Lubica Jakovceska v Australian Capital Territory

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE  )
  )  No SC 414  of 2000
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

BETWEEN:LUBICA JAKOVCESKA          

Plaintiff

AND:AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          

Defendant

AND:CITY GROUP PTY LIMITED

ACN:008 599 899

Third Party

  1. C O R R I G E N D U M

Coram:            Master

Date:               19 August 2003

Place:              Canberra

The Reasons for Judgment of the Master delivered on 19 August 2003  [2003] ACTSC 67 are amended as follows:

Page 4 – paragraph 6 – delete “Counsel for the plaintiff” and substitute “Counsel for the defendant”.

Associate to the Master

Dated:  20 August 2003

LUBICA JAKOVCESKA v AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY;
CITY GROUP PTY LIMITED
[2003] ACTSC 67 (19 August 2003)

CATCHWORDS

NEGLIGENCE – personal injury – unsafe system of work – liability to employee of independent contractor – no issue of principle.
DAMAGES – personal injury – cervical spine – previously asymptomatic degeneration – adjustment disorder – no issue of principle.

Rockdale Beef Pty. Ltd. V Carey [2003] NSWCA 132
Fox v Wood [1981] 148 CLR 438

No SC 414 of 2000

Coram:     Master Harper
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date:     19 August 2003

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE  )
  )  No SC 414  of 2000
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

BETWEEN:LUBICA JAKOVCESKA          

Plaintiff

AND:AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          

Defendant

AND:CITY GROUP PTY LIMITED

ACN:008 599 899

Third Party

ORDER

Coram:  Master Harper
Date:  19 August 2003
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Judgment be entered for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $270,300.00.

  1. The plaintiff claims damages for personal injury occasioned by an incident at her place of work on 23 November 1998.  The plaintiff was employed by the third party, City Group Pty Limited, as a cleaner.  One of her responsibilities was to empty rubbish bins on the fourth floor of Building 10 at the Canberra Hospital.  The defendant, originally sued as the Australian Capital Territory Health and Community Care Service and subsequently amended to the Australian Capital Territory, was the occupier of the building.  The third party was responsible for cleaning and rubbish removal from the building, pursuant to an agreement with the defendant.  Located on the fourth floor of the building was a laboratory where testing was carried out on the quality of samples of water from Canberra lakes and rivers.  The water was brought to the laboratory in two-litre plastic bottles.

  1. The plaintiff’s usual practice was to pull the plastic liner upwards and out of each bin, so that the contents of the bins could be emptied onto a trolley.  There were about ten or fifteen bins to be emptied.  They were conventional polyvinyl domestic garbage bins.  Their contents were normally very light.  On the occasion in question, the plaintiff pulled the plastic liner from a bin and found that it was unusually heavy.  It turned out that the bin had been filled with bottles which had not been emptied after testing, and that the bottles could not be seen because they were hidden below white…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lubica Jakovceska v Australian Capital Territory and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] ACTSC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lubica Jakovceska v Australian Capital Territory involves a personal injury claim by the plaintiff, Lubica Jakovceska, against the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) and a third party, City Group Pty Limited. Jakovceska, a cleaner employed by City Group Pty Limited, was injured while emptying a rubbish bin at the Canberra Hospital. The incident occurred when she pulled the liner from a bin and found it unusually heavy, causing her immediate pain to her left elbow and neck. The ACT, as the occupier of the building, was responsible for the maintenance of a safe environment, including ensuring the safety of rubbish bins. City Group Pty Limited was responsible for cleaning and rubbish removal from the building.

The key legal issues in the case were whether the defendant breached its duty of care, and if so, whether the plaintiff was contributory negligent. The Court found that the defendant breached its duty of care by allowing full water bottles to be placed in the rubbish bin, which constituted an unsafe system of work. The Court also found that the plaintiff was not contributory negligent as she had no reason to suspect that the contents of the bin were unusually heavy.

Regarding damages, the Court accepted that the plaintiff suffered a genuine injury to her neck and elbow, which caused her considerable pain over an extended period of time. The neck injury, superimposed upon a cervical spine with asymptomatic degeneration, caused the plaintiff considerable pain and resulted in an adjustment disorder with depressed mood. The Court awarded general damages for pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life in the sum of $40,000.00, interest on the past component of $3,500.00, treatment and other expenses up to the date of trial of $4,090.06, and $4,300.00 to allow for the period between hearing and judgment. The Court also awarded damages for loss of earning capacity, Fox v Wood component, gratuitous services, and loss of superannuation benefits, resulting in a total award of $270,300.00.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lubica Jakovceska was employed by City Group Pty Limited as a cleaner, responsible for emptying rubbish bins on the fourth floor of Building 10 at the Canberra Hospital. The Australian Capital Territory was the occupier of the building. On 23 November 1998, while emptying a bin, Jakovceska pulled the plastic liner and found it unusually heavy. The bin was filled with two-litre plastic bottles containing water, hidden beneath white packing material, likely polystyrene foam. This caused her immediate pain in her left elbow and neck. Despite her supervisor suggesting it was a muscular injury, Jakovceska continued to work for four more days, during which she developed additional back pain and breathing difficulties. She sought medical attention from Dr. Pitcher, who diagnosed minor muscle and fascia tearing and derangement of cervical and upper thoracic joints. Further examinations revealed marked degenerative narrowing of the C5-6 disc space in her cervical spine.

