Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Specsavers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Specsavers Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1344

Citation: Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Specsavers Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1344
Parties: LUXOTTICA RETAIL AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 000 025 758) v SPECSAVERS PTY LTD (ACN 097 147 932)
File number: NSD 1555 of 2010
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 18 November 2010
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – application for interlocutory injunction preventing broadcast or publication of advertisement – whether advertisement misleading or deceptive because it described certain offers as free
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 50
Federal Court Rules O 62 r 29
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52, 53(e)
Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 63, 208 CLR 199
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill [2006] HCA 46, 227 CLR 57
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Prouds Jewellers Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 199
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v SingTel Optus Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1177
Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148
Equity Access Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation & Westpac Savings Bank Ltd (1990) ATPR ¶40-994
Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Pty Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 82

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21, 240 CLR 651

Telstra Corporation Limited v Cable & Wireless Optus Ltd [2001] FCA 1478
World Series Cricket Pty Ltd v Parish (1977) 16 ALR 181

Date of hearing: 15 November 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 73
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Hall
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mallesons Stephen Jaques
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr R Cobden SC with Mr H Bevan
Solicitor for the Respondent: Minter Ellison

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1555 of 2010

BETWEEN:

LUXOTTICA RETAIL AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 000 025 758)
Applicant

AND:

SPECSAVERS PTY LTD (ACN 097 147 932)
Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 NOVEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 50 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and until further order, the publication of Exhibit 2 (being the folder marked “Confidential Exhibit SH‑2”) is restricted to the following persons:

(a)       the respondent;      

(b)the external legal representatives of the parties; and

(c)Mr Michael Sheedy, in-house legal counsel for the Applicant.

2.The applicant’s claim for interlocutory relief is refused.

3.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

4.The proceeding be listed for directions before the docket judge on a date to be fixed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1555 of 2010

BETWEEN:

LUXOTTICA RETAIL AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
(ACN 000 025 758)
Applicant

AND:

SPECSAVERS PTY LTD (ACN 097 147 932)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Specsavers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd, an Italian luxury eyewear company, brought an action against Specsavers Pty Ltd, an Australian optical retailer, in the Federal Court of Australia. Luxottica sought an interlocutory injunction to restrain Specsavers from advertising a promotional offer for the sale of contact lenses. The crux of the dispute was whether Specsavers' promotion, which included the offer of 30 pairs of Umere Silicon Hydrogel daily disposable contact lenses for free when purchasing one pair of glasses from a specific range, contravened Luxottica's rights under Australian competition and consumer law. Luxottica argued that Specsavers' offer unfairly targeted Luxottica's products and caused consumer confusion.

The court had to determine whether Luxottica had established a serious question to be tried, would suffer irreparable injury without an injunction, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the granting of the injunction. Luxottica needed to demonstrate that there was a probability it would succeed at the trial, that it would suffer irreparable harm for which damages would be inadequate, and that the balance of convenience weighed in its favour. The court assessed the evidence and found that while there was some ambiguity about whether the 25% discount offer had been consistently applied, there was no clear evidence that Specsavers had acted unfairly or caused irreparable harm to Luxottica. The court concluded that the balance of convenience did not favour the grant of injunctive relief.

