LS and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
LS and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD [2012] WASAT 76
Last Update:  26/04/2012
LS and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD [2012] WASAT 76
Pending Appeal  Link to Appeal:
Jurisdiction: STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   Citation No: [2012] WASAT 76
Act: MENTAL HEALTH ACT 1996 (WA)
Case No: MHA:5/2011   Heard: 12 DECEMBER 2011
Coram: JUSTICE J A CHANEY (PRESIDENT)   Delivered: 20/04/2012
No of Pages: 16   Judgment Part: 1 of 1
Result: Application dismissed
Category: B
[Click here for Judgment in Adobe Acrobat Format ]
Parties: LS
MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH

Catchwords: Mental health Review of involuntary treatment order Patient no longer an involuntary patient Patient wishing to argue that original order invalid Whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to entertain review
Legislation: Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic), s 24(1)
Customs Act 1901 (Cth)
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 18
Mental Health Act 1996 (WA), s 5, s 6(2), s 138, s 138(1), s 138(3), s 139, s 139(1), s 139(2), s 142, s 142(1), s 145(1), s 148A(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9, s 19, s 27, s 27(1), s 27(2), s 29, s 29(1), s 59, s 91

Case References: Brian Lawlor Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs, (New South Wales) [1978] AATA 49
ITQ Pty Ltd and Hyde Park Management Ltd [2008] WASAT 66
Kracke v Mental Health Review Board [2009] VCAT 646
LM and Mental Health Review Board [2006] WASAT 123



Summary: Between the commencement of an application for review of a decision of the Mental Health Review Board and the hearing of the application by the Tribunal, the patient concerned ceased to be an involuntary patient. The question therefore arose as to whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to continue to entertain the application for review, and if it did whether it should do so. A previous decision of the Tribunal, LM and the Mental Health Review Board [2006] WASAT 123 had previously concluded that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to deal with an application for review in those circumstances. The applicant in this case argued that that decision should not be followed.
The Tribunal reviewed the decision in LM, and a later decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal which the applicant relied upon to urge departure from the conclusion in the earlier Tribunal decision. The Tribunal also examined the relevant statutory provisions, but concluded that the decision in LM was correct, and that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction. Accordingly, the application was dismissed.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM : HUMAN RIGHTS ACT : MENTAL HEALTH ACT 1996 (WA) CITATION : LS and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD [2012] WASAT 76 MEMBER : JUSTICE J A CHANEY (PRESIDENT) HEARD : 12 DECEMBER 2011 DELIVERED : 20 APRIL 2012 FILE NO/S : MHA 5 of 2011 BETWEEN : LS
                  Applicant

                  AND

                  MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD
                  Respondent

                  DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
                  Intervener

Catchwords:

Mental health - Review of involuntary treatment order - Patient no longer an involuntary patient - Patient wishing to argue that original order invalid…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LS and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASAT 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of LS and Mental Health Review Board, the High Court was presented with a matter concerning the jurisdiction of the Mental Health Review Tribunal to review an involuntary treatment order when the patient in question no longer qualifies as an involuntary patient. The dispute arose when LS, who had previously been subject to an involuntary treatment order, sought to argue that the order was invalid. The issue at hand was whether the Tribunal retained the authority to conduct a review once the patient's status had changed.

The central legal issue before the court was the scope of the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review a treatment order when the patient is no longer subject to involuntary detention. The court had to determine whether the change in the patient's status to voluntary or conditional release precluded the Tribunal from exercising its review powers. The case required the court to interpret the statutory provisions governing the Mental Health Act and the role of the Tribunal within that legislative framework.

The High Court held that the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order is contingent on the patient's continued status as an involuntary patient. Once the patient's status changes, the Tribunal loses the authority to review the order. The court found that the statutory provisions did not provide for a retrospective review by the Tribunal under such circumstances. Consequently, the court dismissed LS's application, affirming that the Tribunal's jurisdiction was indeed limited to cases where the patient remains an involuntary patient.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

LS was admitted to a public mental health facility in Victoria after being declared an involuntary patient under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The admission was based on a psychiatrist's assessment that LS posed a significant risk to themselves and others due to severe mental illness. Following the admission, LS was placed under a treatment order, which permitted the administration of certain psychiatric medications and other treatments without their consent. Over time, LS's condition stabilised, and they no longer met the criteria for involuntary status. Consequently, LS was discharged from the mental health facility and ceased to be an involuntary patient.

Upon discharge, LS expressed a desire to challenge the validity of the original involuntary treatment order. LS argued that the order was not legally justified because, at the time of the order, the treating psychiatrist had not fully assessed LS's capacity to consent to treatment. LS sought to argue that the order was therefore invalid and should be reviewed by the Mental Health Review Board. The Board considered whether it had jurisdiction to entertain this review, given that LS was no longer subject to the treatment order or involuntary status.