Jakovceska's condition did not improve with physiotherapy or medication, and her symptoms persisted. Various medical experts assessed her condition, with opinions differing on the extent of her injuries and the impact of the underlying cervical spine degeneration. Some experts believed her condition was exacerbated by the incident, while others attributed her ongoing symptoms primarily to the pre-existing degeneration. Surveillance footage showed Jakovceska performing various physical activities at home, which appeared inconsistent with her reported limitations in court.

The court found that Jakovceska suffered genuine injuries, which caused her considerable pain and restricted her movement. Although her physical symptoms had improved by November 2002, she continued to experience some level of disability. The court awarded damages considering her pain, loss of enjoyment of life, medical expenses, and loss of earning capacity, among other factors.

The matter of Lubica Jakovceska v Australian Capital Territory came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as a first-instance hearing in relation to a personal injury claim. The plaintiff, Lubica Jakovceska, sought damages for injuries she sustained while emptying a rubbish bin at her workplace, the Canberra Hospital, on 23 November 1998. Jakovceska, employed by City Group Pty Limited as a cleaner, experienced an incident where she pulled out a bin that was unusually heavy due to it being filled with water bottles hidden beneath packing material. This resulted in immediate pain to her left elbow and neck, followed by further pain in her middle back and breathing difficulties over the subsequent days. The defendant, the Australian Capital Territory, was the occupier of the building where the incident occurred. City Group Pty Limited, the third party, was responsible for the cleaning and rubbish removal from the building. The case proceeded directly to trial before the Master, with the defendant conceding liability for the breach of duty of care owed to the plaintiff. The third party made no submissions in relation to the defendant’s liability to the plaintiff or its own potential liability to the defendant. Consequently, the court did not need to adjudicate on the issues between the defendant and the third party. The primary focus of the hearing was on the assessment of damages and the extent of the plaintiff's contributory negligence, if any.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the defendant breach the duty of care owed to the plaintiff by leaving full water bottles in a rubbish bin?

2. Was the plaintiff contributory negligent in not checking the contents of the bin before emptying it?

3. Is the plaintiff’s injury causally related to the incident at work on 23 November 1998?

4. What is the extent and nature of the plaintiff’s injuries and disabilities?

5. What is the appropriate compensation for the plaintiff’s general damages, past and future loss of earning capacity, out-of-pocket expenses, loss of superannuation benefits, and the value of gratuitous services?

6. Should the plaintiff receive credit for the $45,000 received in May 2000, and if so, how much?

7. What is the total amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff after taking into account the credit for the amount received in May 2000?

Held
1. Did the defendant breach the duty of care owed to the plaintiff by leaving full water bottles in a rubbish bin? The court concluded that the defendant did breach the duty of care owed to the plaintiff, and this was admitted by counsel for the defendant.

2. Was the plaintiff contributory negligent in not checking the contents of the bin before emptying it? The court concluded that the plaintiff was not contributory negligent in this matter.

3. Is the plaintiff’s injury causally related to the incident at work on 23 November 1998? The court concluded that the plaintiff's injury was causally related to the incident at work on 23 November 1998.

4. What is the extent and nature of the plaintiff’s injuries and disabilities? The court concluded that the plaintiff suffered a genuine injury to her neck and elbow, which caused considerable pain over an extended period of time, and resulted in a neck injury superimposed upon a cervical spine with asymptomatic degeneration. The plaintiff also experienced an adjustment disorder with depressed mood.

5. What is the appropriate compensation for the plaintiff’s general damages, past and future loss of earning capacity, out-of-pocket expenses, loss of superannuation benefits, and the value of gratuitous services? The court concluded that the appropriate compensation was $283,900.00.

6. Should the plaintiff receive credit for the $45,000 received in May 2000, and if so, how much? The court concluded that the plaintiff should receive credit for $13,600.00 by way of notional interest on the $45,000 received in May 2000.

7. What is the total amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff after taking into account the credit for the amount received in May 2000? The court concluded that the total amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff is $270,300.00.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the defendant breached the duty of care owed to the plaintiff by leaving full water bottles in a rubbish bin. The court accepted the concession by the defendant's counsel that this amounted to a breach of the duty of care. The court found that the plaintiff was not contributory negligent in not checking the contents of the bin before emptying it. The court found that it was not reasonable to expect the plaintiff to check the contents of the bin, as there was no reason to suspect that the contents were unusually heavy.

The court found that the plaintiff's injury was causally related to the incident at work on 23 November 1998. The court accepted the evidence of the plaintiff and medical experts that the plaintiff suffered an aggravation of an underlying cervical spondylosis at the time of her injury.

The court found that the plaintiff's injuries and disabilities were a genuine neck problem causing chronic pain, which was the cause of an adjustment disorder with depressed mood. The court found that the plaintiff had a continuing level of disability, which was relatively mild, and that this would cause a relatively mild continuing comparable level of psychological symptomatology.

The court found that the appropriate compensation for the plaintiff's general damages, past and future loss of earning capacity, out-of-pocket expenses, loss of superannuation benefits, and the value of gratuitous services was $283,900.00. The court found that the plaintiff should receive credit for the $45,000 received in May 2000, and that the appropriate credit was $13,600.00. The court found that the total amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff after taking into account the credit for the amount received in May 2000 was $270,300.00.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an occupier owes a duty of care to a cleaner working on their premises to ensure that their system of work is safe and does not expose the cleaner to unnecessary risks. The court found that leaving full water bottles in a rubbish bin in the circumstances amounted to a breach of the duty of care owed to the plaintiff. The court also found that it was not reasonable to expect the plaintiff to check the contents of the bin before emptying it, as there was no reason to suspect that the contents were unusually heavy.