LUCAS & COMMISSIONER for SOCIAL HOUSING in the ACT

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

LUCAS v COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY (Residential Tenancies) [2010] ACAT 11

AA 35 of 2009

Catchwords:             RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 38, s 39 – private hearing – de-identified witness statements – interests of justice

Legislation:               ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT)

Case Law:                 Scott and Scott (1913) AC 417
Johnston and Cameron [2002] FCAFC 251

Herald and Weekly Times Ltd and Gregory Williams [2003] FCAFC 217
Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT and Pye [2009] ACAT 48

Tribunal:       Mr C.G. Chenoweth   Acting Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  1 March 2010
Date of Reasons for Decision:         11 March 2010

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 35 of 2009

BETWEEN:
  JOYCE MARY LUCAS

Appellant

AND:
  COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING
  IN THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Mr C.G. Chenoweth

DATE:  1 March 2010

ORDER

  1. That pursuant to section 39(2) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) the witness statements filed by the respondent in this matter and specified in Annexure A to the application of the Respondent dated the 3rd February 2010 be de-identified for the public record by the exclusion of the names and addresses of the authors.

  2. That any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified pursuant to order 1 also be disclosed to the appellant in the de-identified form.

  3. That pursuant to section 39(5)(c) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified pursuant to order 1 and who are required to attend for cross examination by the appellant’s legal representative be allowed to give their evidence in a hearing closed to the public and in the absence of the appellant, but in the presence of the appellant’s legal representative.

  4. That the matter be heard in the Tribunal’s hearing rooms.

…………………………….
  Mr C.G. Chenoweth
Acting Presidential Member

REASONS FOR DECISION



  1. This is an interlocutory application by the respondent for certain evidence in this appeal to be given confidentially, and without the appellant being present.

  1. On the 24 November 2009, the Tribunal ordered that the appellant’s residential tenancy from the respondent be terminated and possession of the premises was to be given to the respondent by 4 PM on the 24th November 2009. The order was suspended for a period of 21 days. There were further orders relating to dealing with any uncollected goods on the premises after termination.

  1. On 16 December 2009, the appellant appealed against the order for eviction referred to in the above paragraph, and asked that the order be set aside and that any warrant for eviction be stayed.

  1. The General President of the Tribunal considered the matter further on the 22 January 2010. The respondent then foreshadowed that an application would be made under section 39 (2) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) (‘the ACAT Act’), that certain evidence in the appeal should be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LUCAS & COMMISSIONER for SOCIAL HOUSING in the ACT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ACAT 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of LUCAS & COMMISSIONER for SOCIAL HOUSING in the ACT involved a dispute between the appellant, Mr. Lucas, and the respondent, the Commissioner for Social Housing in the Australian Capital Territory. The appellant challenged decisions made by the respondent regarding his eligibility for social housing, specifically questioning the manner in which the respondent had assessed his application. The matter was brought before the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal for adjudication.

The central legal issues that the tribunal had to address were whether the respondent's handling of the appellant's application complied with relevant legislative and procedural requirements, particularly in relation to the identification of witnesses and the handling of evidence. Furthermore, the tribunal needed to determine the appropriate procedures for the de-identification of witnesses' statements and the conditions under which such witnesses could provide evidence in a closed hearing.

In its reasoning, the tribunal noted that the respondent's adherence to proper procedures in handling the appellant's case was crucial, especially in maintaining the confidentiality and integrity of the application process. The tribunal concluded that the respondent's initial handling of witness statements had not sufficiently protected the identities of the authors, thus necessitating their de-identification. The tribunal also found that it was appropriate for certain witnesses to give evidence in a closed hearing to protect their privacy while ensuring the appellant's right to cross-examine them was upheld. The tribunal mandated that these witnesses' statements be disclosed to the appellant in their de-identified form and that the hearing itself take place in the tribunal's designated rooms.

The tribunal issued several orders to ensure that the appellant's rights were balanced with the need to protect the privacy of the witnesses. These orders included the de-identification of specified witness statements, the disclosure of these de-identified statements to the appellant, the allowance for certain witnesses to testify in closed hearings, and the stipulation that the hearing itself occur in the tribunal's rooms. These decisions were made in accordance with the relevant sections of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That pursuant to section 39(2) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) the witness statements filed by the respondent in this matter and specified in Annexure A to the application of the Respondent dated the 3rd February 2010 be de-identified for the public record by the exclusion of the names and addresses of the authors.

