Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
LUXOTTICA RETAIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v GRANT [2009] NSWCA 378

FILE NUMBER(S):
40306/09

HEARING DATE(S):
23 November 2009

JUDGMENT DATE:
23 November 2009

PARTIES:
Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd - Applicant
Janet Ruth Grant - First Respondent
Andrew Milne Grant - Second Respondent
Specsavers Pty Ltd - Third Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:
McColl JA Basten JA    

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
SC 4571/08

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
White J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
31 July 2009

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant (No 2) [2009] NSWSC 736

COUNSEL:
M J Leeming SC/J K Taylor - Applicant
R Cobden SC - First Respondent

SOLICITORS:
Norton White Lawyers - Applicant
Minter Ellison Lawyers - First Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
COSTS – application for leave to appeal – discretionary costs order – no issue of principle – offer of settlement made by defendant prior to hearing – offer rejected – applicant enjoyed nominal success at trial but failed on single substantive issue litigated – plaintiff ordered to pay defendants' costs following offer – whether basis for interfering with exercise of discretion

LEGISLATION CITED:
[<i>Civil Procedure Act 2005</i>] (NSW), s 98
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.1

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
[<i>Fordyce v Fordham</i>] [2006] NSWCA 274; 67 NSWLR 497
[<i>Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant</i>] [2009] NSWSC 126
[<i>Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin</i>] [1997] HCA 6; 186 CLR 622
[<i>Muhibbah Engineering (M) BHD v Trust Co Ltd</i>] [2009] NSWCA 205
[<i>Newcastle Wallsend Coal Co Pty Ltd v Industrial Relations Commission of NSW</i>] [2006] NSWCA 129; 153 IR 386

TEXTS CITED:

DECISION:
(1)  Dismiss the application for leave to appeal against the costs order made by White J on 31 July 2009.
(2)  Order that the applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the application in this Court.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40306/09
SC 4571/08

McCOLL JA
BASTEN JA

23 November 2009

LUXOTTICA RETAIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v GRANT

Judgment

  1. JUDGMENT of THE COURT delivered by BASTEN JA:  The applicant seeks leave to appeal from a judgment of White J in the Equity Division with respect to the costs of proceedings in that Division: Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant (No 2) [2009] NSWSC 736.

  2. The substantive dispute between the parties concerned a number of documents which the first defendant in the proceedings below (and the first respondent on this application) had emailed to her home computer shortly before the termination of her employment with the applicant (the plaintiff in the proceedings below).  The documents were said to be both confidential and the subject of copyright vested in the applicant.  By the time the matter went to trial, on 23 and 24 February 2009, the only issue in dispute (apart from costs) was the plaintiff’s claim under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) for damages…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd sought leave to appeal from a costs order made by White J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The underlying dispute concerned confidential and copyrighted documents emailed by an employee to her home computer prior to her termination. By the time of trial, the only substantive issue remaining was the applicant's claim for copyright infringement damages, which resulted in a nominal award of $10. The primary judge ordered the applicant to pay the respondents' costs from 18 February 2009, finding that the applicant had unreasonably rejected a settlement offer made by the defendants on 17 February 2009, which would have provided substantially the whole of the relief ultimately obtained.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether there was a sufficient basis to interfere with the primary judge's discretionary costs order, particularly in light of the applicant's nominal success at trial on the sole substantive issue and the rejection of the settlement offer. The applicant's challenge focused on the primary judge's reasoning that the applicant was not entitled to its costs as at 17 February 2009, which underpinned the decision to award costs against it from that date.

The Court of Appeal, comprising McColl and Basten JJA, dismissed the application for leave to appeal. Their Honours reasoned that the primary judge's decision to award costs against the applicant from 17 February 2009 was a proper exercise of discretion. This was based on the finding that the applicant had unreasonably rejected the defendants' settlement offer, which had been made prior to the hearing and would have substantially achieved the outcome the applicant ultimately secured. The court noted that the applicant's insistence on obtaining its costs, despite failing on the substantive issue litigated, was a key factor in the rejection of the offer. The court applied the principle that an appellate court will generally not interfere with a discretionary costs order unless there is an error of law or the order is plainly wrong.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal ordered that the application for leave to appeal against the costs order made by White J be dismissed, and that the applicant pay the respondents' costs of the application in the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Dismiss the application for leave to appeal against the costs order made by White J on 31 July 2009.

(2) Order that the applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the application in this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT of THE COURT delivered by BASTEN JA: The applicant seeks leave to appeal from a judgment of White J in the Equity Division with respect to the costs of proceedings in that Division: Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant (No 2) [2009] NSWSC 736. The substantive dispute between the parties concerned a number of documents which the first defendant in the proceedings below (and the first respondent on this application) had emailed to her home computer shortly before the termination of her employment with the applicant (the plaintiff in the proceedings below). The documents were said to be both confidential and the subject of copyright vested in the applicant. By the time the matter went to trial, on 23 and 24 February 2009, the only issue in dispute (apart from costs) was the plaintiff’s claim under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) for damages for infringement of copyright. That issue resulted in a judgment for the applicant against the first defendant in the sum of $10: see Luxottica Retail Australia Pty Ltd v Grant [2009] NSWSC 126 at [53]. The order made by the primary judge on 31 July 2009 was that the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceedings from and including 18 February 2009 and that there otherwise be no order as to the costs of the proceedings. The reasons given by his Honour for this conclusion appeared in the second judgment at [29]:“However, [the first defendant’s solicitors’] offer of 17 February 2009 gave the plaintiff substantially the whole of the relief which it obtained in the proceedings. … On the findings I have made, [the] offer of 17 February 2009 should have been accepted. The principal reason for its non-acceptance was the plaintiff’s insistence that it obtain its costs. However, for the reasons I have given, the plaintiff was not entitled to its costs. The rejection of the offer of 17 February 2009 was unreasonable. In those circumstances I consider that all of the defendants are entitled to their costs on the ordinary basis from 17 February 2009.” There was no challenge to the reasoning contained in this paragraph: rather, the challenge was to the earlier reason that the plaintiff was not entitled to its costs as at 17 February 2009. That reasoning appeared to refer back to his Honour’s statements at [26] in the following terms:“In the absence of settlement offers and having regard to the parties’ success on the only substantive issues litigated, and having regard to the fact that orders for the delivery up of documents were made by consent and without admissions at the commencement of the hearing, I think the appropriate costs order would be that there be no order as to costs up to 22 February 2009 and that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the hearing. The reason for such an order would be that the plaintiff obtained orders by consent and without admissions on the first day of the hearing for the delivery up of documents. In the absence of any hearing on its entitlement to those orders, there should be no order as to costs. But the plaintiff substantially failed in respect of the matters that were contested at the hearing; the award of nominal damages for breach of contract not being a substantial success.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.