Louth and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Louth and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2021] AATA 3641 (13 October 2021)

Division:                  VETERANS’ APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:          2020/8563

Re:Raymond Louth

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:L Rieper, Member

Date of Decision:               13 October 2021

Place:Hobart

The application is dismissed under s 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

……………[sgd]……………………………..
L Rieper, Member

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Respondent seeks the dismissal of this application under s 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) on the basis that the continuation of the application for review is misconceived and lacks reasonable prospects of success.

  2. The Respondent says that the issues before the Tribunal have all been resolved in favour of the Applicant and the reviewable decision superseded so that further review of the reviewable decision is unnecessary and pointless.

    BACKGROUND

  3. By application lodged with the Tribunal on 24 December 2020, the Applicant sought review of the Respondent’s decision dated 18 November 2020 which affirmed a determination dated 24 July 2020 that retrospectively reduced the rate of service pension to which the Applicant and his wife were entitled for the period from 14 August 2015 to 16 September 2018 (the decision under review). This was to take account of deemed income from the Applicant’s Asgard Infinity eWRAP Pension Account (the Asgard Allocated Pension) which had not previously been assessed.  It resulted in overpayments being raised against the Applicant and his wife.

  4. On 11 June 2021, an officer of the Department of Veterans’ Affairs advised the Applicant by email that:

    Upon further review of our overpayment investigation, we discovered that Mr Louth was on a continuous Income Support benefit with Centrelink prior him transferring to DVA’s Service Pension and as such the Asgard Allocated Pension should have been recorded in their DVA assessment as an Asset from date of grant 14/08/2015.

    We have recalculated the original overpayment raised for the period 14/08/2015 to 16/09/2018 to $1,105.33 each from the original amount raised of $2,967.07 each, a reduction of $1,861.74 each – Mr & Mrs Louth were assessed under the asset test for period 14/08/2015 to 11/03/2016.

    As the original debts raised have already been repaid from portion deductions from their ongoing pension payments, refunds of $1,861.74 each will be paid to their nominated bank accounts within the next week.

    We will need to undertake an action shortly to update Mr & Mrs Louth’s assessment with details of the Asgard Allocated Pension - the last Income Stream Schedule we received is dated 19 August 2020. Could you please supply us with the latest schedule within 14 days.

  5. On 11 June 2021, the Applicant’s representative forwarded the above email, together with his email in response to the Tribunal, advising:

    Clearly, as I have stated in past communications “this settles the matter, once and for all” in Mr Louth’s favour.

    Please therefore cease any further AAT hearings (emphasis in original).

