Lovelee v Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL
CITATION: Lovelee v Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd [2025] NSWPICMP 657
APPELLANT: Christopher Lovelee
RESPONDENT: Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd
APPEAL PANEL
MEMBER: Jacqueline Snell
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Robert Kuru
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Tim Anderson
DATE OF DECISION: 1 September 2025

CATCHWORDS: 

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; the appellant appealed from the Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) but elected to discontinue his proceedings subsequent to the first Appeal Panel decision but prior to the issuing of the certificate of determination by the Commission; appellant recommenced his appeal against the MAC following surgical treatment to his lumbar spine; the second Appeal Panel decided it did not have jurisdiction to consider the appeal and confirmed the MAC; the appellant sought judicial review of the second Appeal Panel’s decision and the Supreme Court of NSW set the decision aside and remitted the matter to the President to be determined according to law; this Appeal Panel received the appellant’s fresh evidence on the appeal and determined the appellant should undergo further medical examination; following which the Appeal Panel was satisfied the injury the appellant sustained to his lumbar spine had deteriorated and there is an increase in the degree of permanent impairment; Held – Medical Assessment Certificate revoked.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL

  1. On 30 July 2021 Christopher Lovelee lodged an Application to Appeal Against the Decision of a Medical Assessor (the 2021 Appeal). The medical dispute was assessed by Dr Kumar, a Medical Assessor, who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) on 5 July 2021.

  2. On 8 September 2021 the delegate of the President of the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) referred the matter to an Appeal Panel (the 2021 Appeal Panel) for determination. On 24 September 2021, the 2021 Appeal Panel determined there was no error in the MAC and the 2021 Appeal Panel confirmed the MAC. Mr Lovelee subsequently elected to discontinue the 2021 Appeal proceedings on 27 September 2021 and as a consequence a Certificate of Determination under s 294 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) was not issued by the Commission.

  3. On 7 February 2024 Mr Lovelee re-commenced his appeal against the MAC (the 2024 Appeal) and on this occasion relied on the following grounds of appeal under s 327(3) of the 1998 Act:

    ·        deterioration of the worker’s condition that results in an increase in the degree of permanent impairment, and

    ·        availability of additional relevant information (being additional information that was not available to, and that could not reasonably have been obtained by, the appellant before the medical assessment appealed against).

  1. While the Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd (SICT) submitted that the matter should be referred back to the Medical Assessor for “reconsideration”, Mr Lovelee objected to this course and requested a re-examination by a Medical Assessor who was a member of the Appeal Panel (the 2024 Appeal Panel).

  2. On 20 March 2024 the delegate of the President of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lovelee v Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 657
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lovelee v Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Ltd, the appellant, Lovelee, sought to appeal a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) issued after a workplace injury. The case involved the interpretation of the Workers Compensation Act 1998, specifically concerning the jurisdiction of appeal panels and the assessment of permanent impairment. Lovelee initially discontinued his appeal but later resumed it following medical treatment. The second Appeal Panel ruled it lacked jurisdiction and confirmed the MAC. Lovelee sought judicial review, and the Supreme Court of New South Wales set aside the Appeal Panel’s decision, remitting the matter for reconsideration. The new Appeal Panel then decided that Lovelee should undergo further medical examination, finding his condition had deteriorated and his degree of permanent impairment had increased.

The legal issues centred on the jurisdiction of the Appeal Panel to reconsider a MAC issued after an initial assessment and the authority to revoke a MAC under specific statutory provisions. Key statutory sections included s 58, s 294, s 322A, and s 329 of the Workers Compensation Act 1998, which govern the publication of decisions, the issuance of certificates, the assessment of permanent impairment, and the referral for further medical assessment, respectively. The Court had to determine whether the Appeal Panel had the jurisdiction to consider Lovelee's appeal and whether the MAC could be revoked based on new evidence of deterioration in his condition.

The Court found that the Appeal Panel did have the jurisdiction to reconsider the MAC in light of new evidence, and it was appropriate to revoke the MAC given the deterioration in Lovelee's condition. The Court relied on the authority established in Sleiman v Gadalla Pty Ltd, where the Court of Appeal held that an appeal from a new MAC could be entertained if there was a significant deterioration in the worker's condition. Additionally, the Court referred to Pollard v Toll Holdings Pty Ltd, which reinforced the principle that a MAC issued by a Medical Appeal Panel could be subject to reconsideration under certain circumstances. The Supreme Court's decision was that the Appeal Panel should have considered the fresh evidence and made a new determination, leading to the revocation of the original MAC.

