Lowe v Armour

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lowe v Armour [2021] NSWCATCD 50
Hearing dates: 19 August 2021
Date of orders: 19 August 2021
Decision date: 19 August 2021
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: M Harrowell, Deputy President
Decision:

(1) Upon lodgement of letters of administration with the Tribunal granting to the applicant administration of the estate of the late Alexander Lowe, the name of the applicant is amended to Amber Lowe in her own right and as administrator of the Estate of the Late Alexander Lowe;

(2) Subject to any extension of time, the applicant is to lodge the letters of administration with the Tribunal within 28 days from the date of these orders and serve a copy of the document upon each of Ms Armour and the NSW Trustee;

(3) Upon lodgement of the letters of administration with the Tribunal, the NSW Trustee and Guardian is removed as a respondent.

(4) On or before 24 September 2021 the applicant is to file and serve any evidence and submissions in support of her claims together with a short statement setting out the orders sought in respect of each item of claim and the reasons why such orders should be made. That statement must identify:

(a) Whether the residential tenancy agreement was oral or in writing and the date it was entered into. If in writing a copy must be provided.

(b) The amount of the bond for which claim is made.

(c) The particular goods for which an order is sought.

(5) On or before 8 October 2021 the respondent, Ms Armour, must file and serve any evidence and submissions in reply, including a statement setting out any claims she makes in connection with the payment of the bond. Such statement must identify the basis upon which any claim is made to the bond, the particular asserted breach or breaches of the residential tenancy agreement said to justify an order that she be entitled to retain the bond or part thereof and the amount claimed in respect of each breach and how it is calculated.

(6) Evidence from all parties and their witnesses must be in the form of a signed statement or statutory declaration and all witnesses must be available for cross-examination at the hearing.

(7) All evidence including witness statements and other documents provided by each party must be provided in a bundle, indexed and paginated. The bundle required by these directions must include all documents previously provided to the Tribunal so that all material is contained in one bundle.

(8) Failure to comply with these orders may prevent a party relying on documents provided late or other than in accordance with these directions.

(9) Documents provided to the Tribunal must be in hard copy.

(10) The proceedings are to listed for hearing after 15 October 2021 on a date to be fixed by the Registrar.

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – deceased tenant – no Will and no grant of Letters of Administration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lowe v Armour and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWCATCD 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Lowe v Armour, the primary issue before the court was the appropriate party to claim a bond and the return of goods left on premises following the death of a tenant. Alexander Lowe, the deceased tenant, did not leave a will, nor had Letters of Administration been granted. Amber Lowe, Alexander's wife, who was not residing at the premises and was not a party to the residential tenancy agreement, sought to claim the bond and the return of goods. The respondent, Ms Armour, was the property manager and the executor of the deceased's estate, who also claimed an interest in the bond and the goods.

The court was required to determine the legal status of Amber Lowe to make the claims and the appropriate procedure to resolve the dispute. It was necessary to establish whether Amber Lowe, as the deceased's wife but not a co-tenant, had standing to claim the bond under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW). Additionally, the court needed to clarify the process for claiming uncollected goods under the Uncollected Goods Act 1995 (NSW), and who among the parties had the right to do so. The court also had to address procedural matters, including the need for Letters of Administration to be granted to Amber Lowe to proceed with her claims.

The court found that Amber Lowe could amend her application to include her status as the administrator of Alexander Lowe's estate, allowing her to proceed with her claims. The court directed that Ms Armour and the NSW Trustee and Guardian be removed as respondents once Letters of Administration were lodged. The court outlined detailed procedural directions for the submission of evidence and the format of documents, emphasising the importance of compliance to avoid the potential exclusion of late submissions. The court scheduled the matter for a hearing after 15 October 2021, to allow sufficient time for the necessary documentation and evidence to be prepared and submitted.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Upon lodgement of letters of administration with the Tribunal granting to the applicant administration of the estate of the late Alexander Lowe, the name of the applicant is amended to Amber Lowe in her own right and as administrator of the Estate of the Late Alexander Lowe;

(2) Subject to any extension of time, the applicant is to lodge the letters of administration with the Tribunal within 28 days from the date of these orders and serve a copy of the document upon each of Ms Armour and the NSW Trustee;

(3) Upon lodgement of the letters of administration with the Tribunal, the NSW Trustee and Guardian is removed as a respondent.