  6. On 2 July 2021, the Tribunal held a directions hearing and,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Louth and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3641
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Louth (the Applicant) for review of a decision by the Repatriation Commission (the Respondent) dated 18 November 2020. This decision affirmed an earlier determination that retrospectively reduced the Applicant and his wife's service pension between 14 August 2015 and 16 September 2018. The reduction was to account for deemed income from the Applicant's Asgard Allocated Pension, which had not been previously assessed, leading to the raising of overpayments. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was asked to consider whether the application for review should be dismissed.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant's application for review had become misconceived, lacked substance, or had no reasonable prospect of success, thereby justifying dismissal under section 42B(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. This question arose following correspondence from the Respondent on 11 June 2021, which indicated a recalculation of the overpayment, a reduction in the amount owed, and the issuance of refunds. The Respondent also stated that the Asgard Allocated Pension should have been recorded as an asset from the initial grant date.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the power to dismiss proceedings should be exercised cautiously, a lack of practical benefit to the applicant could be a ground for dismissal. The Tribunal accepted the Respondent's concession that the application had merit when initially lodged. However, it noted that the Respondent's communication on 11 June 2021 effectively set aside the decision under review and recalculated the overpayments, with refunds subsequently issued. The Applicant's representative had initially indicated that this resolution settled the matter in the Applicant's favour. Despite a later assertion by the Applicant's representative that the basis for the remaining alleged overpayment was still in contention, the Tribunal found that the core issue regarding the treatment of the Asgard Allocated Pension had been resolved by the Respondent's revised assessment and the subsequent refunds.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the application for review was no longer pursuing a live issue, as the decision under review had been superseded by the Respondent's subsequent actions. Therefore, the Tribunal found that the application had no reasonable prospect of success and was an abuse of process. The application for review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent says that the issues before the Tribunal have all been resolved in favour of the Applicant and the reviewable decision superseded so that further review of the reviewable decision is unnecessary and pointless.BACKGROUND By application lodged with the Tribunal on 24 December 2020, the Applicant sought review of the Respondent’s decision dated 18 November 2020 which affirmed a determination dated 24 July 2020 that retrospectively reduced the rate of service pension to which the Applicant and his wife were entitled for the period from 14 August 2015 to 16 September 2018 (the decision under review). This was to take account of deemed income from the Applicant’s Asgard Infinity eWRAP Pension Account (the Asgard Allocated Pension) which had not previously been assessed. It resulted in overpayments being raised against the Applicant and his wife. On 11 June 2021, an officer of the Department of Veterans’ Affairs advised the Applicant by email that:Upon further review of our overpayment investigation, we discovered that Mr Louth was on a continuous Income Support benefit with Centrelink prior him transferring to DVA’s Service Pension and as such the Asgard Allocated Pension should have been recorded in their DVA assessment as an Asset from date of grant 14/08/2015.We have recalculated the original overpayment raised for the period 14/08/2015 to 16/09/2018 to $1,105.33 each from the original amount raised of $2,967.07 each, a reduction of $1,861.74 each – Mr & Mrs Louth were assessed under the asset test for period 14/08/2015 to 11/03/2016.As the original debts raised have already been repaid from portion deductions from their ongoing pension payments, refunds of $1,861.74 each will be paid to their nominated bank accounts within the next week.We will need to undertake an action shortly to update Mr & Mrs Louth’s assessment with details of the Asgard Allocated Pension - the last Income Stream Schedule we received is dated 19 August 2020. Could you please supply us with the latest schedule within 14 days. On 11 June 2021, the Applicant’s representative forwarded the above email, together with his email in response to the Tribunal, advising:Clearly, as I have stated in past communications “this settles the matter, once and for all” in Mr Louth’s favour.Please therefore cease any further AAT hearings (emphasis in original). On 2 July 2021, the Tribunal held a directions hearing and, with the consent of the parties, vacated the hearing that had been listed to take place on 20 August 2021.The application to dismiss Section 42B(1) of the AAT Act relevantly provides:(1)The Tribunal may dismiss an application for the review of a decision, at any stage of the proceeding, if the Tribunal is satisfied that the application:(a) is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance; or(b) has no reasonable prospect of success; or(c) is otherwise an abuse of the process of the Tribunal. On 20 August 2021, the Respondent advised the Tribunal that in its submission, there were no outstanding issues for the Tribunal to determine.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By application lodged with the Tribunal on 24 December 2020, the Applicant sought review of the Respondent’s decision dated 18 November 2020 which affirmed a determination dated 24 July 2020 that retrospectively reduced the rate of service pension to which the Applicant and his wife were entitled for the period from 14 August 2015 to 16 September 2018 (the decision under review). This was to take account of deemed income from the Applicant’s Asgard Infinity eWRAP Pension Account (the Asgard Allocated Pension) which had not previously been assessed. It resulted in overpayments being raised against the Applicant and his wife. On 11 June 2021, an officer of the Department of Veterans’ Affairs advised the Applicant by email that:Upon further review of our overpayment investigation, we discovered that Mr Louth was on a continuous Income Support benefit with Centrelink prior him transferring to DVA’s Service Pension and as such the Asgard Allocated Pension should have been recorded in their DVA assessment as an Asset from date of grant 14/08/2015.We have recalculated the original overpayment raised for the period 14/08/2015 to 16/09/2018 to $1,105.33 each from the original amount raised of $2,967.07 each, a reduction of $1,861.74 each – Mr & Mrs Louth were assessed under the asset test for period 14/08/2015 to 11/03/2016.As the original debts raised have already been repaid from portion deductions from their ongoing pension payments, refunds of $1,861.74 each will be paid to their nominated bank accounts within the next week.We will need to undertake an action shortly to update Mr & Mrs Louth’s assessment with details of the Asgard Allocated Pension - the last Income Stream Schedule we received is dated 19 August 2020. Could you please supply us with the latest schedule within 14 days. On 11 June 2021, the Applicant’s representative forwarded the above email, together with his email in response to the Tribunal, advising:Clearly, as I have stated in past communications “this settles the matter, once and for all” in Mr Louth’s favour.Please therefore cease any further AAT hearings (emphasis in original). On 2 July 2021, the Tribunal held a directions hearing and, with the consent of the parties, vacated the hearing that had been listed to take place on 20 August 2021.The application to dismiss Section 42B(1) of the AAT Act relevantly provides:(1)The Tribunal may dismiss an application for the review of a decision, at any stage of the proceeding, if the Tribunal is satisfied that the application:(a) is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance; or(b) has no reasonable prospect of success; or(c) is otherwise an abuse of the process of the Tribunal. On 20 August 2021, the Respondent advised the Tribunal that in its submission, there were no outstanding issues for the Tribunal to determine. On 23 August 2021, the Tribunal set a timetable for the parties to file and serve submissions in respect of the question of dismissal and advised that the application for dismissal would be determined on the papers. In addition to the submissions provided for in the timetable, the Applicant’s representative sent an email to the Tribunal and the Respondent’s representative on 20 September 2021 to which the Tribunal has had regard.THE PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONSThe Respondent

