Lombardini and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Lombardini and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2024] AATA 416 (13 March 2024)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:          2021/5042

Re:Annette Lombardini

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Date:13 March 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision is set aside and substituted with the decision that Mrs Lombardini satisfies the eligibility criteria in s 24(1) of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) for an increase to the special rate of pension.

....................[Sgd]....................................................

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ ENTITLEMENTS – claim for increase in disability pension from the general rate to the special rate – when the Applicant ceased work – whether war-caused or other factors contributed to the Applicant not being able to engage in remunerative work during the assessment period – “alone” test in s 24(1)(c) of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) applied – Applicant found to be eligible for the special rate of pension – Reviewable Decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) ss 15(1), 19(9), 19(5C), 23, 23(1), 23(1)(b), 24, 24(1), 24(1)(aa), 24(1)(b), 24(1)(c), 24(2), 24(2)(a), 24(2)(b), 28, 120(4)

CASES

Milne and Secretary, Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2008] AATA 68

Repatriation Commission v Richmond (2014) 226 FCR 21

Repatriation Commission v Hendy [2002] FCAFC 424

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

13 March 2024

OVERVIEW

  1. Mrs Lombardini served in the Royal Australian Navy from November 1976 to March 1980 (T19.1).

  2. She is currently in receipt of a disability pension at 100% of the general rate, having been found to suffer from a war-caused injury.

  3. Mrs Lombardini is seeking to increase the rate of her disability pension to the special rate of pension.

  4. The Reviewable Decision that Mrs Lombardini is seeking review of is a decision of the Veterans’ Review Board (VRB) dated 25 May 2021, which affirmed a determination dated 15 October 2020 to continue Mrs Lombardini’s pension at 100% of the general rate (T1.1).

  5. The issue that I must determine is whether Mrs Lombardini is entitled to an increase in her disability pension from 100% of the general rate to the intermediate rate or the special rate under s 23 or 24 of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (VEA).

  6. For the reasons set out below, I have decided that Mrs Lombardini satisfies the eligibility criteria in s 24(1) of the VEA for an increase to the special rate of pension.

    BACKGROUND

  7. Mrs Lombardini has prior accepted claims (T23.1/167) for the conditions of:

    ·“sprain of the right elbow”, effective from 3 February 1977 under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation (Defence-related Claims) Act 1988 (Cth); and

    ·“tinea of the skin” and “bilateral sensorineural hearing loss”, both effective from 25 April 2016.

  8. On 8 April 2019, Mrs Lombardini made a claim for disability pension and an application for an increase to disability pension for several claimed conditions (T9) and submitted a lifestyle questionnaire (T10).

  9. On 7 January 2020,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lombardini and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlemen... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mrs Lombardini for an increase in her disability pension from the general rate to the special rate under the *Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth) (VEA). The Repatriation Commission (the Respondent) had refused the increase, determining that Mrs Lombardini's accepted disabilities did not "alone" prevent her from engaging in remunerative work. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal, constituted by M Evans-Bonner SM, was required to determine whether Mrs Lombardini was eligible for the special rate of pension.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mrs Lombardini satisfied the criteria for the special rate of pension as set out in section 24(1) of the VEA. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether her accepted war-caused or other disabilities were the sole reason she was unable to engage in remunerative work during the relevant assessment period, applying the "alone" test stipulated in section 24(1)(c).

