Ludwig v Copeland

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

INDUSTRIAL LAW - RULES ENFORCEMENT - Officers in amalgamated organisation - Rule providing for full-time positions amended to make the same positions honorary positions - Transitional rule providing that the holders of certain offices shall hold those offices until a stipulated day - Offices described by reference to their constituent organisation before amalgamation - Validity of rule amendment.

Industrial Relations Act 1988, ss.118A(1), 196(a) and (c)

W P LUDWIG, K BALLIN, R BLEWITT, S BOOTH, C BOSWORTH, E BRISCHKE, G BUCKLAND, E J BUTLER, J CAMBRIDGE, F CHAMBERS, B COCHRAN, P CURRIE, T DALY, R DAVIES, J DUNNERY, V FALCONER, J GLISSON, A HARPER, S HARRISON, C HAYES, D HAYES, M HINDLE, G IVORY, G LIVERMORE, W LOWE, B MARTIN, F McINERNEY, B MELKLEJOHN, S MUSCAT, D O'DEA, M O'SHEA, B PATON, F PHILLIPS, D RATCLIFFE, R REDMOND, G ROBERTS, M RUDD, G RYAN, R SMITH, T STEWART, H SUGARS, S WALTERS, M WHEELER, B WILSON, T MUSCAT and AWU-FIME AMALGAMATED UNION

v

ROGER COPELAND, GEOFFREY SUTTON and NICK MINOSKI

No. VI.5026 of 1994

CORAM:    WILCOX CJ, RYAN & MOORE JJ
PLACE:    MELBOURNE
DATE:     9 JUNE 1995

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT)
OF AUSTRALIA  )
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY      )    No. VI.5026 OF 1994

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE
      OF THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:W P LUDWIG, K BALLIN, R BLEWITT, S BOOTH, C BOSWORTH, E BRISCHKE, G BUCKLAND, E J BUTLER, J CAMBRIDGE, F CHAMBERS, B COCHRAN, P CURRIE, T DALY, R DAVIES, J DUNNERY, V FALCONER, J GLISSON, A HARPER, S HARRISON, C HAYES, D HAYES, M HINDLE, G IVORY, G LIVERMORE, W LOWE, B MARTIN, F McINERNEY, B MELKLEJOHN, S MUSCAT, D O'DEA, M O'SHEA, B PATON, F PHILLIPS, D RATCLIFFE, R REDMOND, G ROBERTS, M RUDD, G RYAN, R SMITH, T STEWART, H SUGARS, S WALTERS, M WHEELER, B WILSON, T MUSCAT and AWU-FIME AMALGAMATED UNION

Appellants

AND:ROGER COPELAND,

GEOFFREY SUTTON and

NICK MINOSKI

Respondents

CORAM:    WILCOX CJ, RYAN & MOORE JJ
PLACE:    MELBOURNE
DATE:     9 JUNE 1995

MINUTES OF ORDER

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Industrial Relations Court Rules.


IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT)
OF AUSTRALIA  )
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY      )    No. VI.5026 OF 1994

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE
      OF THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:W P LUDWIG, K BALLIN, R BLEWITT, S BOOTH, C BOSWORTH, E BRISCHKE, G BUCKLAND, E J BUTLER, J CAMBRIDGE, F CHAMBERS, B COCHRAN, P CURRIE, T DALY, R DAVIES, J DUNNERY, V FALCONER, J GLISSON, A HARPER, S HARRISON, C HAYES, D HAYES, M HINDLE, G IVORY, G LIVERMORE, W LOWE, B MARTIN, F McINERNEY, B MELKLEJOHN, S MUSCAT, D O'DEA, M O'SHEA, B PATON, F PHILLIPS, D RATCLIFFE, R REDMOND, G ROBERTS, M RUDD, G RYAN, R SMITH, T STEWART, H SUGARS, S WALTERS, M WHEELER, B WILSON, T MUSCAT and AWU-FIME AMALGAMATED UNION

Appellants

AND:ROGER COPELAND,

GEOFFREY SUTTON and

NICK MINOSKI

Respondents

CORAM:    WILCOX CJ, RYAN &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ludwig v Copeland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] IRCA 300
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Ludwig v Copeland arose from a dispute between members of the amalgamated union AWU-FIME and three respondents who held full-time positions within the union. The respondents, Copeland, Sutton, and Minoski, were officers of the Building Construction and Joinery Branch prior to the amalgamation of the Australian Workers Union and the Federation of Industrial Manufacturing and Engineering Employees. The appellants challenged a resolution passed by the National Executive of AWU-FIME, which sought to amend the union rules to change their full-time positions to honorary roles. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the National Executive had the authority to amend the union rules in such a way as to alter the nature of the respondents' positions from full-time paid roles to honorary positions during the transitional period specified in rule 80 of the union rules.

The court held that the resolution was beyond the power of the National Executive. Rule 80 provided a transitional arrangement that protected the tenure of office holders during the amalgamation period until 30 June 1997. The court found that the resolution to change the nature of the respondents' positions fundamentally altered the terms under which they were elected and continued to hold their offices. The change from full-time paid positions to honorary roles was deemed to be a significant alteration that the National Executive was not empowered to make under the existing rules. The court concluded that the resolution was invalid as it imposed obligations or restrictions on the respondents that were oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust, thereby exceeding the authority granted by the union rules.

The appeal was dismissed, affirming the decision of Keely J that the National Executive did not have the power to amend the union rules in the manner proposed. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the transitional provisions outlined in rule 80 and respecting the elected positions and terms of office of the respondents during the specified period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established