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In his email dated 20 September 2021, the Applicant’s representative further stated:I reiterate the matter before the tribunal is the ALLEGED overpayment, which to date has only partly refunded. The remaining contention that we seek the tribunals (sic) review of, is the basis for the remaining ALLEGED overpayment.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal is mindful that the power to dismiss proceedings under s 42B of the AAT Act is a power that should be exercised cautiously.[2] However, a lack of practical benefit to the Applicant may be a reason for exercising the discretion under s 42B.[3][2] Re Filsell and Comcare [2009] AATA 90.[3] See for example, Re Currey and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2007] AATA 1963. The Respondent concedes that the application for review had merit at the time it was made. The Tribunal accepts that concession. The issue now is whether, in light of the decision of 11 June 2021, it is misconceived or has no reasonable prospects of success. The Tribunal’s role in this matter is limited to reviewing the decision of 18 November 2020. It has the power to affirm, vary or set aside the decision under review and either make a decision in substitution or remit the matter for reconsideration in accordance with any directions or recommendations of the Tribunal.[4][4] AAT Act s 43. The decision of 18 November 2020 affirmed an earlier decision of 24 July 2020 to retrospectively reduce the Applicant and his wife’s rate of service pension with effect from 14 August 2015 until 16 September 2018 and to raise an overpayment totaling $5,934.14. The Tribunal notes that only Mr Louth has lodged an application for review with the Tribunal. The Applicant’s representative signed a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions on 14 May 2021 in which he asserted:Basically, the issue is the non-disclosure to DVA of Mr Louth’s ASGARD Account Based Pension (ABP) when he applied for service pension after attaining age 60… He also stated in the Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions:…the CRUX of the matter is that Mr Louth unequivocally disputes the basis of DVAs assessed income of this APB and therefore the quantum of overpayment. The evidence before the Tribunal establishes that on 11 June 2021, the decision of 18 November 2020 was set aside and it was accepted that the Applicant had been “on a continuous Income Support benefit with Centrelink prior him transferring to DVA’s Service Pension and as such the Asgard Allocated Pension should have been recorded in their DVA assessment as an Asset from date of grant 14/08/2015”. The overpayments which had previously been raised were later recalculated, and refunds issued to Applicant and his wife. It is clear from the correspondence between the parties and the Tribunal that the resolution of the issue regarding the treatment of the Asgard Allocated Pension initially satisfied the Applicant. The Applicant’s representative advised the Tribunal on 11 June 2021 that the matter had been settled “once and for all” in the Applicant’s favour.