Lucas Industries Ltd v Chloride Batteries Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

*

JUDGMENT No. ........ .......,..

-7

/

78

I "

I N T'HE

FEDCFSL

COljliT

O F A U S T I V L I A

)

)

V.G, No. 111 of 1977

-

VICTORIA

REGISTRY

--

l

)

GENERFjL

D I V I S I O N

)

QUESTTO>I

RESERVED

BY TIIE SUPRE!4E

COURT OF VICTORIA-

BETWEEN :

LUCAS INDLJSTRIES

LIMITED

Plaintiff

::

m:

ii

CHLOIIIDE

BATTERIES

AUSTRALIA

LI>lITEi?

---

Defendant

O R D E R

JUDGES MAKING ORDER: Bowen C . J . ,

Smithers and Nirnqlo JJ.

DATE O F ORDER:

3rd March,

1978

WHERE MADE:

Sydney

THE

COUriT

ORDERS

THAT:

1.

The yuestlon reserved for the consideratlon

of

this Court by Crockett J. by his ordcr of 17 th November 1977

be answered : N o

2.

The applicant pay to the respondent Its costs

of

the application In thls Court and

3.n the Supreme Court

of Vlctorla.

CATCIIWORDS

Prac t ice . ’and Procedure

-

Act ion

for

in f r ingemen t

of

p a t e n t a n d c o u n t e r - c l a i m f o r r e v o c a t i o n

-

Order

for

examinat ion of

w i t n e s s overseas

-

Relevance

of

ev idence

-

Obviousness of

invent ion.

P a t e n t s A c t 1952 s . 1 0 0 (1)

Kules of t h e Supreme

Court

of

Vic to r i a

0

.37

r . 5 .

LUCAS IFDUSTRIES LIXITED v. CHLORIDE EITTERIES AUSTR4LIA __-

L I Y I T E D

V . G .

111 of

1 9 7 7

Coram:

Bowen

C. J. , Smithers

and Nimmo JJ.

3rd

March,

1978.

Sydney.

I N THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

VICTORIA REGISTRY

V.G. No.111 of

1977

1 - ..

GENERAL

DIVISION

1

QUESTION RESERVED BY THE SUPREME

COURT OF

VICTORIA

BETWEEN :

LUCAS INDUSTRIES LIMITED

P l a i n t i f f

AND :

CHLORIDE BATTERIES AUSTRALIA LIMITED

Defendant

l

CORAM:

Bowen

C . J . ,

Smithers

and Nimmo JJ.

&.A,

+h(&

F & E ~ E - ~ , 1 9 7 8.

J U D G M E N T

BOWEN

C. J:

:

The q u e s t i o n

b e f o r e

t h e

C o u r t

i s whether

a

le t ter

of r e q u e s t i n London

s h o u l d i s s u e

for

the

examina t ion

of

one

Sven

Uno

Fa l l ;

i n t h e U n i t e d

Kingdom

o r

s u c h o t h e r p l a c e i n t h e U n l t e d

Kingdom as may be

t hough t

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lucas Industries Ltd v Chloride Batteries Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1978] FCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lucas Industries Limited, a plaintiff, filed an action against Chloride Batteries Australia Limited, a defendant, in the Supreme Court of Victoria for the infringement of Australian Letters Patent No. 407,778. The defendant filed a defence denying infringement and also alleging invalidity of the patent for reasons appearing in particulars of objections delivered with the defence. The defendant also counterclaimed for revocation of the patent on the grounds alleged in the particulars of objections. The court was required to decide whether a letter of request should issue for the examination of Sven Uno Falk in the United Kingdom or whether the Court should order a special examination of the said Sven Uno Falk. The court had to consider the relevance and admissibility of Mr. Falk's evidence, which was claimed to relate to the obviousness or lack of inventive step. The court had to determine if the applicant had shown to the Court's satisfaction that Mr. Falk could give evidence that was material. The court considered the evidence of Mr. Falk given in the patent suit in London and the affidavits filed by the parties. The court concluded that the applicant had failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that Mr. Falk would be able to give relevant and admissible evidence on the issue of obviousness. The court ordered that the question reserved for the consideration of this Court by Crockett J. by his order of 17th November 1977 be answered: No. The applicant pay to the respondent its costs of the application in this Court and in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Lucas Industries Limited v Chloride Batteries Australia Limited, the plaintiff, Lucas Industries Limited, filed an action for infringement of Australian Letters Patent No. 407,778 against the defendant, Chloride Batteries Australia Limited. The patent in question was for electric storage batteries, specifically a method of manufacturing improved electric storage batteries. The defendant denied infringement and alleged invalidity of the patent. The defendant also counterclaimed for revocation of the patent. The case involved extensive affidavits and evidence from both parties regarding the materiality and relevance of evidence from a proposed overseas witness, Sven Uno Falk, and the issue of obviousness of the invention.

The case originated in the High Court of Australia, where the writ of summons was issued on 1st May 1975. The matter was subsequently remitted to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The plaintiff filed a statement of claim with particulars of infringement on 4th June 1975, and the defendant filed a defence and counterclaim with particulars of objections on 11th July 1975. The case saw multiple amendments to the particulars of objections and the filing of various affidavits. On 5th October 1977, the matter was ordered to be remitted to the Supreme Court of Victoria. In early November 1977, the applicant/defendant applied to the Supreme Court of Victoria for an order that a letter of request issue for the examination of Sven Uno Falk in the United Kingdom, or alternatively, an order for a special examination of the witness. The application was not decided by the Supreme Court and was reserved for the consideration of the Federal Court of Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a letter of request should issue for the examination of Sven Uno Falk in the United Kingdom or whether an order should be made for a special examination of the witness.
2. Whether the applicant has shown to the Court's satisfaction that Sven Uno Falk can give relevant and admissible evidence on the issue of obviousness or lack of inventive step.

Held
1. The Court answered the reserved question in the negative, meaning that a letter of request should not issue for the examination of Sven Uno Falk in the United Kingdom.
2. The applicant did not demonstrate to the Court's satisfaction that Sven Uno Falk can give relevant and admissible evidence on the issue of obviousness or lack of inventive step.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether a letter of request should issue for the examination of Sven Uno Falk in the United Kingdom or whether an order should be made for a special examination of the witness. The court found that Sven Uno Falk, a Swedish citizen, could not be compelled to attend the trial in Australia. The court also considered whether the applicant had shown to the Court's satisfaction that Mr. Falk can give evidence which is material. The court found that the applicant failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that Mr. Falk's evidence would be relevant and admissible.

In reaching its decision, the court examined the nature of Mr. Falk's evidence in relation to the issue of obviousness or lack of inventive step. The court noted that Mr. Falk's knowledge included information from American and German journals which were not available in Australia. This additional knowledge possessed by Mr. Falk would be a fatal objection to the application. The court concluded that the applicant had failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that Mr. Falk would be able to give relevant and admissible evidence on the issue of obviousness.