Lowe and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1599 (9 June 2023)
Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION
File Number(s): 2022/1984
Re:Lachlan Rowe
APPLICANT
AndNational Disability Insurance Agency
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Member I Thompson
Date: 9 June 2023
Place:Adelaide
For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal has determined that the Respondent is granted leave to inspect all documents under summons issued to the:
(a)Practice Manager, Territory Medical; and
(b)Practice Manager, Palmerston Medical Clinic.
.............[sgnd]........................
Member I Thompson
Catchwords
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - objection by the Applicant to the Respondent’s inspection of material produced under summonses – relevance of the material produced under summonses to the issues raised by the reviewable decision – objections disallowed
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
Cases
Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285
MMMY & National Disability Insurance Agency [2002] AATA 3236
REASONS FOR DECISION
Member I Thompson
9 June 2023
On 4 January 2022, the applicant, Mr Rowe, made a request to access the National Disability Insurance Scheme, pursuant to s 18 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (“the NDIS Act”). On 2 February 2022, the National Disability Insurance Agency (“the Agency”) refused the applicant’s request. On 10 March 222, the Agency’s refusal was affirmed on internal review. Mr Rowe lodged an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of the internal review decision.
In the access request form, Mr Rowe listed his disabilities as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder – combined type (“ADHD”), sensory processing disorder and complex post-traumatic stress (“PTSD”).
In its reasons for the decision on internal review, the Agency accepted that Mr Rowe has impairments of ADHD, delayed sensory processing and PTSD. However, the Agency was not satisfied that the impairments are or are likely to be permanent. Hence, the Agency determined the disability requirements in s 24 (1)(b) of the NDIS Act and the early intervention requirements in s 25 (1)(a) of the NDIS Act were not met. In his application to the Tribunal, Mr Rowe submitted that the Agency’s decision is incorrect in the application of the access criteria outlined in ss 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act.
SUMMONSES
The Agency requested summonses to be issued to, Mr Henry Kwiatkowski of EASA, Dr Zelko Mustac of Dokotela, the Practice Manager at Territory Medical, with reference to Dr Hong Liu and the Practice Manager at Palmerston Medical Clinic, with reference to Dr Roy Abraham.
In each one of the requests to issue summonses, the Agency sought “referrals, reports, clinical notes, correspondence or any other documents regarding any attendance on or treatment of the Applicant”. The reasons for the requests included an identical assertion in each request, specifically that the summonsed documents “have a bearing specifically on the assessment of whether the Applicant’s conditions have the requisite permanency to satisfy the criteria in ss 24 and 25 of the Act.”
The Tribunal directed that the summonsed material…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lowe and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 1599
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the material produced under summonses was relevant to the reviewable decision, and consequently, whether the NDIA should be permitted to inspect it. Mr Lowe had raised objections to this inspection, necessitating the Tribunal's determination on the scope of discovery and the relevance of the documents.
The Tribunal acknowledged Mr Lowe's need for time to review the NDIA's written submissions and attachments, which he had not had an opportunity to consider before the directions hearing. His request for time to assess the material was deemed reasonable. The Tribunal indicated that further consideration might be required at a subsequent directions hearing to allow Mr Lowe to make submissions regarding the NDIA's contention that no further orders for document production were necessary.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the production of the documents, the Agency sought to inspect the material under the summonses. Mr. Lowe objected to this inspection on the grounds that the material was irrelevant to the issues raised by the reviewable decision. Mr. Lowe argued that the relevance of the material to the review should be determined by the Tribunal, and that the Agency's inspection was premature and unwarranted. This objection was lodged prior to the Agency having the opportunity to fully review the material produced under the summonses. At a telephone directions hearing on 10 February 2023, both Mr. Lowe and the Agency presented oral submissions on the matter. Mr. Lowe highlighted that, due to the timing of the hearing, he had not had sufficient opportunity to consider the Agency's written submissions and attachments, which further underscored his need for time to assess the relevance of the material in question. The Tribunal acknowledged that Mr. Lowe's request for time to review the material was reasonable, given the circumstances. However, the Tribunal also noted that the matter might require further consideration at a subsequent direction hearing. This would allow Mr. Lowe to make any necessary submissions regarding the Agency's contention that no further orders for the production of documents were required.
The matter of Lowe and the National Disability Insurance Agency originated as an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Agency. Following the filing of the application, the Agency served a notice to produce documents under summonses, to which Mr. Lowe subsequently responded by lodging materials pursuant to the summonses. The Respondent then applied for inspection of the material produced under the summonses, which application was opposed by Mr. Lowe on the basis of relevance and confidentiality. This opposition led to a telephone directions hearing on 10 February 2023, where both parties presented oral submissions. Given that Mr. Rowe had not had the opportunity to review the Agency's written submissions and attachments prior to the directions hearing, his request for time to consider the material was deemed reasonable. The court acknowledged the need for further consideration of the relevance and admissibility of the material at a subsequent direction hearing, should Mr. Rowe choose to make further submissions regarding the Agency's stance that no further orders for document production are necessary.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court allowed the Respondent's inspection of the material produced under summonses despite the Applicant's objection, focusing on the procedural fairness to both parties. The Applicant, Mr Rowe, argued that he needed time to consider the Respondent's written submissions and attachments before proceeding with the inspection. The court acknowledged the reasonableness of Mr Rowe's request but proceeded with the inspection to ensure that the proceedings were not unduly delayed and to maintain procedural fairness towards the Respondent. The court balanced the need for expeditious resolution of the matter against the Applicant's right to adequately prepare his response.
In assessing the relevance of the material produced under summonses to the issues raised by the reviewable decision, the court found that the material was pertinent to the proceedings. The court emphasised that the material was directly related to the issues at hand, justifying its inspection. The Applicant's argument that the material was irrelevant did not convince the court, which determined that the inspection was necessary for a comprehensive review of the case. The court's decision hinged on the premise that all relevant information must be considered to ensure a fair and thorough examination of the reviewable decision.
The court also considered whether it should have granted the Applicant's request for time to consider the Respondent's written submissions and attachments before proceeding with the inspection of the material. The court recognised the Applicant's reasonable suggestion that he needed time to adequately prepare his response. However, the court opted to proceed with the inspection to prevent undue delay in the proceedings. The court's decision was influenced by the need to balance the procedural rights of both parties and to maintain the momentum of the case.
The court acknowledged the need for further consideration at a subsequent direction hearing regarding the Agency's submission that there is no need for the Tribunal to make any further order for production of documents. The court recognised that the matter may require additional scrutiny to determine whether further orders for document production are necessary. This consideration is crucial to ensure that all relevant information is available for the Tribunal's review and that the proceedings are conducted efficiently and fairly. The court's decision to defer this issue to a subsequent hearing allows for a more comprehensive evaluation of the Agency's submission and the implications for the case.
In conclusion, the court's decision to allow the Respondent's inspection of the material produced under summonses, despite the Applicant's objection, was grounded in the principles of procedural fairness and the necessity to avoid undue delay. The relevance of the material to the issues raised by the reviewable decision was deemed sufficient to warrant inspection. While the court recognised the Applicant's reasonable request for time to consider the Respondent's submissions, it prioritised the expeditious resolution of the matter. The court's decision to reserve judgment on the Agency's submission regarding further orders for document production ensures that this aspect will be thoroughly examined at a subsequent hearing, allowing for a comprehensive and fair resolution of the case.