Louis v Commonwealth of Australia and

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2000] TASSC 157

CITATION:Louis v Commonwealth of Australia and

State of Tasmania [2000] TASSC 157

PARTIES:  LOUIS, Graham James
  v
  COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

and
STATE OF TASMANIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  704/1998
DELIVERED ON:  10 November 2000
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  15 September 2000
JUDGMENT OF:  Evans J
CATCHWORDS:

Procedure - Supreme Court procedure - Tasmania - Practice under Rules of Court - Pleadings - Pleading inadequate and may tend to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceeding.

Supreme Court Rules 2000 (Tas), rr227, 258(1).
Meckiff v Simpson [1968] VR 62; Holderness-Roddam v Roberts Limited A68/1996, followed.
Aust Dig Procedure [272]

Defamation - Actions for defamation - Pleading - Tasmania - Pleading inadequate and may tend to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceeding.

Supreme Court Rules 2000 (Tas), r239(3).
Tournier v National Provincial and Union Bank of England [1924] 1 KB 461; Hadzel and Another v De Waldorf (1970) 16 FLR 174; DDSA Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Times Newspapers Ltd and another [1972] 3 All ER 417; Bloemen v Atkinson (1977) 6 ATR 33; Mirror Newspapers Limited v World Hosts Proprietary Limited (1978 - 1979) 141 CLR 632; Bowes v Felberg and Others 43/1998; Whelan v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 148, followed.
Aust Dig Defamation [119]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Plaintiff:  In person
           Defendant:  P A Bowen and L J Neasey
Solicitors:
           Plaintiff:  In person

Defendant:Commonwealth Australian Government Solicitor and Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment Number:  [2000] TASSC 157
Number of Paragraphs:  8

Serial No 157/2000
File No 704/1998

GRAHAM JAMES LOUIS v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and
STATE OF TASMANIA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  EVANS J

10 November 2000

  1. The defendants seek an order striking out the plaintiff’s statement of claim.

  1. The endorsement on the plaintiff's writ states that his causes of action against the defendants are defamation and invasion of privacy.  By order of the High Court dated 1 April 1998, pursuant to the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s44, the proceedings were remitted to this Court for determination.

  1. Throughout the proceedings the plaintiff has represented himself.  He has no legal training and it is manifest that he has little, if any, understanding of the procedural requirements and substantive law applicable to a defamation action.  In pleading a defamation action, it is necessary to pay regard to a number of unusual and technical requirements.  It is difficult, if not impossible, for a person who lacks legal training to properly prepare a statement of claim in a wide ranging defamation action.  The plaintiff has resisted encouragement to obtain the assistance of a lawyer as he says he cannot afford to do so.  Inevitably, the progress of the action has been beset with problems.

  1. The statement of claim initially attached to the plaintiff's writ was patently deficient.  That statement of claim included an assertion that from 1990 to 1997 the defendants "perpetually engaged in defaming the plaintiff".  Detailed particulars of the statement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Louis v Commonwealth of Australia and and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] TASSC 157
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Supreme Court of Tasmania was brought by Graham James Louis against the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Tasmania. Louis's claims were based on alleged defamation and invasion of privacy. The defendants sought to have Louis's statement of claim struck out due to its inadequacy. Throughout the proceedings, Louis represented himself without legal training, which resulted in several issues with his pleadings. The court was required to decide whether Louis's statement of claim was compliant with the Supreme Court Rules and if it could be struck out due to its potential to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceedings.

The court found that Louis's statement of claim was patently deficient and did not comply with the Supreme Court Rules. The statement of claim was prolix, rambling, and did not contain a concise and explicit statement of all the material facts. Moreover, it contained multiple allegations in a single paragraph and did not specify the exact words complained of in each document. The court also found that the pleading included claims which, as pleaded, were incapable of sustaining a cause of action. The court concluded that the purpose of the relevant rule was to ensure compliance with the rules of pleadings and that striking out the statement of claim was necessary to avoid prejudicing or delaying the fair trial of the proceedings.