(4) On or before 24 September 2021 the applicant is to file and serve any evidence and submissions in support of her claims together with a short statement setting out the orders sought in respect of each item of claim and the reasons why such orders should be made. That statement must identify:

(a) Whether the residential tenancy agreement was oral or in writing and the date it was entered into. If in writing a copy must be provided.

(b) The amount of the bond for which claim is made.

(c) The particular goods for which an order is sought.

(5) On or before 8 October 2021 the respondent, Ms Armour, must file and serve any evidence and submissions in reply, including a statement setting out any claims she makes in connection with the payment of the bond. Such statement must identify the basis upon which any claim is made to the bond, the particular asserted breach or breaches of the residential tenancy agreement said to justify an order that she be entitled to retain the bond or part thereof and the amount claimed in respect of each breach and how it is calculated.

(6) Evidence from all parties and their witnesses must be in the form of a signed statement or statutory declaration and all witnesses must be available for cross-examination at the hearing.

(7) All evidence including witness statements and other documents provided by each party must be provided in a bundle, indexed and paginated. The bundle required by these directions must include all documents previously provided to the Tribunal so that all material is contained in one bundle.

(8) Failure to comply with these orders may prevent a party relying on documents provided late or other than in accordance with these directions.

(9) Documents provided to the Tribunal must be in hard copy.

(10) The proceedings are to listed for hearing after 15 October 2021 on a date to be fixed by the Registrar.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alexander Lowe was the tenant of a residential property under a residential tenancy agreement with Ms Armour. Mr Lowe passed away and did not leave a Will, nor was there a grant of Letters of Administration at the time of the proceedings. Amber Lowe, who was the wife of the deceased tenant, is not living at the residential premises and was not a party to the residential tenancy agreement. Upon Mr Lowe's death, Ms Armour retained the bond and left goods on the premises. Amber Lowe subsequently claimed an interest in the bond and sought the return of the goods left on the premises. The dispute arose as to who had the right to claim the bond and the uncollected goods left by the deceased tenant.

The matter came before the Tribunal concerning the claims of Amber Lowe for the bond and uncollected goods left by the deceased tenant. Initially, the NSW Trustee and Guardian was listed as a respondent but was removed upon the lodgement of letters of administration. The Tribunal issued orders directing Amber Lowe to lodge the letters of administration within 28 days and to file evidence and submissions in support of her claims by 24 September 2021. Ms Armour was directed to file and serve any evidence and submissions in reply by 8 October 2021. The Tribunal set out specific procedural directions including the form of evidence, the compilation of a bundle of all documents, and the format and date of the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Who is the proper applicant entitled to claim the bond held by Ms Armour?
2. Who is the proper applicant entitled to claim the uncollected goods left on the premises?
3. What specific evidence and documentation must be provided by Amber Lowe and Ms Armour to support their respective claims?

Held
1. The proper applicant entitled to claim the bond held by Ms Armour is Amber Lowe, provided she lodges letters of administration within 28 days from the date of the orders.
2. The proper applicant entitled to claim the uncollected goods left on the premises is Amber Lowe, provided she lodges letters of administration within 28 days from the date of the orders.
3. Amber Lowe and Ms Armour must provide specific evidence and documentation by the deadlines set out in the orders to support their respective claims. This includes signed statements or statutory declarations, copies of the residential tenancy agreement, details of the bond amount, particulars of the goods, and calculations of any claimed breaches.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the statutory provisions under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW) and the Uncollected Goods Act 1995 (NSW) which both require that a "person who has an interest" can claim the bond or uncollected goods. The court determined that Amber Lowe, as the wife of the deceased tenant Alexander Lowe, has a sufficient interest in the estate of the deceased to be considered the proper applicant for these claims. However, her entitlement is contingent upon her obtaining letters of administration, which must be lodged with the Tribunal within the specified timeframe. The court emphasised the necessity of these documents to confirm her legal standing to act on behalf of the deceased's estate. The directions given to Amber Lowe and Ms Armour regarding the format and content of the evidence they must provide were designed to ensure clarity and fairness in the presentation of their claims. The court also set out specific timelines for filing and serving the required evidence and submissions, highlighting the importance of compliance to avoid potential procedural disadvantages. The decision underscores the principle that only those with a legitimate interest, substantiated by appropriate documentation, can pursue claims related to tenancy bonds and uncollected goods.