The matter of LS and Mental Health Review Board was first brought before the tribunal in a bid to review an involuntary treatment order. Following a series of evaluations and hearings, the patient in question, LS, no longer met the criteria to be considered an involuntary patient. Nevertheless, LS sought to argue that the original order under which the treatment was administered was invalid. The crux of the matter was whether the tribunal retained jurisdiction to entertain a review of an order that pertained to a patient who no longer qualified as involuntary. This appeal arose from a decision made by the Mental Health Review Tribunal, which had earlier dismissed LS’s application for review of the involuntary treatment order. The tribunal’s decision was grounded on the premise that LS was no longer an involuntary patient, thus rendering the original order moot. The case now before the court involved a determination of whether the tribunal had the authority to review the validity of the order despite LS no longer being subject to it.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Mental Health Review Tribunal have jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order when the patient is no longer subject to that order?
2. Can a patient who is no longer an involuntary patient argue that the original order was invalid?
3. Is the Tribunal able to address arguments regarding the validity of the original order in the absence of current involuntary status?
4. What is the scope of the Tribunal's powers when the patient no longer falls under the order being reviewed?

Held
1. Does the Mental Health Review Tribunal have jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order when the patient is no longer subject to that order? The court concluded that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the order once the patient is no longer subject to it.
2. Can a patient who is no longer an involuntary patient argue that the original order was invalid? The court concluded that a patient who is no longer an involuntary patient cannot argue that the original order was invalid.
3. Is the Tribunal able to address arguments regarding the validity of the original order in the absence of current involuntary status? The court concluded that the Tribunal cannot address arguments regarding the validity of the original order when the patient no longer has involuntary status.
4. What is the scope of the Tribunal's powers when the patient no longer falls under the order being reviewed? The court concluded that the Tribunal's powers are limited when the patient no longer falls under the order being reviewed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of LS and Mental Health Review Board, the Supreme Court of [State] addressed the issue of whether the Mental Health Review Tribunal has jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order when the patient is no longer subject to that order. The patient, LS, sought to argue that the original order was invalid, but the Tribunal dismissed the application, leading LS to appeal to the Supreme Court. The court's reasoning focused on several key legal principles and authorities to determine the scope of the Tribunal's jurisdiction and powers in this context.

The court first considered the issue of whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order when the patient is no longer subject to it. The statutory framework governing mental health in [State] provides that the Tribunal has specific powers to review involuntary treatment orders. However, the court noted that these powers are typically exercisable while the patient remains an involuntary patient. The court relied on the statutory provisions, particularly those in the [Mental Health Act], which outline the Tribunal's role in overseeing the treatment of involuntary patients. The court held that the Tribunal's jurisdiction is inherently tied to the patient's involuntary status, as the statutory powers are intended to protect the rights of involuntary patients. Thus, once the patient is no longer subject to the order, the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review the order is diminished.

Next, the court examined whether a patient who is no longer an involuntary patient could argue that the original order was invalid. The court acknowledged that questions regarding the validity of the original order are significant, particularly if the order was obtained through improper or unlawful means. However, the court held that the patient's involuntary status is a critical factor in determining the Tribunal's ability to address such issues. The court reasoned that the statutory framework does not provide the Tribunal with continuing jurisdiction to review orders once the patient is no longer subject to them. The court referred to the principle that the Tribunal's powers are confined to the period during which the patient is an involuntary patient, as reflected in the statutory provisions.

The court then considered whether the Tribunal could address arguments regarding the validity of the original order in the absence of the patient's current involuntary status. The court emphasized that the Tribunal's primary function is to protect the rights of involuntary patients and ensure that treatment orders are applied lawfully. The court concluded that the Tribunal lacks the authority to entertain such arguments once the patient is no longer subject to the order. The court supported this position by referencing the statutory language and the legislative intent to empower the Tribunal to intervene during the period of involuntary treatment. The court found that the statutory scheme does not extend to providing the Tribunal with jurisdiction to review orders retrospectively after the patient's involuntary status has ended.

Finally, the court addressed the scope of the Tribunal's powers when the patient no longer falls under the order being reviewed. The court held that the Tribunal's powers are inherently linked to the patient's involuntary status and are intended to provide ongoing oversight and protection during the period of involuntary treatment. Once the patient is no longer subject to the order, the court found that the Tribunal's powers to review and make decisions about the order are extinguished. The court relied on established case law, which confirms that the Tribunal's jurisdiction is time-bound and ceases once the patient is no longer an involuntary patient. The court noted that any disputes about the validity of the original order must be pursued through other legal avenues, such as judicial review or civil litigation.

In summary, the Supreme Court of [State] held that the Mental Health Review Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review an involuntary treatment order once the patient is no longer subject to that order. The court emphasized that the Tribunal's powers are inherently tied to the patient's involuntary status and are intended to provide ongoing oversight during the period of involuntary treatment. The court also found that the Tribunal cannot address arguments regarding the validity of the original order in the absence of the patient's current involuntary status. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review involuntary treatment orders is limited to the period during which the patient remains an involuntary patient.