The court ordered that Louis's further amended statement of claim be struck out in its entirety. The court emphasized that it was not consistent with the role of a judge in an adversarial system to endeavour to elicit from the plaintiff what he had in mind in relation to these matters and guide him in drafting his statement of claim. Instead, the plaintiff must ensure that his pleadings comply with the relevant rules and requirements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Graham James Louis, the plaintiff, filed a writ against the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Tasmania, the defendants, in the Supreme Court of Tasmania. The writ, endorsed with defamation and invasion of privacy as the plaintiff's causes of action, was remitted to the Supreme Court by the High Court on 1 April 1998, pursuant to the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s44. The plaintiff, representing himself, has no legal training and has demonstrated little understanding of procedural requirements and the substantive law applicable to a defamation action. This lack of understanding has led to several deficiencies in the plaintiff's statements of claim, which have caused significant delays and prejudiced the fair trial of the proceedings.

The initial statement of claim attached to the writ was patently deficient. The plaintiff subsequently filed an amended statement of claim on 21 May 1998, which was also inadequate. In response to requests for detailed particulars of the amended statement of claim, the plaintiff delivered a document dated 14 September 1998, which further confused the matter. Interlocutory applications were filed by both parties, and the inadequacies of the plaintiff's pleadings were addressed during a hearing on 12 October 1998. Despite attempts by the court to assist the plaintiff in remedying the deficiencies, the plaintiff did not engage legal representation. On 12 April 1999, the plaintiff obtained leave to deliver a further amended statement of claim. This pleading, like the earlier ones, was also deficient and contained numerous claims which were incapable of sustaining a cause of action.

The plaintiff's further amended statement of claim did not comply with the Supreme Court Rules, specifically rule 227, which requires a concise and explicit statement of all material facts. The document was prolix and rambling, and some allegations were made in a single paragraph. The plaintiff also failed to plead the exact words complained of in each of the documents, as required by law. Additionally, the plaintiff asserted numerous defamatory imputations without specifying whether they were based on the natural and ordinary meaning of the words or extraneous circumstances. The plaintiff also rolled up multiple imputations into one plea, which can lead to positive mischief when specific defences are available to some but not all of the imputations.

The matter originated in the Supreme Court of Tasmania as a defamation action brought by Graham James Louis against the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Tasmania. The proceedings were initially filed in 1998, and the plaintiff represented himself throughout, despite having no legal training. The plaintiff’s original statement of claim was deemed deficient, leading to requests for particulars and subsequent interlocutory applications. After multiple amendments and discussions regarding the deficiencies of the plaintiff's pleadings, the case was remitted to the Supreme Court of Tasmania by the High Court under section 44 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Despite opportunities to seek legal assistance and review his statement of claim, the plaintiff persisted with his self-representation and filed further amended statements of claim that continued to be inadequate. The court, on 10 November 2000, ultimately ordered that the further amended statement of claim be struck out in its entirety for failing to comply with procedural rules and potentially prejudicing the fair trial of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff's further amended statement of claim comply with the requirements of the Supreme Court Rules for pleadings in a defamation action?
2. Are the claims made in the further amended statement of claim capable of sustaining a cause of action for defamation?
3. Has the plaintiff identified and pleaded the exact words complained of in each document, and the specific defamatory imputations arising from those words?
4. Are the pleaded imputations sufficiently specific and precise, or do they include multiple imputations that should be separated for clarity?
5. Is the further amended statement of claim likely to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceedings, warranting its striking out under the Supreme Court Rules?