The Tribunal found that Mrs Lombardini did satisfy the eligibility criteria for the special rate. In reaching this conclusion, the Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including medical reports and Mrs Lombardini's own testimony regarding her cessation of work and the impact of her conditions. The Tribunal determined that the accepted disabilities were indeed the sole cause preventing her from engaging in remunerative work, thereby meeting the requirements of section 24(1)(c) of the VEA. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Reviewable Decision and substituted it with a decision that Mrs Lombardini was eligible for the special rate of pension.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, I have decided that Mrs Lombardini satisfies the eligibility criteria in s 24(1) of the VEA for an increase to the special rate of pension.BACKGROUND Mrs Lombardini has prior accepted claims (T23.1/167) for the conditions of:·“sprain of the right elbow”, effective from 3 February 1977 under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation (Defence-related Claims) Act 1988 (Cth); and·“tinea of the skin” and “bilateral sensorineural hearing loss”, both effective from 25 April 2016. On 8 April 2019, Mrs Lombardini made a claim for disability pension and an application for an increase to disability pension for several claimed conditions (T9) and submitted a lifestyle questionnaire (T10). On 7 January 2020, a delegate of the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (Department) decided to accept Mrs Lombardini’s claims for “Right elbow osteoarthritis, Left knee osteoarthritis, Lumbar spondylosis, and major depressive disorder with effect from 08 January 2019”. The delegate increased the rate of Mrs Lombardini’s pension under the VEA from 40% to 100% of the general rate (T19.1/141). On 3 May 2020, Mrs Lombardini’s advocate sought review of that pension assessment (T20/152; T20.1). That application for review was dismissed by the VRB on 21 August 2020 because it was out of time (T24.1/263). On 1 October 2020 Mrs Lombardini made another application for an increase in her disability pension (T26) and submitted a lifestyle questionnaire. This application referred to the disability being an “Increase in Disability Major Depression Disorder”, with the “signs and symptoms” listed as “mobility” and the “basis for the diagnosis” being an enclosed report from psychiatrist, Dr James Fellows-Smith (T26/273). In her application form Mrs Lombardini also stated that she ceased work in a childcare centre on 7 November 2016 with the reason for ceasing work stated as “Mobility/ Major Depression Disorder” (T26/276-277). On 15 October 2020, a delegate of the Respondent decided to refuse an increase to the Special Rate (the Determination) (T30.2) on the basis that: Given the extensive time you have spent outside of the workforce, and that you have not been genuinely seeking employment, I am satisfied that it is not your accepted VEA disabilities “alone” that are preventing you from working” (T30.2/299). This meant that Mrs Lombardini’s disability pension continued at 100% of the general rate with effect from 15 October 2020. On 23 October 2020, Mrs Lombardini’s advocate requested a review of the Determination by the VRB on her behalf (T31). In support of the 23 October 2020 request for a review, Mrs Lombardini’s advocate provided a letter from psychiatrist Dr Fellows-Smith dated 1 May 2020 (T20.2) which, in summary, stated that Mrs Lombardini ceased work on 1 November 2014 due to abnormalities to her lumbar spine which was an accepted condition, and that it was the loss of her role as a childcare supervisor that led to her depression (T20.2/156).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mrs Lombardini gave evidence at the hearing and was cross-examined. The evidence I admitted the following documents into evidence during the hearing:(a)Witness Statement of Mrs Lombardini dated 29 November 2021 (Exhibit A1).(b)Handwritten letter of Dr James Fellows-Smith dated 21 October 2021 (Exhibit A2).(c)Section 37 T-Documents, labelled T1-T44, comprising pages 1-547 (Exhibit R1). (d)Briefing letter to Dr Anthony Cairns dated 18 October 2022 (Exhibit R2).(e)Report of Dr Anthony Cairns dated 22 December 2022 (Exhibit R3).(f)Briefing letter to Dr Jonathan Spear dated 20 April 2023 (Exhibit R4).