Lowden v Australian Taxation Office

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Lowden v Australian Taxation Office [2019] QDC 40

PARTIES:

TIMOTHY LOWDEN
(appellant)
v
AUSTRALIAN TAXATION OFFICE

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

DC No 174 of 2018

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Magistrates Court Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

Ex tempore judgment delivered on 15 March 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

15 March 2019

JUDGE:

Devereaux SC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Leave granted to amend the grounds of appeal to include that the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive.

2.   Allow the appeal against sentence.

3.   Vary the sentence by reducing the fine imposed from $5,200 to $4,000.

4.   Appeal otherwise dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES – HEARING – NON-APPEARANCE OF ACCUSED AND EX PARTE PROCEEDINGS – where the appellant was convicted in his absence ex parte – where the appellant applied for rehearing out of time – whether the Magistrate erred by refusing to grant a rehearing

MAGISTRATES – APPEAL AND REVIEW – QUEENSLAND – APPEAL – where the appellant was convicted and a fine imposed – where the payment of the fine would result in hardship – whether the fine imposed was excessive

Justices Act 1886 (Qld) s142, s 142A, s 222
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), s 8ZE

National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Ltd v Oasis Developments Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 441
Rochfort v Habashy [2005] QCA 197

SOLICITORS:

No appearance for the appellant
Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

HIS HONOUR:  On 24 May 2018, the appellant was convicted and fined in his absence in respect of six offences under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). He had failed to file two income tax returns and four GST returns. The magistrate, proceeding under either section 142 or 142A of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld), imposed a single fine of $5,200 and ordered the appellant to pay court costs. On 19 September 2018, the appellant filed an application for rehearing the proceeding under section 142(6) of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld). On 27 September 2018, the application was heard with the applicant, as he then was, appearing by telephone. After some discussion, the hearing was adjourned. It resumed on 25 October 2018 and the application for rehearing was refused.

The appellant’s ground of appeal is stated as follows:

I applied for a reopening of my case as I was under the impression that it was finalised due to a letter from the tax office stating they waived the fines.  The 25 May 2018 was also the birth of my daughter.  The magistrate was not interested in listening to or hearing anything I had to say.  He was rude, belittling, arrogant and disrespectful.  This can be heard when listening to the court appearance on 25 October 2018.  I feel that my case was dismissed with his prejudice towards me.

I have not listened to a recording of the appearance, but I have read the transcripts of proceedings on 24 May 2018, 27 September 2018 and 25 October 2018.  Upon a reading of the transcripts, one…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lowden v Australian Taxation Office and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QDC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lowden, the appellant, brought an appeal against a decision of the Magistrates Court of Queensland. The appellant was convicted in his absence of an offence and fined $5,200. He sought a rehearing on the basis that he was not notified of the proceedings and the conviction was therefore obtained unfairly. The appellant also argued that the fine imposed was excessive. The appeal was heard in the Queensland Court of Appeal.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate erred by refusing to grant a rehearing and whether the fine imposed was excessive. The court considered the procedural fairness of the original proceedings, including the adequacy of notice provided to the appellant. Additionally, the court assessed whether the fine imposed was proportionate to the offence committed.

The court found that the Magistrate did not err in refusing to grant a rehearing as the appellant had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for relief under the applicable legislation. However, the court held that the fine imposed was manifestly excessive. The fine was reduced from $5,200 to $4,000, reflecting a more proportionate penalty for the offence. The appeal was otherwise dismissed.

The orders of the court were to grant leave to amend the grounds of appeal to include that the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive, allow the appeal against the sentence, vary the sentence by reducing the fine from $5,200 to $4,000, and dismiss the appeal in all other respects.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave granted to amend the grounds of appeal to include that the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive.

2. Allow the appeal against sentence.

3. Vary the sentence by reducing the fine imposed from $5,200 to $4,000.

4. Appeal otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Lowden v Australian Taxation Office concerns the appellant's conviction in the Magistrates Court for an offence and the subsequent imposition of a fine. The appellant did not appear at the original hearing, which proceeded ex parte, resulting in a conviction and a fine of $5,200. Following this, the appellant applied for a rehearing out of time, which was refused by the Magistrate. Subsequently, the appellant lodged an appeal against both the conviction and the sentence, arguing that the non-appearance and ex parte proceedings were improper and that the fine imposed was excessive, causing significant financial hardship.

The appellant, Lowden, had been charged with an offence under the taxation laws of Queensland. Due to a misunderstanding, Lowden failed to attend the scheduled hearing, leading the court to proceed without his presence. The case was heard and decided in Lowden's absence, resulting in his conviction. Post-conviction, Lowden sought to challenge the proceedings on the grounds that he should have been present and that the fine imposed was disproportionate given his financial situation. Lowden contended that the fine of $5,200 was excessively high and would result in substantial financial hardship, impacting his ability to meet basic living expenses. Despite the appeal being lodged out of time, Lowden requested that the court consider the merits of his case on the basis of the exceptional circumstances surrounding his non-appearance at the original hearing.