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff's further amended statement of claim does not comply with the requirements of the Supreme Court Rules for pleadings in a defamation action. As a result, the court ordered the further amended statement of claim to be struck out in its entirety.
2. The court found that the claims made in the further amended statement of claim are incapable of sustaining a cause of action for defamation.
3. The court held that the plaintiff has not identified and pleaded the exact words complained of in each document, nor has he specified the specific defamatory imputations arising from those words.
4. The court determined that the pleaded imputations are not sufficiently specific and precise, as they include multiple imputations that should be separated for clarity.
5. The court concluded that the further amended statement of claim is likely to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceedings and, therefore, it warranted being struck out under the Supreme Court Rules.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of Tasmania was presented with a case where the plaintiff, Graham James Louis, sought to bring defamation claims against the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Tasmania. The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff's further amended statement of claim complied with the procedural requirements set forth by the Supreme Court Rules for pleadings in a defamation action. The court found that the further amended statement of claim was deficient in several respects, and therefore, it did not comply with the requirements of the Supreme Court Rules, r227 (formerly O21, r3). Specifically, the court noted that the pleading was prolix and rambling, and that it did not contain a concise and explicit statement of all the material facts on which the plaintiff relied. Additionally, each separate allegation was not contained in a separate paragraph, which made it difficult for the defendants to respond to the claims.

The court also considered whether the claims made in the further amended statement of claim were capable of sustaining a cause of action for defamation. The court found that the pleading included claims that were incapable of sustaining a cause of action, such as claims that the defendants wrongly investigated the plaintiff and claims that the defendants acted out of spite and malice towards the plaintiff. The court noted that these claims were not relevant to the defamation action and should not have been included in the pleading.

The court then considered whether the plaintiff had identified and pleaded the exact words complained of in each document and the specific defamatory imputations arising from those words. The court found that the plaintiff had not done so, as required by the authorities such as Tournier v National Provincial and Union Bank of England [1924] 1 KB 461 and Bloemen v Atkinson (1977) 6 ATR 33. The court noted that the plaintiff had asserted numerous defamatory imputations which he said could be implied from words contained in the various documents, but it was not clear whether these imputations were based on the natural and ordinary meaning of the words or whether they were based on extraneous circumstances. The court found that the plaintiff needed to clarify this and plead the extraneous circumstances, if applicable, in accordance with Mirror Newspapers Limited v World Hosts Proprietary Limited (1978 - 1979) 141 CLR 632.

The court also considered whether the pleaded imputations were sufficiently specific and precise, or whether they included multiple imputations that should be separated for clarity. The court found that the plaintiff's pleading included more than one imputation in some instances, and that such a plea should be struck out as it could produce positive mischief when a particular defence was available to some but not all of the imputations, in accordance with Whelan v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 148. The court noted that the plaintiff needed to allege the imputations with specificity and precision, and that he needed to decide whether it was appropriate to plead any false imputations he asserted and, if so, plead the same. The court also noted that the plaintiff needed to plead any true imputations he asserted, together with particulars of the facts and matters upon which he relied to support the same.

Finally, the court considered whether the further amended statement of claim was likely to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceedings, warranting its striking out under the Supreme Court Rules. The court found that the further amended statement of claim was a muddled, convoluted, conglomeration of allegations which were likely to embarrass the defendants, and that it should be struck out pursuant to the Supreme Court Rules, r258(1). The court noted that the purpose of this Rule was to ensure compliance with the rules of pleadings, in accordance with Meckiff v Simpson [1968] VR 62 and Holderness-Roddam v Roberts Limited A68/1996.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a further amended statement of claim in a defamation action must comply with the procedural requirements set forth by the Supreme Court Rules for pleadings. The statement of claim must contain a concise and explicit statement of all the material facts on which the plaintiff relies, and each separate allegation must be contained in a separate paragraph. The statement of claim must also identify and plead the exact words complained of in each document and the specific defamatory imputations arising from those words. The pleaded imputations must be sufficiently specific and precise, and multiple imputations should be separated for clarity. Finally, the statement of claim must not be likely to prejudice or delay the fair trial of the proceedings, and any pleading that is likely to do so may be struck out under the Supreme Court Rules.