The final orders included the revocation of the initial MAC and the direction that Lovelee should undergo further medical examination. The Court emphasised the importance of allowing appeals in cases where there is clear evidence of a deterioration in a worker's condition, ensuring that the statutory framework provides a fair and just resolution for injured workers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 58 of the PIC Act relevantly provides:“Publication of decisions:(1) The Commission must cause details of the following to be published in accordance with the Commission rules –(a)decisions of the Commission…(b)decisions of Appeal Panels for medical assessments under Part 7 of Chapter 7 of the 1998 Act.” Section 294 of the 1998 Act provides:“Certificate of Commission’s determination(1) If a dispute is determined by the Commission, the Commission must as soon as practicable after the determination of the dispute issue the parties to the dispute with a certificate as to the determination.(2) A brief statement is to be attached to the certificate setting out the Commission’s reasons for the determination.” Section 322A of the 1998 Act provides:“One assessment only of degree of permanent impairment(1) Only one assessment may be made of the degree of permanent impairment of an injured worker.(1A) A reference in subsection (1) to an assessment includes an assessment of the degree of permanent impairment made by the Commission in the course of the determination of a dispute about the degree of the impairment that is not the subject of a referral under this Part.(2) The medical assessment certificate that is given in connection with that assessment is the only medical assessment certificate that can be used in connection with any further or subsequent medical dispute about the degree of permanent impairment of the worker as a result of the injury concerned (whether the subsequent or further dispute is in connection with a claim for permanent impairment compensation, the commutation of a liability for compensation or a claim for work injury damages).(3) Accordingly, a medical dispute about the degree of permanent impairment of a worker as a result of any injury cannot be referred for, or be the subject of, assessment if a medical dispute about that matter has already been the subject of –(a)Assessment and a medical assessment certificate under this Part, or (b)A determination by the Commission under Part 4.(4) This section does not affect the operation of section 327 (Appeal against medical assessment) or 352 (Appeal against decision of Commission constituted by non-presidential member).” Section 326 of the 1998 Act provides:“Status of medical assessments(1) An assessment certified in a medical assessment certificate pursuant to a medical assessment under this Part is conclusively presumed to be correct as to the following matters in any proceedings before a court of the Commission with which the certificate is concerned –(a)The degree of permanent impairment of the worker as a result of an injury,(b)Whether any proportion of permanent impairment is due to any previous injury or re-existing condition or abnormality;(c)The nature and extent of loss of hearing suffered by a worker;(d)Whether impairment is permanent;(e)Whether the degree of permanent impairment is fully ascertainable.(2) As to any other matter, the assessment certified is evidence (but not conclusive evidence) in any such proceedings.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 329 of the 1998 Act provides:“Referral of matter for further medical assessment or reconsideration(1) A matter referred for assessment under this Part may be referred again on one or more further occasions for assessment in accordance with this Part, but only by –(a)The President as an alternative to an appeal against the assessment as provided by section 327, or(b)A court or the Commission.(1A) A matter referred for assessment under this Part may be referred again on one or more further occasions by the President for reconsideration.(2) A certificate as to a matter referred again for further assessment or reconsideration prevails over any previous certificate as to the matter to the extent of any inconsistency.” It is essential to note authority the Appeal Panel considers to be central to Mr Lovelee’s 2024 Appeal, and of particular importance in the circumstances of Mr Lovelee’s 2024 Appeal are the matters of Sleiman v Gadalla Pty Ltd [3] and Lovelee No 2. Of relevance too is the recent decision of Pollard v Toll Holdings Pty Ltd.[4][3] [2021] NSWCA 236 (Sleiman).[4] [2025] NSWPICPD 58 (Pollard). In Sleiman, Mr Sleiman’s claim for permanent impairment compensation payable under s 66 of the 1987 Act was referred by consent for assessment of WPI by an Approved Medical Specialist (AMS) in the former Workers Compensation Commission (WCC). The AMS assessed Mr Sleiman with 2% WPI and a MAC was issued. Mr Sleiman subsequently appealed the MAC on the grounds the assessment was made on the basis of incorrect criteria, and the MAC contained a demonstrable error. Mr Sleiman was re-examined by a member of the Medical Appeal Panel who assessed Mr Sleiman with 14% WPI. The Medical Appeal Panel revoked the MAC issued and a new MAC (new MAC) was issued. The WCC subsequently issued a Certificate of Determination which reflected the increase in Mr Sleiman’s WPI in accordance with the new MAC. Sometime later Mr Sleiman appealed the new MAC on the grounds there had been a deterioration of condition that results in an increase in the degree of permanent impairment. Mr Sleiman’s appeal failed essentially on the basis that an appeal from the new MAC was not available to him because the new MAC resulted from the decision of a Medical Appeal Panel. Mr Sleiman’s subsequent application to the NSW Supreme Court for judicial review of the delegate’s decision that his appeal could not proceed for jurisdictional reasons also failed. In essence, Harrison AJ said that a MAC issued by a Medical Appeal Panel is not the same as a MAC issued by a Medical Assessor in that a MAC issued by a Medical Appeal Panel it is not an “original” medical assessment as referred in s 328(2) of the 1998 Act, being the section which outlines procedure on appeal. Mr Sleiman subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal, which in essence determined that in circumstances where there was a deterioration of his condition that resulted in an increase in the degree of permanent impairment it was available to Mr Sleiman to seek a reconsideration of the MAC issued by the Medical Appeal Panel. Of significance is that in Sleiman the Court of Appeal accepted Mr Sleiman’s appeal from the new MAC was precluded because of s 327(2) and s 327(7) of the 1998 Act, the former being that “a matter is appealable under this section if it is a matter as to which the assessment of a medical assessor certified in a medical assessment certificate under this Part is conclusively presumed to be correct in proceedings before a court of the Commission” and the latter being “there is to be no appeal against a medical assessment once the dispute concerned has been the subject of determination by a court or the Commission or agreement registered under section 66A of the 1987 Act”.