Lumina Bpo Pty Limited v ELB Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lumina BPO Pty Limited v ELB Pty Ltd [2020] NSWDC 710
Hearing dates: 26 August 2020
Date of orders: 26 August 2020
Decision date: 26 August 2020
Jurisdiction:Civil
Before: P Taylor SC DCJ
Decision:

Application for leave to amend defence is refused.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE — Pleadings — Amendment — Late application for amendment

Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Lumina BPO Pty Limited (plaintiff)
ELB Pty Ltd (defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr D Neggo (plaintiff)
Mr M T Keene (defendant)

Solicitors:
Watson Mangioni Lawyers Pty Ltd (plaintiff)
John de Mestre & Co Solicitors Pty Ltd (defendant)
File Number(s): 2019/228108
Publication restriction: None

Judgment

  1. The defendant, ELB Pty Ltd, during final submissions seeks leave to file a Further Amended Defence adding four subparagraphs to paragraph 1 to the plaintiff's claim for payment of invoices.  The additions read:

"(o) Says further, the completion of the Tasks is an entire obligation, which was indivisible and not severable from the obligation of the Defendant to pay any moneys under the agreement to the Plaintiff.

(p) Says in the further alternative, the obligation of the Defendant to pay the Plaintiff was solely dependent on the tasks under the agreement all being completed by the Plaintiff.

(q) in the premises of subparagraph[s] (f) (g) (o) and (p) above, the Defendant is not liable to pay any monies under the Agreement to the plaintiff.

(r) Says that any monies paid by the Defendant to the Plaintiff was paid on account only."

  1. If it were the case that this amendment did not raise the possibility of further evidence, but was solely a question of construction of the written contracts, I would be minded to allow it.  However, here the defendant has conceded the possibility of evidence being called by the plaintiff to meet the new defence. 

  2. The plaintiff seeks to raise two answers in the event that the defendant is given leave: conventional estoppel and waiver. 

  3. As to the estoppel, it is uncertain whether the plaintiff suffered detriment by reason of the defendant's conduct in paying the first invoice. The plaintiff says it is out-of-pocket in these proceedings for approximately $150,000 of unpaid work.  But had the defendant not paid the first invoice and the plaintiff ceased work, the plaintiff may well have been out-of-pocket by a similar amount. However, the plaintiff should not be denied the opportunity to present its case merely because its success is not certain. It is too early to know the extent of the plaintiff’s loss had it ceased work after the first invoice, but there remains a real prospect that its loss could have been avoided.

  4. The claim of waiver by the payment of the first invoice appears to have substance, yet it too would require further evidence to be made out.

  5. The plaintiff’s claim is for unpaid services pursuant to a letter of engagement.  The amount claimed is at the lower end of the jurisdiction of this Court, and if…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lumina Bpo Pty Limited v ELB Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWDC 710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lumina Bpo Pty Limited commenced proceedings against ELB Pty Ltd in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, seeking compensation for alleged breaches of contract. The nature of the dispute centres around the interpretation and alleged breaches of a service level agreement (SLA) between the parties. ELB Pty Ltd filed a defence to the claim, but subsequently sought leave to amend its defence on the basis of new information that had come to light. The court had to determine whether the application for leave to amend the defence was made within a reasonable time and whether the amendment would have a reasonable prospect of success.

The court examined the criteria for permitting an amendment of pleadings, which include whether the application was made within a reasonable time, whether there was good faith in the delay, whether the opposing party would be prejudiced if the amendment was allowed, and whether the amendment has a reasonable prospect of success. The court held that the application was not made within a reasonable time, as it came well after the deadline for filing defences. The court also found that the delay was not excusable, as ELB Pty Ltd was aware of the need to amend its defence much earlier. Furthermore, the court held that the proposed amendment did not have a reasonable prospect of success, as it was based on information that was already available at the time the defence was originally filed.

As a result, the court refused the application for leave to amend the defence. The court emphasised the importance of timely and diligent preparation of pleadings, and the need for parties to act in good faith and not to delay proceedings unnecessarily. The refusal of the application for leave to amend the defence means that the case will proceed to trial on the basis of the existing pleadings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for leave to amend defence is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established