. The QCAT also considered the application in light of the objects of the QCAT Act which include having the tribunal deal with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal and quick. The QCAT concluded that the application was brought at an early stage of the proceedings and that there was no prejudice to the other parties or any persons proposed to be joined as respondents to the counter-application. However, the QCAT concluded that the application to join the parties was not consistent with the objects of the QCAT Act as the tribunal did not have the statutory power to assist with the resolution of contractual matters between a homeowner and professional engineers.

The QCAT refused the application for miscellaneous matters filed 5 February 2020. The Silvesters' application to join Casswell and Cyber to their counterclaim was refused as the QCAT did not have the statutory power to assist with the resolution of contractual matters between a homeowner and professional engineers. The QCAT did not transfer the proceedings to the Supreme Court as requested by the Silvesters. The QCAT's decision was based on the tribunal's lack of jurisdiction to hear and decide the dispute between the Silvesters and Casswell and Cyber.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for miscellaneous matters filed 5 February 2020 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Silvesters have applied to join two additional parties, Casswell Consulting Pty Ltd and Cyber Services Group Pty Ltd, as respondents to their counterclaim.[1] The joinder application falls for consideration. [1]Application for miscellaneous matters filed 5 February 2020.Background to the dispute In early 2016 the Silvesters engaged an architect to prepare plans for a proposed dwelling to be constructed on land in Fortitude Valley. At or about this time the Silvesters also engaged Casswell to prepare structural designs for the proposed dwelling. Casswell subsequently prepared revised structural drawings. In May 2018 the Silvesters and MP2 entered into a contract for the construction of the dwelling.[2] The contract included the revised structural drawings prepared by Casswell.[3] Casswell subsequently prepared further revised structural drawings. It appears that the Silvesters originally intended that Casswell would also periodically inspect the building works being carried out by MP2 and certify the works. Instead, the Silvesters engaged Cyber to undertake the inspection and certification works. [2]Draft amended response and counter-application, para 13.[3]Contract dated 30 May 2018 - Drawing 16002. Cyber undertook inspections of the building works on various dates and issued four (4) Form 16 certificates certifying that, inter alia, MP2 had performed the building works in accordance with the revised structural drawings. MP2 says that during the course of the building works the Silvesters took possession of the site with the result that the works were contractually deemed to have reached practical completion. The Silvesters deny having taken possession of the site. They say that MP2 repudiated the contract entitling them the Silvesters to terminate which they did. The Silvesters lodged a non-completion claim with the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘QBCC’). A report by Matthew Cornell (‘the Cornell report’), [4] prepared after the claim was lodged with the QBCC, identified a number of defects in the building work undertaken by MP2. The Cornell report also identified a number of defects in the engineering design and drawings prepared by Casswell. [4]The Cornell Report dated 15 May 2019.Counter-applications and the joinder of parties – the QCAT Act and rules The tribunal may make an order joining a person as a party to a proceeding if the tribunal considers that:(a)The person should be bound by, or have the benefit of, a decision of the tribunal in the proceeding;(b)The person’s interests may be affected by the proceeding;(c)For another reason, it is desirable that the person be joined as a party to the proceeding.[5][5]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’), s 42(1). The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT rules’) provide that a respondent to an application, in response to the application, may apply to the tribunal for stated orders against another person, who may or may not be a party to the proceeding (a counter-application).[6] The rules do not differentiate in respect of a proposed counter-application against a party or a non-party. In neither case is the leave of the tribunal required to pursue a counter-application. [6]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT rules’), r 48(1).

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Silvesters allege that they entered into an agreement with Cyber whereby Cyber would undertake engineering inspections and certify the works performed by MP2.[45] Whether the work undertaken by Cyber falls within designing and planning work is not a matter upon which any concluded view can be formed, at least in the present application. [45]Draft amended response and counter-application, para 19(c).Conclusion The application for miscellaneous matters is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In reply the Silvesters say:(a)On a proper construction of the QBCC Act, the disputes between the Silvesters and Casswell and Cyber are domestic building disputes;(b)They have complied with s 77(2) of the QBCC Act;(c)The QBCC does not have the statutory power to assist with the resolution of contractual matters between a homeowner and professional engineers;(d)Should the tribunal determine that it does not have jurisdiction in respect of the dispute between the Silvesters and Casswell or the Silversters and Cyber, the proceedings should be transferred to the Supreme Court. Consideration As I have observed, the QCAT rules provide that a counter-application against either an existing party or another person must be included in the response filed by the respondent.[18] The principal purpose of rule 48 is to enable a respondent to an application to make a counter-application without having to make a separate application to the tribunal.[19][18]QCAT rules, r 48(1).[19]Ibid, r 48(2). The tribunal may:(a)Extend or shorten a time limit fixed by the QCAT Act, an enabling Act or the rules;[20](b)Waive compliance with another procedural requirement under the QCAT Act, an enabling Act or the rules;[21](c)Give a direction at any time in a proceeding and do whatever is necessary for the speedy and fair conduct of the proceeding.[22][20]QCAT Act, s 61(1)(b).[21]Ibid, s 61(1)(c).[22]Ibid, s 62(1). The Silvesters seek to amend their response and counter-application and thereby join Casswell and Cyber to the proceedings. Accordingly, I approach the application by the Silvesters as seeking leave to amend the response and counter-application. The QCAT Act and rules are to be applied consistently with the objects of the Act including having the tribunal deal with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal and quick.[23] Subject to what I have said earlier in these reasons regarding the necessary relationship or connection between the relief sought in a counter-application and the subject of the original proceeding, where leave to amend a response and counter-application is sought and where the amendment is not likely to cause prejudice to the other parties or any persons proposed to be joined as respondents to the counter-application, it is consistent with the objects of the QCAT Act to permit such an amendment to enable all of the issues to be determined justly and expeditiously. This is of course subject to the application of the relevant principles in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University.[24] [23]Ibid, s 3(b).[24](2009) 258 ALR 14. Here, the Silvesters have brought the application at a relatively early stage of the proceedings and the Aon considerations regarding late amendment do not fall for consideration. It is trite to observe that leave to bring a counter-application against a non party will not be granted if the proposed claim is not within the jurisdiction of the tribunal. Building disputes Whether a dispute is a ‘building dispute’ requires consideration of the provisions of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (‘QBCC Act’) and the complex interaction between the provisions of the Act and the various schedules of the Act. Of specific relevance for present purposes are Schedule 1B and Schedule 2.