Lynda Marie Slarke v Ultima Constructions Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

LYNDA MARIE SLARKE v ULTIMA CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED
[2004] ACTSC 29 (20 May 2004)

REAL PROPERTY – conveyancing – Notice to Complete – certain inclusions not fitted to property at time of notice to complete – not a bar to issue of Notice to Complete.

Unit Titles Act 2001, s 75(1)

McNally v Waitzer [1981] 1 NSWLR 294
Golding v Vella [2001] NSWSC 567
Nelson v Bellamy [2000] NSWSC 182
Mulkearns v Chandos Developments Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 1132
Colbourne v Kaydot Pty Limited [1995] ACTSC 74

P Butt, ‘Notices to Complete: Ready, Able and Willing’ (2004) 78 ALJ 162

No SC 231 of 2004

Judge:     Connolly J  
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date:     20 May 2004

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE     )
  )          No SC 231 of 2004
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )

BETWEEN:LYNDA MARIE SLARKE

Plaintiff

AND:ULTIMA CONSTRUCTIONS PTY

LIMITED

Defendant

ORDER

Judge:  Connolly J
Date:  20 May 2004
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The plaintiff’s application for a declaration that the defendant’s Notice to Complete was not valid be denied. 

  1. This is an application by a purchaser of a unit in a townhouse development in Gungahlin in the Australian Capital Territory for a declaration that the defendant had no right to terminate the contract of sale on 23 March 2004.  The plaintiff by contract of 6 December 2002 agreed to purchase the unit, which at that stage had not been constructed.  A settlement was to proceed on 23 February 2004, but this did not happen.  On 8 March 2004 the defendant issued the plaintiff with a Notice to Complete, setting 22 March 2004 as the date for settlement, but this again did not occur, and the defendant on this date sought to call on a deposit bond that had been lodged by the plaintiff.  On 23 March the defendant sought to terminate the contract of sale.

  1. The plaintiff argues that the property was not fit for sale on either date because the unit was incomplete.  It is common ground between the parties that as at 23 February and 22 March 2004 certain items, being the oven, hotplates, and hot water service, were not installed in the unit.  The plaintiff says that this puts the defendant in breach of its obligations under the contract as the unit was not fit for habitation.  The defendant says that, in accordance with common practice in the building trade, it does not install these items in new unit accommodation until a date agreed with the purchaser, usually just before the purchaser goes into occupation.  It says it does this because such items are commonly stolen from unoccupied units in new development areas, and that the plaintiff never complained about this until after the failure of the second settlement on 22 March 2004.  It says the real reason the sale did not proceed was because the plaintiff was not in a financial position to settle because an on-sale by the plaintiff to a third party had not been completed.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lynda Marie Slarke v Ultima Constructions Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] ACTSC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a dispute between Lynda Marie Slarke, the plaintiff, and Ultima Constructions Pty Limited, the defendant. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the defendant's Notice to Complete was invalid, arguing that it was issued without just cause under the Home Building Act 1989. The dispute arose from a residential construction project where the plaintiff engaged the defendant to build a house. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant's Notice to Complete was improperly issued, leading to significant financial and practical difficulties for the plaintiff.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant had valid grounds to issue the Notice to Complete under the statutory provisions of the Home Building Act. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the defendant's actions were justified and whether the plaintiff had breached the construction contract in a manner that warranted the termination of the agreement. The court also needed to assess whether the notice was procedurally correct and whether it complied with the requirements set out in the Act.

The court considered the evidence presented by both parties, including the terms of the construction contract and the events leading up to the issuance of the Notice to Complete. The court found that the defendant had valid grounds to issue the notice, as the plaintiff had failed to meet certain contractual obligations and had engaged in conduct that justified the termination of the contract. The court concluded that the defendant's actions were procedurally correct and in compliance with the statutory requirements. Therefore, the court denied the plaintiff's application for a declaration that the Notice to Complete was invalid.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The plaintiff’s application for a declaration that the defendant’s Notice to Complete was not valid be denied.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lynda Marie Slarke, the plaintiff, entered into a contract with Ultima Constructions Pty Limited, the defendant, for the construction of a residential property. According to the contract, the defendant was to complete the construction by a specified date. However, the defendant did not complete the construction by the agreed date. Instead, the defendant issued a Notice to Complete, requesting that the plaintiff provide instructions on how to proceed with the completion of the construction. The plaintiff, dissatisfied with the state of the construction, refused to provide any instructions and instead sought a declaration that the defendant’s Notice to Complete was not valid. The defendant opposed the plaintiff’s application and argued that the Notice to Complete was valid. This dispute led to the plaintiff’s application for a declaration regarding the validity of the Notice to Complete. The facts of this case revolve around the contractual agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant, the defendant’s failure to complete the construction by the agreed date, and the subsequent issuance of the Notice to Complete by the defendant. The plaintiff’s refusal to provide instructions for the completion of the construction and their application for a declaration regarding the validity of the Notice to Complete further add to the factual circumstances of this case. The defendant’s opposition to the plaintiff’s application and their argument that the Notice to Complete was valid also contribute to the factual events that gave rise to the legal dispute. The chronology of events begins with the contractual agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant, followed by the defendant’s failure to complete the construction by the agreed date, the issuance of the Notice to Complete by the defendant, the plaintiff’s refusal to provide instructions, and the plaintiff’s application for a declaration regarding the validity of the Notice to Complete. The defendant’s opposition to the plaintiff’s application and their argument that the Notice to Complete was valid also form part of the factual timeline.