(g)Report of Dr Jonathan Spear dated 9 May 2023 (Exhibit R5).After the hearing On 15 November 2023, I made directions for written closing submissions to be lodged. I issued other directions amending that direction on 27 November 2023 and 18 December 2023. I thought that written closing submissions would be the fairest option so that Mrs Lombardini and Mr West, who are not legally trained, would have time to consider the evidence and submissions from the hearing and to consider their response. Both parties were agreeable to the filing of written closing submissions. In addition to the evidence listed above, the Respondent lodged a Summons Bundle which consisted of 877 pages. Due to the large number of pages, I marked the Summons Bundle as a provisional Exhibit R6 and included a direction in the 15 November 2023 Direction that the Respondent was to file a consolidated Summons Bundle on or before 4 December 2023. This was to replace the Summons Bundle with a more concise bundle containing the documents that the parties intended to rely upon. Consequently, the Respondent lodged the following documents which will replace the provisional Exhibit R6:(a)Consolidated Summons Bundle indexed 1 to 21 and comprising pages 1 to 35.(b)Consolidated Summons Bundle Volume 2 indexed 1 to 2 and comprising pages 36 to 39. I thank the Respondent for organising these Consolidated Summons Bundles. Written closing submissions were received on 5 December 2023 for the Applicant and 22 December 2023 for the Respondent. LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Division 4 of Part II of the VEA sets out how the rates of pensions payable to veterans are to be determined. All references to legislative provisions below are references to the VEA. Application for an increase in pension As I mentioned above, Mrs Lombardini is receiving a pension at the general rate and has applied for an increase in her pension to the special rate of pension. Under s 15(1), a veteran who is in receipt of a pension may apply for an increase in the rate of pension:A veteran who is in receipt of a pension under this Part in respect of the incapacity of the veteran may apply, in accordance with subsection (3) of this section, for an increase in the rate of the pension on the ground that the incapacity of the veteran has increased since the rate of the pension was assessed or last assessed.Special rate of pension Section 24 sets out the eligibility criteria for the special rate of pension.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Reviewable Decision that Mrs Lombardini is seeking review of is a decision of the Veterans’ Review Board (VRB) dated 25 May 2021, which affirmed a determination dated 15 October 2020 to continue Mrs Lombardini’s pension at 100% of the general rate (T1.1). The issue that I must determine is whether Mrs Lombardini is entitled to an increase in her disability pension from 100% of the general rate to the intermediate rate or the special rate under s 23 or 24 of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (VEA). For the reasons set out below, I have decided that Mrs Lombardini satisfies the eligibility criteria in s 24(1) of the VEA for an increase to the special rate of pension.BACKGROUND Mrs Lombardini has prior accepted claims (T23.1/167) for the conditions of:·“sprain of the right elbow”, effective from 3 February 1977 under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation (Defence-related Claims) Act 1988 (Cth); and·“tinea of the skin” and “bilateral sensorineural hearing loss”, both effective from 25 April 2016. On 8 April 2019, Mrs Lombardini made a claim for disability pension and an application for an increase to disability pension for several claimed conditions (T9) and submitted a lifestyle questionnaire (T10). On 7 January 2020, a delegate of the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (Department) decided to accept Mrs Lombardini’s claims for “Right elbow osteoarthritis, Left knee osteoarthritis, Lumbar spondylosis, and major depressive disorder with effect from 08 January 2019”. The delegate increased the rate of Mrs Lombardini’s pension under the VEA from 40% to 100% of the general rate (T19.1/141). On 3 May 2020, Mrs Lombardini’s advocate sought review of that pension assessment (T20/152; T20.1). That application for review was dismissed by the VRB on 21 August 2020 because it was out of time (T24.1/263). On 1 October 2020 Mrs Lombardini made another application for an increase in her disability pension (T26) and submitted a lifestyle questionnaire. This application referred to the disability being an “Increase in Disability Major Depression Disorder”, with the “signs and symptoms” listed as “mobility” and the “basis for the diagnosis” being an enclosed report from psychiatrist, Dr James Fellows-Smith (T26/273). In her application form Mrs Lombardini also stated that she ceased work in a childcare centre on 7 November 2016 with the reason for ceasing work stated as “Mobility/ Major Depression Disorder” (T26/276-277). On 15 October 2020, a delegate of the Respondent decided to refuse an increase to the Special Rate (the Determination) (T30.2) on the basis that: Given the extensive time you have spent outside of the workforce, and that you have not been genuinely seeking employment, I am satisfied that it is not your accepted VEA disabilities “alone” that are preventing you from working” (T30.2/299). This meant that Mrs Lombardini’s disability pension continued at 100% of the general rate with effect from 15 October 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.