|
BRISBANE
22 MARCH 1996
Re: Determination of unimproved value -
Application for Conversion of Tenure -
Land Act 1962
Special Lease No: 22/50584, Herberton District
Lessee: James S. Lockyer
(Hearing at Atherton)
D E C I S I O N
Mr Lockyer made application for conversion of tenure of this lease on 1st September, 1994. It is at that date when the unimproved value of the land is required to be determined.
The land is described as Lot 804 on Plan H25335, Parish of Herberton, and contains an area of 4.0469 ha. It is situated fronting Alma Road, about 3.5 kilometres east of Wondecla. Alma Road is gravel formed off Bradlaugh Road which is also gravel formed to the bitumen sealed Rolley Road. Electricity is capable of extension, at the applicant's cost, from Bradlaugh Road. Telephone has been connected. Apart from rainwater storage, a private water supply line has been laid from an external source to a property on the opposite side of Alma Road. The lessee of the subject land, Mr Lockyer, is a part owner with other family members, of that property opposite. An extension of that water supply has been laid to the subject property.
The land is zoned "Rural". It comprises grey sandy loam and partly granite soils and is gently sloping. The highest and best use of the land is as a rural residential homesite.
On the basis of its highest and best use, the Minister determined the unimproved value at the relevant date in the amount of $40.000. That determination was the valuation of Mr R.G. Moroney, registered valuer with the Lands Department. His basis of valuation was a comparison with three sales of rural residential sites in the locality. Brief details of those sales are as follows:
(1)Lot 4, Zinglemann Road, 2.058 ha, zoned "Rural Residential", sold in January 1994, for $48,000, showing an analysed unimproved value of $46,530. A creek formed the rear boundary of the sale site which Mr Moroney considered to be superior to the subject land.
(2)Lot 34, Wieland Road, 5.76 ha, zoned "Rural", sold in February 1994, for $50,000 as unimproved land. There was no natural water source and electricity mains were about 200 metres distant. Mr Moroney's evidence was that this site was very similar to the subject land and superior mainly because of the larger area.
(3)Lot 4, Chester Road, 1.537 ha, zoned "Rural Residential", sold in April 1994, for $41,500, showing an analysed unimproved value of $37,500. Mr Moroney had considered that site to be slightly inferior to the subject land.
Mr Lockyer submitted that the unimproved value of the subject land should have been $27,500. His basis of assessment was in some way related to the conditions of the lease. He saw it as unfair that the land should be described as having an external water supply when that was a private line constructed to a pump site on a creek some distance removed. He was concerned that if…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lockyer v Minister for Lands and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] QLC 29
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was the determination of the unimproved value of the land as at the date of application for conversion of tenure. The Court was required to decide whether the valuation of $40,000 by Mr Moroney was fair and reasonable, and whether the conditions of the lease or the concerns of Lockyer regarding the external water supply should influence this valuation. The Court also needed to clarify the scope of its task in determining the unimproved value, which is to assess the land as if it was held in fee simple, independent of any lease conditions.
The Court found that the valuation provided by Mr Moroney was soundly based and that nothing presented during the hearing undermined his evidence. The Court accepted that while the external water supply was a private improvement, it was still a potentiality that the land possessed in its unimproved state. The Court emphasised that its task was not to consider the conditions of the lease, but to determine the unimproved value of the land. Consequently, the Court upheld the valuation of $40,000 as fair and reasonable. The unimproved value of the subject land was therefore determined to be Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000) as at the date of application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi