Luce Optical Pty Limited v Budget Specs (Franchising) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Luce Optical Pty Limited v Budget Specs (Franchising) Pty Limited [2006] FCA 221

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – requests for further and better particulars – function of particulars – comparison with interrogatories – ‘vexatious and oppressive’ – whether requests for further and better particulars amount to requests for evidence by which material facts are to be proved

Federal Court Rules O 11 r 2, O 12 r 3, O 16 r 1

Bean v Flower (1895) 73 LT 371
Blake v Albion Life Assurance Society (1876) 45 LJQB 663
Gold Coast City Council v Pioneer Concrete (Qld) Pty Ltd (1998) 157 ALR 135
Goldsmith v Sandilands (2002) 190 ALR 370
GW Young and Co Ltd v Scottish Union and National Insurance Company (1907) 24 TLR 73
International Entertainment (Aust) Pty Ltd v Churchill [2003] QSC 247
King v AG Australia Holdings Ltd (formerly GIO Australia Holdings Ltd) [2003] FCA 543
Norman v Matthews (1916) 85 LJK 857
North Western Salt Co Ltd v Electrolytic Alkali Co Ltd [1913] 3 KB 422
R v Associated Northern Collieries (1910) 11 CLR 738
Re Dependable Upholstery Ltd (1936) 3 All ER 741
Spedding v Fitzpatrick (1888) 38 Ch D 410
Temperton v Russell (1893) 9 TLR 319
The Atlantic Star [1974] AC 436
The Briton Medical and General Life Association Limited v The Britannia Fire Association and Whinney (1889) 59 LT 888
Walton v Gardiner (1992-1993) 177 CLR 378
Wooton v Sievier [1913] 3 KB 499
Young v Holloway [1895] P 87

LUCE OPTICAL PTY LIMITED v BUDGET SPECS (FRANCHISING) PTY LIMITED

QUD 370 OF 2005

COLLIER J
16 MARCH 2006
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 370 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

LUCE OPTICAL PTY LIMITED ACN 093 265 199
APPLICANT

AND:

BUDGET SPECS (FRANCHISING) PTY LIMITED
ACN 006 861 329
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 MARCH 2006

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In relation to para 7 of the Statement of Claim:

a.The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of the timing of the event referred to in para 7 of the Statement of Claim clarifying when the Audit Team is alleged to have arrived at the Budget Mt Gravatt premises;

b.The Applicant must provide particulars of whom it alleges notice or warning should have been given of the Audit Team’s arrival at the Budget Mt Gravatt premises.

2.In relation to para 10 of the Statement of Claim:

a.The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of how and when the conversation referred to in para 9 of the Statement of Claim was relayed to Mr Livoni by Ms Wilde.

b.The Respondent is not entitled to particulars detailing any substance of the alleged conversation between Mr Livoni and Ms Wilde.

3.          In relation to para 11 of the Statement of Claim:

a.The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of the timing of the event referred to in para 11 of the Statement of Claim.

b.The Applicant must particularize…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Luce Optical Pty Limited v Budget Specs (Franchising) Pty Li... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Luce Optical Pty Limited v Budget Specs (Franchising) Pty Limited involved a dispute over requests for further and better particulars of allegations made in the applicant's statement of claim. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's requests for further and better particulars were seeking material facts or evidence. The applicant claimed that several of the respondent's requests were in the nature of seeking evidence rather than material facts. The Federal Court had to consider the principles governing requests for further and better particulars and how they applied to the specific allegations made in the statement of claim.

The court examined the relevant provisions of the Federal Court Rules and previous case law to determine the appropriate scope of requests for further and better particulars. It considered whether the respondent's requests were seeking facts upon which the applicant relied or evidence by which those facts were to be proved. The court also noted that requests for further and better particulars should not be granted if they seek to disclose evidence by which the applicant intends to prove its case at trial. The court had to balance the need for clarity in pleadings with the protection of a party's right to a fair trial.

The court ruled that some of the respondent's requests for further and better particulars were seeking material facts, while others were seeking evidence. The court granted particulars for some paragraphs of the statement of claim, such as the timing of events and the parties involved, while denying requests for the substance of conversations or the content of complaints. The court held that the respondent was not entitled to particulars of the evidence by which the applicant intended to prove its case at trial. The court's reasoning was based on the principles governing requests for further and better particulars and the specific circumstances of the case.

The court ordered that the applicant must provide particulars of certain events, timing, and parties involved in the allegations made in the statement of claim. However, the respondent was not entitled to particulars of the substance of conversations, content of complaints, or evidence by which the applicant intended to prove its case at trial. The court's orders aimed to balance the need for clarity in pleadings with the protection of a party's right to a fair trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to para 7 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of the timing of the event referred to in para 7 of the Statement of Claim clarifying when the Audit Team is alleged to have arrived at the Budget Mt Gravatt premises;

b. The Applicant must provide particulars of whom it alleges notice or warning should have been given of the Audit Team’s arrival at the Budget Mt Gravatt premises.