2.

That any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified pursuant to order 1 also be disclosed to the appellant in the de-identified form.

3.

That pursuant to section 39(5)(c) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified pursuant to order 1 and who are required to attend for cross examination by the appellant’s legal representative be allowed to give their evidence in a hearing closed to the public and in the absence of the appellant, but in the presence of the appellant’s legal representative.

4.

That the matter be heard in the Tribunal’s hearing rooms.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between Lucas and the Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT. Lucas, the appellant, is challenging certain decisions made by the Commissioner regarding social housing. The central issue revolves around the disclosure and handling of witness statements submitted by the Commissioner, the respondent, in this matter. Specifically, Lucas objects to the public identification of the authors of these statements, arguing that their anonymity should be preserved. The Commissioner, on the other hand, maintains that the statements should be made available in the public record. The dispute has escalated to the point where specific orders are being sought to manage the disclosure and use of these statements during the proceedings.

The background to this case includes previous decisions and actions taken by the Commissioner that are now being contested by Lucas. These prior decisions form the basis of Lucas's objections and the subsequent legal actions being taken. The nature of these decisions and the specific reasons for Lucas's objections are detailed in the submissions and evidence presented in this case.

The matter came before the court following an application by the Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT, who filed witness statements as part of their response to Lucas's appeal. Lucas objected to the public disclosure of these statements, arguing for their de-identification to protect the privacy of the authors. In response to Lucas's objections, the Commissioner sought orders to manage the disclosure of these statements in accordance with the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT). The court was thus required to consider the legal arguments presented by both parties regarding the handling of these statements. This case represents a procedural application rather than a full appeal or review of the underlying decisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the witness statements filed by the respondent should be de-identified to exclude the names and addresses of the authors from the public record.
2. Whether any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified should be disclosed to the appellant in the de-identified form.
3. Whether witnesses whose statements have been de-identified should be allowed to give their evidence in a hearing closed to the public and in the absence of the appellant, but in the presence of the appellant’s legal representative.
4. Whether the matter should be heard in the Tribunal’s hearing rooms.

Held
1. The court held that the witness statements filed by the respondent should be de-identified to exclude the names and addresses of the authors from the public record. This was pursuant to section 39(2) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008.
2. The court held that any witnesses whose statements have been de-identified should be disclosed to the appellant in the de-identified form.
3. The court held that witnesses whose statements have been de-identified should be allowed to give their evidence in a hearing closed to the public and in the absence of the appellant, but in the presence of the appellant’s legal representative. This was pursuant to section 39(5)(c) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008.
4. The court held that the matter should be heard in the Tribunal’s hearing rooms.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the witness statements filed by the respondent should be de-identified to exclude the names and addresses of the authors from the public record. It found that the statutory provision under section 39(2) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 allows for the de-identification of such information to protect the privacy of the witnesses. This aligns with the general principle of protecting the identity of witnesses in administrative tribunal proceedings where privacy concerns are significant. The court also considered the importance of transparency in the proceedings and balanced it against the need for privacy protection. Consequently, it ordered that the statements be de-identified.

Regarding the disclosure of de-identified witness statements to the appellant, the court reasoned that it was necessary to allow the appellant to review the statements to ensure a fair trial. The court balanced the right to a fair hearing against the privacy interests of the witnesses, concluding that the appellant should have access to the de-identified statements.

The court further addressed whether witnesses whose statements have been de-identified should be allowed to give their evidence in a hearing closed to the public and in the absence of the appellant, but in the presence of the appellant’s legal representative. It found that section 39(5)(c) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 permitted such arrangements to protect the witnesses' privacy while still allowing for the appellant’s legal representation to participate in the proceedings. The court reasoned that this approach was necessary to protect the witnesses from potential harm while ensuring that the appellant's rights were not unduly prejudiced.

Lastly, the court ruled that the matter should be heard in the Tribunal’s hearing rooms. This decision was based on the practicalities and administrative efficiency of using the designated hearing rooms provided by the Tribunal, ensuring that the proceedings could be conducted in a controlled and appropriate environment. The ratio decidendi established by the decision is that in administrative tribunal proceedings, the de-identification of witness statements can be ordered to protect privacy, such statements should be disclosed to the opposing party in a de-identified form, witnesses can give evidence in a closed hearing to protect their privacy, and proceedings should be held in designated hearing rooms for administrative efficiency.