In its decision, the court emphasised that Luxottica had not made out a strong case for interlocutory relief and that the balance of convenience did not support the grant of an injunction. The court also considered discretionary grounds and refused the order sought by Luxottica. The court granted Specsavers' application for confidentiality regarding certain documents, finding that the disclosure of these documents could prejudice the administration of justice by allowing competitors to gain an unfair commercial advantage.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts in support of the claim for interlocutory relief are contained in two affidavits sworn by Jaime Lee and Emma Bathurst, both solicitors with Mallesons Stephen Jaques, who act for Luxottica in the proceeding, and one sworn by Katrina Rathie, the responsible partner. The injunction is opposed. Specsavers relies on two affidavits sworn by Lynne Peach, a partner at Minter Ellison, Specsavers’s solicitors, an affidavit sworn by one of her employed solicitors, Jonathon Friedrich, and an affidavit sworn by Simon Hawkins, Joint Marketing Director of Specsavers. Background Mr Hawkins referred at length in his affidavit to the background to the campaign. For some time before 30 August 2010, Specsavers branded stores offered a 25% discount to any customer who purchased one pair of glasses from the $179 range (“the 25% offer”). The cost to the customer under this offer was therefore $134.25. Mr Hawkins did not say when the 25% offer began, but Ms Rathie gave evidence that she was told by Mr Michael Sheedy, Luxottica’s in-house counsel, based on his regular review of Specsavers’s website, that the 25% offer had been in place at least since the start of 2010. Mr Hawkins gave evidence that the 25% offer had been “a standard offer” but that during the first half of 2010, Specsavers made a decision that it would no longer be a standard offer but “a promotional offer”, available from time to time and not able to be used in conjunction with any other offer. Reflecting this decision, he said, the in-store brochure issued to Specsavers stores on 2 August 2010, called the Clear Price Guide, said that the 25% offer “cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer” and is “available for a limited time only”. Despite this change, in a “Partner Communication” - a confidential document sent on 29 August 2010 to all Specsavers stores to keep them up to date (amongst other things) with price changes and new offers - the stores were told that from 30 August 2010 the 25% offer was “terminated” and “there is no longer a standard offer of 25% off a single pair”. Luxottica put some weight on the use of the expression “standard offer” to support of its argument that the 25% offer was the normal or standard price up to that time. Until 2 October 2010, when the offer was temporarily restored, Mr Hawkins’s evidence was that 921 single pairs of glasses from the $179 range or above (including 128 from the $179 range) were purchased at full price. There is no evidence that in this period any glasses were sold with a 25% discount. But there is some ambiguity in Mr Hawkins’s evidence about whether any customer received the discount during this period. On 2 August 2010 Specsavers commenced a promotion during which consumers were informed they could receive 30 pairs of Umere Silicon Hydrogel daily disposable contact lenses for free when they purchased one pair of glasses from the $179 range or above (“the Contact Lenses Offer”). The leaflet used to promote the Contact Lenses offer, which Mr Hawkins said was distributed to about 6 million households on or around 30 October 2010, showed that 30 pairs of disposable contact lenses cost $60 and carried a disclaimer that the offer could not be used in conjunction with any other offer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The principles governing the grant of an interlocutory injunction are well established. Luxottica must prove that:(1)there is a serious question to be tried or thatit has made out a prima facie case, in the sense that, if the evidence remains as it is, there is a probability that at the trial of the action it will be held entitled to relief; (2)it will suffer irreparable injury for which damages will not be an adequate remedy; and (3)the balance of convenience favours the granting of an injunction.See Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148 at 153; Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill [2006] HCA 46, 227 CLR 57 (“ABC v O’Neill”) at 81-84.The evidence The facts in support of the claim for interlocutory relief are contained in two affidavits sworn by Jaime Lee and Emma Bathurst, both solicitors with Mallesons Stephen Jaques, who act for Luxottica in the proceeding, and one sworn by Katrina Rathie, the responsible partner. The injunction is opposed. Specsavers relies on two affidavits sworn by Lynne Peach, a partner at Minter Ellison, Specsavers’s solicitors, an affidavit sworn by one of her employed solicitors, Jonathon Friedrich, and an affidavit sworn by Simon Hawkins, Joint Marketing Director of Specsavers. Background Mr Hawkins referred at length in his affidavit to the background to the campaign. For some time before 30 August 2010, Specsavers branded stores offered a 25% discount to any customer who purchased one pair of glasses from the $179 range (“the 25% offer”). The cost to the customer under this offer was therefore $134.25. Mr Hawkins did not say when the 25% offer began, but Ms Rathie gave evidence that she was told by Mr Michael Sheedy, Luxottica’s in-house counsel, based on his regular review of Specsavers’s website, that the 25% offer had been in place at least since the start of 2010. Mr Hawkins gave evidence that the 25% offer had been “a standard offer” but that during the first half of 2010, Specsavers made a decision that it would no longer be a standard offer but “a promotional offer”, available from time to time and not able to be used in conjunction with any other offer. Reflecting this decision, he said, the in-store brochure issued to Specsavers stores on 2 August 2010, called the Clear Price Guide, said that the 25% offer “cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer” and