2. In relation to para 10 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of how and when the conversation referred to in para 9 of the Statement of Claim was relayed to Mr Livoni by Ms Wilde.

b. The Respondent is not entitled to particulars detailing any substance of the alleged conversation between Mr Livoni and Ms Wilde.

3. In relation to para 11 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of the timing of the event referred to in para 11 of the Statement of Claim.

b. The Applicant must particularize the records and information it alleges the Audit Team took and/or copied.

4. In relation to paras 12 and 13 of the Statement of Claim the Respondent is not entitled to particulars of the conversations between Ms Wilde and/or Mr Livoni and one or more of the Audit Team.

5. In relation to para 14 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of any complaint or objection made in relation to the removal of the hard drive, who made the complaint or objection and to whom the complaint or objection was made.

b. The Respondent is not entitled to particulars of the content of any complaint or objection made.

6. In relation to para 18 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent the same particulars to be provided in relation to para 11 of the Statement of Claim above;

b. The Respondent is not entitled to further particulars of para 18(a) of the Statement of Claim;

c. The Applicant must amend para 18(b) of the Statement of Claim or provide the particulars of when, how and by whom on behalf of the Respondent the information and materials referred to are alleged to have been obtained.

7. In relation to para 24 of the Statement of Claim:

a. The Applicant must provide to the Respondent further particulars of para 24(b) of the Statement of Claim as requested.

b. The Respondent is not entitled to any further particulars of para 24(c) of the Statement of Claim.

8. In relation to para 25 of the Statement of Claim the Applicant must provide to the Respondent particulars of the conduct constituting the alleged failure to act in accordance with the Franchise Agreement.

9. In relation to para 29 of the Statement of Claim the Respondent is not entitled to any further particulars.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When these terms are sought to be applied to a request for further and better particulars, the practical application of them is not always an easy task. The special circumstances of each case must be carefully considered (Wootton v Sievier [1913] 3 KB 499 at 503). One test which can be applied is whether the pleading is such that no reasonable person could properly treat it as bona fide (Norman v Mathews (1916) 85 LJKB 857). However, courts will not lightly rule that pleadings are to be struck out for this reason (Bean v Flower (1895) 73 LT 371).Particulars and evidence Order 11 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules states that a pleading of a party shall only contain in a statement in a summary form of the material facts on which the party relies, but not the evidence by which those facts are to be proved (Blake v Albion Life Assurance Society (1876) 45 LJQB 663 at 667 per Brett J and North Western Salt Co Ltd v Electrolytic Alkali Co Ltd [1913] 3 KB 422 at 425.) Further, a request for particulars should not include a request to disclose evidence by which the applicant intends to prove its case at trial (Temperton v Russell (1893) 9 TLR 319 at 322). The application of this principle to individual facts can be difficult. A useful illustration of the principle however was in Re Dependable Upholstery Ltd (1936) 3 All ER 741, where the liquidator of a company sought a declaration against two directors that dividends had been paid wholly out of the capital of the company and not out of profits, and that there had been no profits of the company out of which dividends could be paid. The defendant directors sought further and better particulars of the facts relied upon in support of these allegations. Crossman J held that the liquidators were not required to give particulars of those facts. As the learned judge observed:‘In the present case the material fact on which the applicant, the official receiver, relies, is the alleged fact that each of the two dividends was in fact paid wholly out of the capital of the company. But it is suggested by Mr Morton on behalf of the respondents, the directors, that you have to go behind that allegation and find out the allegations or facts upon which that statement is based. It seems to me if one begins there, I do not know where one would end in the particulars which would have to ordered; because the fact that each of the dividends was paid wholly out of the capital of the company is the fact on which each party relies in the claim or defence. The facts which lead up to that are, in my view, really the evidence of the fact that the dividends were in fact paid wholly out of the capital of the company.’ (at 745) The applicant claims that a number of the requests of the respondents for further particulars are in the nature of seeking evidence rather than material facts.FURTHER AND BETTER PARTICULARS IN DISPUTE Prior to the hearing of this matter on 13 February 2006 the parties had resolved a number of issues in relation to the respondent’s request for further and better particulars. Outstanding matters requiring determination by this court are requests for further and better particulars concerning the following paragraphs of the applicant’s statement of claim:(a)paragraph 7(b)paragraph 10(c)paragraph 11(d)paragraph 12(e)paragraph 13(f)paragraph 14(g)paragraph 18(h)paragraph 24(i)paragraph 25(j)paragraph 29Paragraph 7 of the Statement of Claim

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J