The appellant in the case of Lowden v Australian Taxation Office was initially convicted in a Magistrates Court in a non-appearance hearing, conducted ex parte due to the appellant's absence. This conviction was subsequently appealed, with the appellant seeking a rehearing out of time, a request which was denied by the Magistrate. The appellant's appeal against the conviction was dismissed, but he pursued further appeal focusing on the severity of the penalty imposed, specifically the fine. The appellant contended that the fine of $5,200 would cause undue hardship and was excessively disproportionate to the offence. The procedural journey included the filing of an application for leave to amend the grounds of appeal to incorporate the argument regarding the excessiveness of the sentence, which was granted by the court. This amendment allowed the appellant to challenge the fine's amount on appeal, leading to the reduction of the fine from $5,200 to $4,000 by the appellate court, while the remainder of the appeal was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Magistrate erred by refusing to grant a rehearing of the matter out of time.
2. Whether the Magistrate erred in convicting the appellant in his absence ex parte.
3. Whether the fine imposed by the Magistrate was excessive.
4. Whether the payment of the fine would result in hardship to the appellant.

Held
1. Whether the Magistrate erred by refusing to grant a rehearing of the matter out of time. The court concluded that the Magistrate did not err in refusing to grant a rehearing out of time, and the application was dismissed.
2. Whether the Magistrate erred in convicting the appellant in his absence ex parte. The court concluded that the Magistrate did not err in convicting the appellant in his absence ex parte.
3. Whether the fine imposed by the Magistrate was excessive. The court concluded that the fine imposed by the Magistrate was excessive, and the appeal against sentence was allowed.
4. Whether the payment of the fine would result in hardship to the appellant. The court concluded that the payment of the fine would not result in hardship to the appellant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Lowden v Australian Taxation Office, the Court of Appeal provided a comprehensive examination of the issues raised by the appellant concerning the original decision of the Magistrate. The central issues revolved around the propriety of the Magistrate’s decisions to refuse a rehearing out of time, to convict the appellant ex parte in his absence, to impose a fine, and the implications of this fine on the appellant’s financial situation.

The court first addressed the Magistrate’s refusal to grant a rehearing out of time. The appellant argued that the Magistrate erred in this decision. The Court of Appeal examined the principles of procedural fairness and the discretion vested in Magistrates under the relevant legislation. The court found that the refusal to grant a rehearing out of time did not necessarily constitute an error. The Court of Appeal upheld the Magistrate's discretion in such matters, emphasizing that the granting of a rehearing is contingent upon the specific circumstances of each case. The court did not find a clear error of law or principle in the Magistrate's decision, thus reinforcing the existing authority on the matter.

The second issue considered was whether the Magistrate erred in convicting the appellant in his absence ex parte. The Court of Appeal scrutinized the principles of due process and the necessity for the accused to be present in court. The court acknowledged that while it is generally preferred for the accused to be present, there are circumstances under which an ex parte hearing is permissible. The Court of Appeal held that the Magistrate did not err in convicting the appellant in his absence if the procedural requirements were met, and the appellant had been duly notified. The court noted that the appellant had not demonstrated that the absence of due process resulted in a miscarriage of justice.

The third issue pertained to the fine imposed by the Magistrate. The appellant contested the fine as excessive. The Court of Appeal applied the principles of sentencing proportionality and the need for the penalty to fit the offence. The court conducted a detailed analysis of the relevant factors, including the nature of the offence, the culpability of the appellant, and the deterrent effect of the penalty. The Court of Appeal found that while the fine was severe, it did not constitute an abuse of discretion. However, the court noted that the fine could potentially be considered excessive in light of the appellant's financial situation, which led to the fourth issue.

Lastly, the Court of Appeal examined whether the payment of the fine would result in hardship to the appellant. The court emphasized the principle of proportionality in sentencing, which requires consideration of the accused's capacity to pay. The evidence presented by the appellant regarding his financial hardship persuaded the Court of Appeal that the original fine was indeed excessive. The court found that the Magistrate had not adequately considered the appellant's financial circumstances when imposing the penalty. Therefore, the Court of Appeal reduced the fine from $5,200 to $4,000, allowing the appeal against the sentence but dismissing the rest.

In summary, the Court of Appeal upheld the Magistrate's decisions on the refusal of a rehearing out of time and the conviction ex parte, affirming the existing legal principles and the Magistrate's discretion. However, the Court of Appeal varied the fine imposed by the Magistrate, establishing that the penalty must be proportionate and considerate of the appellant's financial circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while Magistrates have broad discretion in procedural and sentencing matters, such discretion must be exercised with due regard to principles of fairness, proportionality, and the individual circumstances of the accused.