is “available for a limited time only”. Despite this change, in a “Partner Communication” - a confidential document sent on 29 August 2010 to all Specsavers stores to keep them up to date (amongst other things) with price changes and new offers - the stores were told that from 30 August 2010 the 25% offer was “terminated” and “there is no longer a standard offer of 25% off a single pair”. Luxottica put some weight on the use of the expression “standard offer” to support of its argument that the 25% offer was the normal or standard price up to that time. Until 2 October 2010, when the offer was temporarily restored, Mr Hawkins’s evidence was that 921 single pairs of glasses from the $179 range or above (including 128 from the $179 range) were purchased at full price. There is no evidence that in this period any glasses were sold with a 25% discount. But there is some ambiguity in Mr Hawkins’s evidence about whether any customer received the discount during this period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, putting to one side my views about whether there is a serious issue to be tried, I believe the balance of convenience weighs in Specsavers’s favour.Conclusion I conclude that there is no serious issue to be tried. At best Luxottica has a weak case, the balance of convenience does not favour the grant of injunctive relief and, in any event, on discretionary grounds the order sought should be refused.Confidentiality Specsavers applies for the following order:Pursuant to s 50 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 and until further order, Exhibit 2 (being the folder marked “Confidential Exhibit SH-2”) be confidential and that it not be published other than to:(a) the Respondent;(b)the external legal representatives of the parties; and(c)Mr Michael Sheedy, in-house legal counsel for the Applicant. Luxottica does not oppose the making of an order in this form. Section 50(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) relevantly provides that the Court may, at any time during or after the hearing of a proceeding, make such order forbidding or restricting the publication of particular evidence as appears to the Court to be necessary in order to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice. In Parish Bowen CJ said at pages 232-233:This court is a court established by statute. It is clear from section 17(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 that, in general, it is obliged to exercise its jurisdiction in open court. This provision gives statutory force to the principle that justice must be administered publicly in open court and gives recognition to the weight of public interest which attaches to that principle. The question, then, is whether the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice (that being the exercise by the Court of the judicial power of the Commonwealth): Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21, 240 CLR 651 at [30]. As Bowen CJ indicated in Parish at 233, where disclosure would prejudice the proper exercise of the function the Court is appointed to discharge – doing justice between the parties – an order ought to be made. His Honour also emphasised that the categories of public interest are not closed. Here the parties are trade rivals. Mr Hawkins evidence was that the documents in question are confidential to Specsavers because they could be used by a competitor to determine Specsavers’s marketing strategy with respect to its television commercials and to better position itself in the market.I accept the evidence. The material is commercially sensitive. I also accept Specsavers’s submission that, in the absence of a confidentiality order, it could suffer prejudice in that its competitors could use the information to their commercial advantage and to Specsavers’s commercial detriment. Promoting competition is one of the purposes of the Trade Practices Act. Without the protection of orders of this nature, a company is unlikely to want to come to court to vindicate its rights.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In assessing the application for interlocutory relief, the court considered the three established principles governing the grant of an interlocutory injunction. Firstly, the court examined whether there was a serious question to be tried, which involves determining if Luxottica has made out a prima facie case, meaning there is a probability it will be entitled to relief at trial. The court found that Luxottica had not demonstrated a serious question to be tried, as the case was at best weak.

Secondly, the court assessed whether Luxottica would suffer irreparable injury for which damages would not be an adequate remedy. The court noted that the nature of the alleged injury was not clearly defined, and Luxottica had not provided sufficient evidence to substantiate its claim of irreparable harm. Consequently, the court concluded that Luxottica was unlikely to suffer irreparable injury.

Thirdly, the court considered the balance of convenience, weighing the potential harm to both parties if the injunction were granted or denied. The court determined that the balance of convenience favoured Specsavers, as Luxottica had not demonstrated that it would suffer significant harm if the injunction were not granted.

Lastly, the court addressed the application for confidentiality concerning certain documents. The court found that the documents in question were commercially sensitive and that Specsavers could suffer prejudice if the information were disclosed. The court accepted the evidence that the documents contained confidential marketing strategies, and their disclosure could harm Specsavers' competitive position. Therefore, the court made an order for confidentiality in relation to the documents, limiting their disclosure to the parties involved and certain individuals.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in interlocutory injunction applications, the court must weigh the three established principles and consider the balance of convenience, even if there is no serious question to be tried. Additionally, the court can make orders for confidentiality to protect commercially sensitive information from being disclosed to competitors.