Luff and Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Luff and Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2024] AATA 2637 (17 July 2024)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2024/2322 2024/2323

Re:   Christopher Luff

APPLICANT

Re:   Build Your Wealth Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

And Australian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Date:17 July 2024

Place:Sydney

The stay application and confidentiality orders sought by the applicants are refused.

................................[SGD]........................................

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – STAY APPLICATION – interim stay application – ASIC undertaking – objectives of the regulators in making a decision – protection – objective of transparency – stay application and confidentiality orders refused

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185

Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

Xtrade.Au Pty Ltd and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 1372

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

17 July 2024

  1. The corporate and individual applicants have made interlocutory applications for stay and non-publication orders while the Tribunal deals with the decisions under review. An interim stay is currently in place in favour of the corporate applicant while the interlocutory applications are progressed. For reasons I will explain below, I have decided against making the interlocutory orders sought. The interim stay is dissolved (and the respondent is released from its undertaking with respect to publication) as of 4pm on 24 July 2024. These reasons and earlier reasons published to the parties on 3 July 2024 will not be published beyond the parties until 25 July 2024.

    The background to the interlocutory application

  2. Build Your Wealth Pty Ltd (BYW) is the corporate applicant in these proceedings. BYW has asked the Tribunal to make orders under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) staying the operation and implementation of a decision by a delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The delegate made a reviewable decision on 8 April 2024 under s 915C of the Corporations Act 2001 to cancel the Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) of BYW. The same delegate also decided to disqualify Mr Luff, the individual applicant, from providing financial services pursuant to s 920A of the Corporations Act. Mr Luff was a responsible manager of the corporate applicant. He remains the controlling shareholder of the corporate entity.

  3. BYW has also asked for orders under:

    ·s 41(2) of the AAT Act that would restrain ASIC from announcing the reviewable decisions on its website in the ordinary course pending the outcome of the review, and;

    ·s 35 of the AAT Act that would effectively grant a private hearing.

  4. The regulator sometimes agrees to an interim stay in proceedings like these. An interim stay allows each party to properly prepare to deal with the issues that can arise in a contested hearing of stay. But ASIC was initially reluctant to agree to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Luff and Australian Securities & Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2637
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Build Your Wealth Pty Ltd (BYW) and Mr Luff, sought interlocutory orders from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a stay of decisions made by a delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and for non-publication orders. The ASIC delegate had decided to cancel BYW's Australian Financial Services Licence and disqualify Mr Luff, a responsible manager and controlling shareholder of BYW, from providing financial services. An interim stay had been in place for BYW while these applications were considered.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether to grant a stay of ASIC's decisions to cancel BYW's licence and disqualify Mr Luff, and whether to make orders preventing the publication of these decisions. The applicants also sought orders for a private hearing. The core of the dispute involved balancing the applicants' desire to continue operating and maintain confidentiality against ASIC's regulatory objectives, including protection of the public and transparency of its actions.

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe reasoned that while BYW was making progress in addressing ASIC's concerns, including implementing process changes and seeking to appoint a new responsible manager, the seriousness of the breaches identified by ASIC, which pointed to systemic, personnel, and leadership failures, and the ongoing role of Mr Luff, weighed against granting a stay. The Tribunal also refused to make non-publication orders, citing the logistical difficulties and potential prejudice to ASIC's functions, and affirming the principle of open justice as the default position under section 35(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

Consequently, the Tribunal ordered that the interim stay in favour of BYW be dissolved, and ASIC be released from its undertaking not to publish the decisions, both effective from 4pm on 24 July 2024. The applications for non-publication orders were refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The corporate and individual applicants have made interlocutory applications for stay and non-publication orders while the Tribunal deals with the decisions under review. An interim stay is currently in place in favour of the corporate applicant while the interlocutory applications are progressed. For reasons I will explain below, I have decided against making the interlocutory orders sought. The interim stay is dissolved (and the respondent is released from its undertaking with respect to publication) as of 4pm on 24 July 2024. These reasons and earlier reasons published to the parties on 3 July 2024 will not be published beyond the parties until 25 July 2024.The background to the interlocutory application Build Your Wealth Pty Ltd (BYW) is the corporate applicant in these proceedings. BYW has asked the Tribunal to make orders under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) staying the operation and implementation of a decision by a delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The delegate made a reviewable decision on 8 April 2024 under s 915C of the Corporations Act 2001 to cancel the Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) of BYW. The same delegate also decided to disqualify Mr Luff, the individual applicant, from providing financial services pursuant to s 920A of the Corporations Act. Mr Luff was a responsible manager of the corporate applicant. He remains the controlling shareholder of the corporate entity. BYW has also asked for orders under:·s 41(2) of the AAT Act that would restrain ASIC from announcing the reviewable decisions on its website in the ordinary course pending the outcome of the review, and;·s 35 of the AAT Act that would effectively grant a private hearing. The regulator sometimes agrees to an interim stay in proceedings like these. An interim stay allows each party to properly prepare to deal with the issues that can arise in a contested hearing of stay. But ASIC was initially reluctant to agree to an interim stay in this case. ASIC said the specific conduct which led to the regulatory action against BYW was the product of poor processes and personnel, and it was worried further problems might manifest themselves in the short term. After hearing from the parties, I decided an interim stay was appropriate while BYW simultaneously progressed an application it had already made to ASIC’s licensing team for variation of an AFSL that provided for (amongst other things) the appointment of a new responsible manager. If approved by ASIC, the individual, would replace Mr Luff in that role. BYW also spoke about important process changes that it was implementing. ASIC acknowledged the appointment of a new responsible manager, along with the implementation of revised compliance arrangements, might be relevant to the question of whether a stay should be ordered in favour of BYW. The net effect of the interim stay order was that BYW was not required to immediately cease the regulated activity pending the outcome of the (adjourned) interlocutory hearing of stay. I did not make any orders relating to publication of the reviewable decision at that point although ASIC offered an undertaking not to announce news of the reviewable decision on its website while the stay application was on foot.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I discussed other considerations which may relevant, including the potential for an earlier hearing. The parties agreed the matter could be heard before the end of the year, subject to the Tribunal’s availability. That is not an expeditious timetable, but nor is it a delayed one. I do not think this consideration weighs heavily one way or the other.Conclusion in relation to the stay application If there were reasonable prospects of BYW quickly obtaining the variation of its licence that would permit it to implement further changes, the arguments for a stay would have been much stronger. I accept BYW is making progress towards addressing concerns ASIC has raised in reviewable decision. That progress offers some assurance that it can safely remain in business in the short term. But ASIC’s findings point to very serious breaches which were apparently attributable to systemic, personnel and leadership failures, and the ongoing role of Mr Luff is inevitably a concern. Having regard to all the factors I have discussed above, I do not think, on balance, it would be desirable to order a stay. It follows the interim stay should be dissolved. That should occur as of 4pm on 24 July 2024. Subject to my observations about non-publication orders, ASIC should also be released from its undertaking with respect to publication as of 4pm on 24 July 2024.Non-publication orders The applicants both asked for non-publication orders under s 35 of the AAT Act. I refused to make interim non-publication orders for reasons I have already explained on 3 July. Those reasons also explain why I am not disposed to make continuing orders today. Crafting effective orders would create logistical difficulties and be difficult to enforce. Such orders may also prejudice the respondent in the discharge of its function. Ultimately, I am not persuaded why I should depart from the default position referred to in s 35(5) of the AAT Act, which contemplates open justice. I should add I would not be disposed to make continuing orders that kept news of the regulatory action from participants in the market even if I had made stay orders under s 41(2) of the AAT Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established