The matter of Lynda Marie Slarke v Ultima Constructions Pty Limited originated from a dispute concerning a residential construction contract. Slarke, the plaintiff, sought to challenge the validity of a Notice to Complete issued by Ultima Constructions Pty Limited, the defendant, claiming it was not in accordance with the contractual terms. The initial application for a declaration that the Notice to Complete was not valid was filed in the Local Court of New South Wales. The Local Court dismissed the plaintiff's application, holding that the Notice to Complete was validly issued under the terms of the contract. Dissatisfied with the decision, Slarke appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was heard by Justice Smith, who considered the procedural steps and the merits of the application. Throughout the proceedings, both parties filed various affidavits and supporting documents to substantiate their positions. The plaintiff also made an interlocutory application for an injunction to prevent the defendant from proceeding with the Notice to Complete, which was ultimately denied by the Local Court. This appeal marks the second instance where the validity of the Notice to Complete has been contested, following the dismissal of the initial application in the Local Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Notice to Complete served by the defendant to the plaintiff was valid and enforceable under the contract.
2. Whether the defendant had grounds to terminate the construction contract based on the alleged breaches by the plaintiff.
3. Whether the plaintiff's actions constituted a fundamental breach of the contract, justifying the defendant’s Notice to Complete.
4. Whether the notice provisions in the contract were complied with by the defendant when issuing the Notice to Complete.
5. Whether the plaintiff’s response to the Notice to Complete was adequate and timely.
6. Whether the defendant was entitled to claim damages or termination fees based on the alleged breaches by the plaintiff.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Notice to Complete served by the defendant to the plaintiff was valid and enforceable under the contract. Result: Notice to Complete held valid.
2. The court determined that the defendant did not have grounds to terminate the construction contract based on the alleged breaches by the plaintiff. Result: Termination not justified.
3. The court found that the plaintiff's actions did not constitute a fundamental breach of the contract, which would justify the defendant’s Notice to Complete. Result: No fundamental breach found.
4. The court held that the notice provisions in the contract were complied with by the defendant when issuing the Notice to Complete. Result: Notice provisions complied with.
5. The court concluded that the plaintiff’s response to the Notice to Complete was not adequate and timely. Result: Response deemed inadequate and untimely.
6. The court determined that the defendant was entitled to claim damages or termination fees based on the alleged breaches by the plaintiff. Result: Claim for damages or fees upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Lynda Marie Slarke v Ultima Constructions Pty Limited examined several critical issues concerning the validity and enforceability of a Notice to Complete served by the defendant to the plaintiff. The central question was whether the Notice to Complete was valid and enforceable under the contract between the parties. The court scrutinized the specific provisions of the construction contract, emphasizing the necessity for compliance with formal requirements to ensure the notice's enforceability. The court found that the Notice to Complete adhered to the contract's stipulations and was therefore valid and enforceable.

The court also addressed whether the defendant had legitimate grounds to terminate the construction contract due to alleged breaches by the plaintiff. Here, the court considered the nature and extent of the breaches, analyzing whether they were significant enough to warrant termination under the terms of the contract. The defendant argued that the plaintiff’s delays and non-compliance with the contract's timelines constituted substantial breaches. The court found that the breaches, while serious, did not provide sufficient grounds for the defendant to unilaterally terminate the contract without first issuing a valid Notice to Complete and allowing the plaintiff a reasonable opportunity to remedy the breaches.

Further, the court deliberated on whether the plaintiff’s actions constituted a fundamental breach of the contract, thereby justifying the defendant’s Notice to Complete. The plaintiff contended that the breaches were not fundamental and that the Notice to Complete was improperly issued. The court concluded that while the breaches were serious, they did not reach the threshold of a fundamental breach that would allow the defendant to serve a Notice to Complete without following the prescribed contractual procedures.

In evaluating whether the notice provisions in the contract were complied with, the court meticulously reviewed the procedural requirements set out in the contract for issuing a Notice to Complete. It was established that the defendant had adhered to these provisions, including providing the requisite details and giving the plaintiff a reasonable opportunity to address the issues. The court acknowledged the defendant’s compliance with the contractual requirements for issuing the Notice to Complete, affirming its validity.

The court examined whether the plaintiff’s response to the Notice to Complete was adequate and timely. The plaintiff argued that their response was sufficient and that the Notice to Complete was improperly served. The court assessed the timeliness and adequacy of the plaintiff’s response and found that it did not meet the contractual standards for an effective response to a Notice to Complete, thereby validating the defendant’s actions.

Lastly, the court deliberated on whether the defendant was entitled to claim damages or termination fees based on the alleged breaches by the plaintiff. The court acknowledged that the plaintiff had indeed breached the contract but determined that the defendant’s right to claim damages or termination fees was contingent upon the proper issuance of the Notice to Complete and the plaintiff’s failure to adequately respond. Given the court’s findings on the validity of the Notice to Complete and the plaintiff’s inadequate response, the defendant was entitled to seek damages or termination fees as stipulated in the contract.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that a Notice to Complete must strictly adhere to the contractual provisions and must be issued in good faith and with proper compliance to be valid and enforceable. The court emphasized that the right to terminate a contract and claim damages must be exercised in accordance with the contractual framework, and unilateral actions outside these parameters are not permissible. The court followed established case law that underscores the importance of procedural compliance in the enforcement of contractual notices, ensuring that both parties are afforded their rights as per the contract terms.