Louise Hulme v Toll Transport Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
[2025] FWC 2971

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.365 - Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal

Louise Hulme
v

Toll Transport Pty Ltd

(C2025/2372)

COMMISSIONER LIM

PERTH, 6 OCTOBER 2025

Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – jurisdictional objection – dismissed/not dismissed –

  1. What is this decision about?

  1. On Saturday 3 March 2025, Ms Louise Hulme resigned from her employment with Toll Transport Pty Ltd as a Driver Operator. Ms Hulme says that she was forced to resign due to how she was treated by several other Toll Employees and how Toll responded to her complaints about her treatment. Because of this, Ms Hulme says she was dismissed as per the definition in s 386 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Ms Hulme has applied to the Commission under s 365 of the Act. Toll objects to Ms Hulme’s application on the basis it did not dismiss her.

  1. Ms Hulme needs to have been dismissed for her application to proceed. In Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford,[1] the Full Court of the Federal Court held that where there is a question over jurisdiction – as is the case here – the Commission must determine the jurisdictional issue before exercising its powers under s 368 of the Act.[2]

  1. I heard the matter on Tuesday 10 June 2025. I granted permission for both parties to be legally represented. 

  1. In this decision I do not cover all the material the parties submitted. However, I acknowledge that the material provided is very significant to the people involved.

  1. Having considered the relevant evidence and submissions of the parties, I have found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed. Her application must therefore be dismissed.

  1. My detailed reasons for my decision follow.

  1. The evidence

  1. Ms Hulme gave evidence in support of her case. Ms Hulme has been working as driver operator since 2012. Ms Hulme was the only witness to give probative evidence about the events of 2022 to 2024 regarding her interactions with her co-workers. However, that does not mean that I must accept her evidence. The credibility of her evidence must be assessed.

  1. In assessing Ms Hulme’s evidence, I have taken into consideration that she had both mental and physical health issues, which may have affected her recall of details. However, I did find that large parts of Ms Hulme’s evidence were general in nature, with imprecise references to dates, or without proper explanation as to how she knew certain information. Ms Hulme also did not provide evidence that was presumably within her possession, such as text messages she complained about receiving.

  1. Ms Hulme also called Mr Daniel Wilkins to give evidence. Mr Wilkins was a Toll employee from September 2023 to Thursday 11 April 2024 and worked alongside Ms Hulme. Mr Wilkins is Ms Hulme’s partner. With respect to Mr Wilkins, his evidence was largely not probative, as it mostly dealt with matters that Ms Hulme had relayed to him. I have only given weight to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Louise Hulme v Toll Transport Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 2971
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Louise Hulme applied to the Fair Work Commission for relief under section 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act) after she resigned from her employment with Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Toll). Ms Hulme alleged that she was forced to resign due to the conduct of her co-workers and Toll's response to her complaints about her treatment. The Commission must dismiss Ms Hulme's application for want of jurisdiction if she was not dismissed within the meaning of section 386 of the Act. The Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed within the meaning of the Act as she had other options that did not involve her resigning. Therefore, the Commission dismissed Ms Hulme's application for want of jurisdiction.

Ms Hulme submitted that she was forced to resign because of conduct or a course of conduct engaged in by Toll. She submitted that she was subjected to gender-based discrimination, harassment, and poor treatment by her co-workers. She submitted that she had no choice but to resign because of the investigation outcome and the imposition of refresher training on her as a penalty. Toll submitted that it did not engage in conduct that forced Ms Hulme to resign or engage in conduct with the intention of bringing about Ms Hulme’s resignation, and that at the time of Ms Hulme’s resignation, she had other options that did not involve her resigning.

The Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed within the meaning of section 386 of the Act as Ms Hulme had other real or effective choices other than resignation. Ms Hulme could have waited to see if the training addressed the poor behaviour of Mr A or Mr B, Ms Hulme could have followed up with Mr Davey, who wanted to talk to her about her decision to resign, Ms Hulme could have made an application to this Commission for a stop bullying or stop sexual harassment order. The Commission found that there was not enough evidence before it to properly assess whether the investigation was procedurally or substantively flawed. Accordingly, the Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed within the meaning of section 386 of the Act. The Commission dismissed Ms Hulme's application for want of jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

On Saturday 3 March 2025, Ms Louise Hulme resigned from her employment with Toll Transport Pty Ltd as a Driver Operator. Ms Hulme claimed that she was forced to resign due to gender-based discrimination, harassment, and poor treatment by several Toll employees, particularly Mr A and Mr B, as well as Toll's inadequate response to her complaints. Ms Hulme alleged that her treatment began during her interview and continued throughout her employment, including incidents such as being given the worst jobs, denial of career progression, and inappropriate conduct by her colleagues. Ms Hulme lodged a formal complaint with Toll on 5 December 2024, and an investigation was conducted. On 14 February 2025, Ms Hulme received an outcome letter from Toll, which she found unsatisfactory. On 15 February 2025, Ms Hulme sent her resignation email to Toll, citing her distress and dissatisfaction with Toll's handling of her complaint.

Ms Hulme applied to the Fair Work Commission under section 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, seeking to have the Commission deal with contraventions involving her dismissal. Toll objected to the application on the basis that Ms Hulme was not dismissed. The matter was heard by Commissioner Lim on 10 June 2025. Both parties were legally represented. The decision found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed, and her application was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Ms Hulme dismissed within the meaning of section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009?
2. If not, does the Commission have jurisdiction to deal with contraventions involving her alleged dismissal?

Held
1. Was Ms Hulme dismissed within the meaning of section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009?
The Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed within the meaning of section 386(1) of the Act. The Commission held that Ms Hulme had other real or effective choices other than resignation, and therefore, she was not forced to resign due to conduct or a course of conduct engaged in by her employer. As a result, Ms Hulme's application was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.
2. If not, does the Commission have jurisdiction to deal with contraventions involving her alleged dismissal?
Since the Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed, it does not have jurisdiction to deal with contraventions involving her alleged dismissal. Consequently, her application was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Commission considered the definition of 'dismissed' under section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009, which includes termination of employment on the employer's initiative and resignation forced by the employer's conduct. The Commission found that Ms Hulme had other options besides resignation, such as waiting to see if the training addressed the poor behaviour of her co-workers, following up with her employer, or making an application to the Commission for a stop bullying or stop sexual harassment order. The Commission noted that Ms Hulme had the support of the Transport Workers' Union, which might have mentioned the possibility of making an application. The Commission held that there was not enough evidence to determine whether the investigation was procedurally or substantively flawed. Consequently, the Commission found that Ms Hulme was not dismissed within the meaning of section 386 of the Act and dismissed her application for want of jurisdiction. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an employee must prove they did not resign voluntarily when claiming to have been forced to resign due to their employer's conduct. The Commission did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority in reaching its decision.